Fri, Oct 28, 2011 - Page 9 News List

Asian giants collide at sea

Chinese activity in Pakistan and Myanmar, the expansion of China’s port agreements in the Indian Ocean and heightened Chinese naval activity in the Indian Ocean have jangled India’s security antennas

By Jaswant Singh

Illustration: Mountain People

Even in an age of 24-hour globalized news, some important events only come to light well after the fact. Something of this sort happened several months ago in the South China Sea and it may shape how relations between the world’s two most populous countries, China and India, develop in the years ahead.

While returning in late July from a goodwill visit to Vietnam in waters recognized as international, an Indian naval ship was “hailed” on open radio and advised to “lay off” the South China Sea. Although naval incidents between China and its near neighbors — particularly Vietnam, Japan and the Philippines — are not unusual, this is the first one to involve India.

Why did China attempt to interfere with a ship sailing in open seas? Was this “merely” another of China’s unwarranted assertions of sovereignty over the whole South China Sea, or was something more malevolent afoot?

At the Chinese Foreign Ministry, a spokesperson explained: “We are opposed to any country engaging in oil and gas exploration or development activities in waters under China’s jurisdiction.”

Then he added: “Countries outside the region, we hope ... will respect and support countries in the region” in their efforts “to solve ... disputes through bilateral channels.”

India’s government responded promptly.

“Our cooperation with Vietnam or any other country is always as per international laws, norms and conventions,” it said, stating that “cooperation with Vietnam in the area of energy is very important.”

Indeed, Indian companies have already invested heavily in the region and they are seeking to expand their operations.

Although India’s statement is explicit enough, doubts persist.

Is the argument merely about who will develop the South China Sea’s untapped energy resources, or are we dealing with the beginning of a struggle for spheres of influence?

To find an answer requires confronting civilizational norms, which are reflected in the intellectual games that the countries favor.

India has traditionally favored the game of chaupad (four sides) or shatranj (chess), concentrating on contest, conquest and subjugation. China, on the other hand, has wei qi (go), which focuses on strategic encirclement.

As the Chinese strategist Sun Tzu (孫子) advised thousands of years ago: “Ultimate excellence lies ... not in winning every battle, but in defeating the enemy, without ever fighting.”

A recent US Department of Defense paper, China’s Military and Security Developments 2011, argued that “China’s ‘near sea’ politics has seriously disturbed not only India, but Japan, Australia, the US and the ASEAN countries.”

In response, the Chinese Defense Ministry said: “China and India are not enemies, not opponents, but neighbors and partners.”

So where do things stand?

It is clear that India, given its years of cooperation with Vietnam on oil and gas development, is not about to acquiesce to China’s claim over the South China Sea. Moreover, as energy extraction begins, a new memorandum of understanding between India and Vietnam is scheduled to be signed later this year.

China was most likely reacting to these developments by accusing India of violating its territorial waters. For India, the sense that a struggle for regional mastery is occurring has become increasingly keen.

Chinese activity in Pakistan and Myanmar, the expansion of China’s port agreements in the Indian Ocean (the so-called “string of pearls”) and heightened Chinese naval activity in the Indian Ocean have jangled India’s security antennas.

This story has been viewed 3601 times.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top