A campaign to remove statues of Chiang Kai-shek (蔣介石) has been going on for many years. Although it has to some extent succeeded, there is still a long way to go, given that Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall continues to tower over Taipei.
Interestingly, a movement to remove statues and achieve transitional justice is also taking place in the US, that great democratic nation. This movement comes more than 100 years after the related historical events, and its main target is statues commemorating General Robert E. Lee.
Rising tensions between black and white people in recent years have led people to reconsider the myth of Lee.
As far as his military achievements are concerned, Lee was not the greatest of Confederate generals nor was his character or beliefs particularly remarkable. After surrendering to the Union, apart from accepting the abolition of slavery, in which he had no choice, Lee’s opinion of black people did not change much.
When he was invited to testify before a congressional committee, he strongly advocated keeping the South’s economic conditions as they had been, and he opposed giving black people the right to vote.
Despite this, the political considerations of northern and southern politicians led to him being highly praised and elevated to an important symbol of reconciliation between the north and south.
However, that meant reconciliation between southern whites and northern whites, not between black and white, still less between former slaves and former slave owners.
Lee’s heroic image is now crumbling, and the memorials that were erected to him have become politically incorrect edifices that many people see as eyesores.
In May, New Orleans removed a statue of Lee that had quite a long history. At the beginning of this year, the Charlottesville City Council in Virginia decided to remove its memorial to Lee, and in June it resolved to change the name of the park where the statue was located from Lee Park to Emancipation Park.
Unsurprisingly, these moves were met with protests from far-right groups, who converged for demonstrations, which turned into a bloody terrorist attack in which three people were killed and many others were injured.
This issue has become the focus of attention nationwide and a hot topic for commentators, especially after remarks by US President Donald Trump that poured oil onto the flames.
Following the incident, Charlottesville authorities covered the Lee memorial with a black tarpaulin in mourning for the dead. The city council has been very cautious, doing its best not to cause even bigger clashes.
However, some people still asked why it did not cover the statue until more than a week after the incident. The city council said that it could not find a big-enough tarpaulin right away.
The council’s concerns were quite reasonable, but after the statue was covered, white supremacist groups descended on the area again. Gunshots were heard, and it looked as though the tense situation could spin out of control.
Following the clash at Charlottesville, the trend of removing memorials to Lee and other Confederate generals has become unstoppable. Statues of Lee have been removed from the University of Texas, Duke University in North Carolina, Wyman Park in Baltimore and in other places, with more likely to be removed as time goes by.
Who would have thought that in the US, which has never had a dictatorship, statues of Lee would be pulled down amid curses from the public, just as has happened to those of Joseph Stalin, General Francisco Franco and General Augusto Pinochet.
Even though Lee was not a real hero, neither was he an extremely wicked person. He was just a defeated general who was used for political propaganda to promote reconciliation between two groups of white people.
Stranger yet is what is happening in Taipei. The Generalissimo no doubt ranks high among the wicked, but visitors from China are keen to pay their respects at Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall.
Perhaps that is a kind of reconciliation, but it is reconciliation between one group of Chinese and another. It is a reconciliation that tramples on Taiwanese.
When people carrying China’s five-star red flag shout and curse at Taiwanese, it is just like far-right neo-Nazis in the US shouting and cursing while waving the Confederate flag.
Such rude provocations amount to telling Taiwanese to keep quiet about their history.
The continued presence of Chiang statues is a symptom of this oppression. Maybe we could learn something from Charlottesville by covering the offending statues with big, black tarpaulins before deciding their final fate.
Li Chung-chih is a professor at Illinois State University and president of the North America Taiwanese Professors’ Association.
Translated by Julian Clegg
Because much of what former US president Donald Trump says is unhinged and histrionic, it is tempting to dismiss all of it as bunk. Yet the potential future president has a populist knack for sounding alarums that resonate with the zeitgeist — for example, with growing anxiety about World War III and nuclear Armageddon. “We’re a failing nation,” Trump ranted during his US presidential debate against US Vice President Kamala Harris in one particularly meandering answer (the one that also recycled urban myths about immigrants eating cats). “And what, what’s going on here, you’re going to end up in World War
Earlier this month in Newsweek, President William Lai (賴清德) challenged the People’s Republic of China (PRC) to retake the territories lost to Russia in the 19th century rather than invade Taiwan. He stated: “If it is for the sake of territorial integrity, why doesn’t [the PRC] take back the lands occupied by Russia that were signed over in the treaty of Aigun?” This was a brilliant political move to finally state openly what many Chinese in both China and Taiwan have long been thinking about the lost territories in the Russian far east: The Russian far east should be “theirs.” Granted, Lai issued
On Tuesday, President William Lai (賴清德) met with a delegation from the Hoover Institution, a think tank based at Stanford University in California, to discuss strengthening US-Taiwan relations and enhancing peace and stability in the region. The delegation was led by James Ellis Jr, co-chair of the institution’s Taiwan in the Indo-Pacific Region project and former commander of the US Strategic Command. It also included former Australian minister for foreign affairs Marise Payne, influential US academics and other former policymakers. Think tank diplomacy is an important component of Taiwan’s efforts to maintain high-level dialogue with other nations with which it does
On Sept. 2, Elbridge Colby, former deputy assistant secretary of defense for strategy and force development, wrote an article for the Wall Street Journal called “The US and Taiwan Must Change Course” that defends his position that the US and Taiwan are not doing enough to deter the People’s Republic of China (PRC) from taking Taiwan. Colby is correct, of course: the US and Taiwan need to do a lot more or the PRC will invade Taiwan like Russia did against Ukraine. The US and Taiwan have failed to prepare properly to deter war. The blame must fall on politicians and policymakers