Mon, May 17, 2004 - Page 16 News List

Nuclear waste train splits a Nevada town

A firebrand mayor welcomes the waste as a generator of jobs, but his detractors see mortal danger in the cargo

NY TIMES NEWS SERVICE , CALIENTE, NEVADA

A Union Pacific freight train passes through Caliente, Nevada. Caliente's mayor Kevin Phillips, not pictured, is the chief proponent for a rail route for nuclear waste. Phillips, who owns a local hardware store, has volunteered Caliente, population 1,200, to be the transfer station for the US' spent nuclear fuel that is supposed to be stored in a nearby repository beginning in 2010.

PHOTO: NY TIMES

This used to be a railroad town with a dozen tracks and a dozen bars and a lot of jobs.

But then the railroad company decided it did not need Caliente anymore. Now, instead of stopping, the freight trains barrel through the middle of town.

Most of the bars are closed, and storefronts on the main street are boarded up, but Mayor Kevin Phillips has figured out a way to lift the fortunes of his struggling hamlet tucked in the mountains about 200km north of Las Vegas. Nuclear waste.

Phillips, 53, who owns a local hardware store, has volunteered Caliente, population 1,200, to be the transfer station for the nation's spent nuclear fuel that is supposed to be stored in the Yucca Mountain repository beginning in 2010.

Though the repository plan has run into stiff opposition in Nevada, Phillips' idea has supporters, including the federal government, which announced in April that it wanted to run a train through here to carry the waste to its final resting place.

"It would be absolutely safe, with the proper training, and it would bring jobs that we sorely need," said Phillips, who walks around town with a tape measure on his belt. "We rural people don't get all watery-eyed about this kind of thing."

Phillips, who earns US$190.40 a month as mayor, has become a political lightning rod in the national nuclear waste disposal debate.

Not one major politician in Nevada supports the Yucca Mountain plan, and the "Glow Train" plan, as it is called around here, has split this tiny town down the middle.

Marge Detraz is the mayor's archnemesis, and the person responsible for the "No Nukes" signs on trees and fences around town. Detraz, a 77-year-old widow who offers strangers brownies with nuts, figures she has spent US$125,000 of her own money battling the mayor and the federal government over the train. She and her husband earned that money working at the nuclear test site where the waste is to be stored.

She is a fixture in the local Mormon church, which Phillips also attends. She considers him a good, spiritual man and compliments him on his skin-tingling oratory. But when it comes to the train, her invective for her neighbor is stinging, referring to him as corrupt, tyrannical and an unwitting tool of forces more powerful than himself.

"If they bring that train in with that nuclear waste, it has the potential to kill all of us," Detraz said. "I mean, the tracks run straight through the middle of town. And the mayor thinks he's going to save Lincoln County with that thing? He's crazy."

Phillips is philosophical about the criticism. "This is no launch pad into senatorial politics, I'll tell you that," he said.

Nukes mean jobs -- maybe 100, maybe 300 -- and Phillips, father of 10, is tired of seeing Caliente children graduate from high school and move down the hill to Las Vegas to find a living. Handled correctly, nuclear waste can be as safe to handle as household garbage, he said.

"What's the picking difference?" asked Phillips. "The government is going to put a rail system in anyway, so why shouldn't we benefit?"

Caliente is on a main line of the Union Pacific Railroad. Dozens of hazardous material shipments come through every day, the mayor said, and there has never been a major accident.

"It's just 50 yards out my front door," he said. "It could take out the whole town, but no one ever complains about that."

This story has been viewed 3645 times.
TOP top