This book examines the phenomenon of the Taiwanese New Cinema via a close study of four of its directors -- Ang Lee, Edward Yang, Hou Hsiao-hsien and Tsai Ming-liang. Both authors have published books before on Asian film. Emilie Yueh-yu Yeh lectures on the topic at Hong Kong Baptist University, while Darrell William Davis teaches the it at the University of New South Wales, Sydney.
Taiwanese New Cinema is perceived as having begun in 1982. Today, argue the authors, we are in a "post-New Cinema" phase. Even though the key New Cinema directors are still making movies, these find audiences largely at foreign film festivals, and financing often from foreign agencies.
In their introduction the authors represent Taiwan as, among other things, an "island of greed." The book's subtitle is "A Treasure Island," and Yeh and Davis point out that it was seen by early European explorers as a lawless and marginal place that could be pillaged with impunity as it belonged to no one except fishermen and head-hunters. It has since become a site for "a procession of would-be owners claiming legitimacy." Their general remarks on Taiwan, it should be said, are among the best things in an excellent book.
The big four
First Yeh and Davis offer two excellent long chapters on Taiwanese film in general, then examine the technical aspects of the sophisticated films of Edward Yang, take the films of Hou Hsiao-hsien ("Taiwan's preeminent director") as representative of the evolution of Taiwan cinema as a whole, and look at Ang Lee's attempts to, as they put it, "Confucianize" Hollywood.
I am insufficiently familiar with Taiwanese films to assess the value of all aspects of Taiwan Film Directors: a Treasure Island equally. But I do have some knowledge of Tsai Ming-liang's movies, and so will consider the chapter devoted to him in more detail.
The author responsible for this chapter takes the idea of "camp" as his or her guiding principle. (The division of work between the two writers is nowhere detailed, but it seems unlikely that they wrote all the chapters in equal collaboration). On the surface, this seems inappropriate to this director's controversial, repetitive, yet nonetheless often striking work. The theme running through such films as What Time Is It There?, Goodbye, Dragon Inn and The Wayward Cloud appears to be the progressive loss of the capacity for human feeling, especially love, in the context of the modern city. That the films are to be understood as a progression is underlined by the use of the same lead actor, Lee Kang-sheng, in many of them, as well as cross-references between the films and the consistent, often over-obvious, use of the same symbolic images, notably lifts, underpasses, public toilets and, most extensively, water.
First came an impossible love for someone who was going away, then a drifting world of casual sexual encounters, then recruitment into an active role in porn movies, all culminating in the extraordinary concluding sequence of The Wayward Cloud where Lee, copulating with a catatonic woman during the making of a pornographic sequence, finally achieves satisfaction with the body of another woman, the one who really loves him. The over-riding need for love in the human heart, and yet the comparative honesty of those who respond to modern urban conditions by seeking it only in the most oblique of ways, are surely the twin themes of this highly individual director's work.
RSS