I must largely agree with Chang Sheng-en's (
But I feel that there is more to this issue than is immediately apparent from the statistical analysis of examination results. As a very experienced Australian teacher who has visited my wonderful family in Taiwan many times, I have noted several things about Taiwanese English speakers -- both young and old.
First, through vocal emulation of their teachers, students develop a US accent. This accent in all its forms, from "deep South" origins to the Canadian border, is often difficult for other English speaking people in the world to understand. Naturally students learn by imitating their teachers, but the difference between strongly-accented vowel sounds (as in the US "drawl") and standard, non-colloquial and non-idiomatic written text can cause confusion in an exam situation.
Second, it is necessary to practise conversational and grammatically "correct" English frequently to develop a proficiency in the language. Students need to be immersed in English language and culture to learn it effectively. Unlike Hong Kong, Malaysia, Singapore and India, Taiwan does not have a residual colonial English culture. English for Taiwanese is as difficult to learn as Chinese is for Westerners.
The English language teaching programs on television and radio are full of heavily-accented US content, and some of the teachers speak rapidly and often leap from topic to topic with little continuity or repetition, and with no visual or contextual cues.
Furthermore, popular US television shows shown in Taiwan are also heavily accented, very idiomatic and the speech is far too rapid -- comments often made about Americans in general.
I feel that all of these combined can present unreasonable and daunting obstacles to students' learning.
I note that many English teaching jobs advertised in Taiwan state that a "North American accent" is preferred, presumably for perceived status, cultural and economic reasons.
But surely, if students are to have some competency in spoken and written English, then exposure to "neutrally accented" teachers is preferable.
English can be a strongly accented language, and even I, a "neutrally accented" Australian with many years of teaching experience, have difficulty understanding not only US English, but also South African, Indian, Scot and Irish-accented English.
Selection of teachers and teaching models should be based not only on qualifications, but on the ability to speak clear and non idiomatic English.
Geoffrey Cartridge
Adelaide, Australia
The Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) has its chairperson election tomorrow. Although the party has long positioned itself as “China friendly,” the election is overshadowed by “an overwhelming wave of Chinese intervention.” The six candidates vying for the chair are former Taipei mayor Hau Lung-bin (郝龍斌), former lawmaker Cheng Li-wen (鄭麗文), Legislator Luo Chih-chiang (羅智強), Sun Yat-sen School president Chang Ya-chung (張亞中), former National Assembly representative Tsai Chih-hong (蔡志弘) and former Changhua County comissioner Zhuo Bo-yuan (卓伯源). While Cheng and Hau are front-runners in different surveys, Hau has complained of an online defamation campaign against him coming from accounts with foreign IP addresses,
Former Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) lawmaker Cheng Li-wun (鄭麗文) on Saturday won the party’s chairperson election with 65,122 votes, or 50.15 percent of the votes, becoming the second woman in the seat and the first to have switched allegiance from the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) to the KMT. Cheng, running for the top KMT position for the first time, had been termed a “dark horse,” while the biggest contender was former Taipei mayor Hau Lung-bin (郝龍斌), considered by many to represent the party’s establishment elite. Hau also has substantial experience in government and in the KMT. Cheng joined the Wild Lily Student
When Taiwan High Speed Rail Corp (THSRC) announced the implementation of a new “quiet carriage” policy across all train cars on Sept. 22, I — a classroom teacher who frequently takes the high-speed rail — was filled with anticipation. The days of passengers videoconferencing as if there were no one else on the train, playing videos at full volume or speaking loudly without regard for others finally seemed numbered. However, this battle for silence was lost after less than one month. Faced with emotional guilt from infants and anxious parents, THSRC caved and retreated. However, official high-speed rail data have long
Taipei stands as one of the safest capital cities the world. Taiwan has exceptionally low crime rates — lower than many European nations — and is one of Asia’s leading democracies, respected for its rule of law and commitment to human rights. It is among the few Asian countries to have given legal effect to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the International Covenant of Social Economic and Cultural Rights. Yet Taiwan continues to uphold the death penalty. This year, the government has taken a number of regressive steps: Executions have resumed, proposals for harsher prison sentences
RSS