Since 2001, Lee Zimmerman's Evergreen Lodge has helped almost 60 low-income young adults get their lives on track, while consistently paying 9 percent back to investors backing his business. Pura Vida Coffee, of which John Sage was a co-founder in 1997, has generated US$2.7 million in cash and resources for health and education programs for children and their families.
Both companies deserve praise for their good deeds. But what might be more remarkable about the founders of Pura Vida and Evergreen Lodge is the way they raised capital to build businesses that have two bottom lines: one financial and one social.
Such business models are becoming increasingly popular among philanthropists and foundations, which like the idea of self-sustaining charities. They also want their investments to have the same kind of social impact as their donations, an idea called mission-related, or program-related, investing.
PHOTO: NY TIMES NEWS SERVICE
A study released earlier this year by FSG Social Impact Advisors, a consultancy founded by Michael Porter, a Harvard Business School professor, and Mark Kramer, a former venture capitalist, calculated that mission-related investing has grown 16.2 percent a year over the last five years.
At the same time, businesses like Pura Vida and Evergreen blur the line between charities and companies. That's a hurdle to raising money, because investing in a for-profit company does not yield a tax deduction. And such businesses often need extra time to succeed.
Grameen Bank, which won the Nobel Peace Prize last year for validating the idea of microfinance, was subsidized for 15 years, notes J. Gregory Dees, a professor at the Fuqua School of Business at Duke University. (Last year, Grameen made US$20 million on US$135 million in revenue.)
There is not yet a template for financing such businesses, says R. Todd Johnson, a lawyer at Jones Day who has handled a number of deals for social entrepreneurs and is writing a book to be called Greed Is Bad.
Because the entrepreneurs want to make sure that investors can't change the social mission for the sake of profits, "you get these one-off, crazy, debt-equity weird structures," he says. "People say, `Gosh, you're making my head hurt.'"
Sage's efforts to fund Pura Vida show just how migraine-inducing these deals can be. He set up Pura Vida Coffee as a for-profit company, earmarking all profits for its nonprofit arm. To raise money the first time and to allow Pura Vida to accept grants, he created the nonprofit organization, Pura Vida Partners, which became the owner of Pura Vida Coffee.
Pura Vida Partners issued US$1.8 million in interest-paying bonds, each of which would, when paid off, convert into a warrant for a share in the parent organization. Shareholders were required to donate dividends to a charity but couldn't claim that as a tax deduction.
The structure of the deal wound up biting Sage, as it tied his hands early on. Pura Vida grew faster than he expected, in part because its mission struck a chord with college students. The company needed money to buy new equipment and supplies, but interest payments were eating up all its cash.
Led by Sage, the largest debtholder, 18 of the 19 other investors agreed to restructure their debt into common stock that would dilute their holdings from 60 percent of Pura Vida Partners to 12 percent and to allow the company to create preferred stock, which it sold to raise more capital.
It was thus similar to a typical private offering, but with a twist: The common shares -- held by those original investors focused on the mission -- are the only ones with voting rights, to insulate the social goals of the company. Freshly capitalized, Pura Vida eventually was able to fund growth from its operations. It's on track to make a net profit next year.
The contrast between Sage's financing experience and that of Zimmerman and his co-founders suggests that a simple and traditional financing structure makes the most sense for businesses that are considered socially responsible.
Evergreen Lodge, just outside of Yosemite National Park, hires promising young people from low-income areas. The three co-founders believed that they could give these people a foundation for more stable lives by putting them in a rural environment with a full-time "counselor" who paid close attention to their needs.
Evergreen Lodge's holding company -- First Light Destinations -- raised money through a conventional debt-equity financing, in which a third of its money came in the form of equity from investors and two-thirds from a bank loan. Its results have been strong enough that First Light has paid dividends to its investors for the last two years. It also has in place a provision allowing it to issue debt in the future to pay back investors the full amount of their original investment, without requiring them to give up their shares. That allows its investors to get a good financial return on their investment without having to push for the company to go public or be acquired.
Zimmerman and his partners and their investors are still refining the model. However, he's excited that the basic model has worked, and he says that "what we're trying to do can be applied to many different kinds of businesses."
If he's right, the timing is excellent. Billions of dollars could soon start flowing to social entrepreneurs, especially from foundations.
Recently, the Annie E. Casey Foundation, the F.B. Heron Foundation and the Meyer Memorial Trust called on all the nation's foundations to invest 2 percent of their endowments into such organizations. If answered, that call would bring an estimated US$10 billion into the social investing realm over the next five years.
Dees at Duke cautions that there still aren't well-developed market mechanisms for double-bottom-line investors. But he called what's happening on the financing side of Pura Vida and Evergreen Lodge "extremely exciting" and said he thinks that "these kinds of companies will make headway against serious social problems."
Sage calls it compassionate capitalism, while stating the obvious: If the capitalism doesn't work, there will be no compassion.
MORE VISITORS: The Tourism Administration said that it is seeing positive prospects in its efforts to expand the tourism market in North America and Europe Taiwan has been ranked as the cheapest place in the world to travel to this year, based on a list recommended by NerdWallet. The San Francisco-based personal finance company said that Taiwan topped the list of 16 nations it chose for budget travelers because US tourists do not need visas and travelers can easily have a good meal for less than US$10. A bus ride in Taipei costs just under US$0.50, while subway rides start at US$0.60, the firm said, adding that public transportation in Taiwan is easy to navigate. The firm also called Taiwan a “food lover’s paradise,” citing inexpensive breakfast stalls
TRADE: A mandatory declaration of origin for manufactured goods bound for the US is to take effect on May 7 to block China from exploiting Taiwan’s trade channels All products manufactured in Taiwan and exported to the US must include a signed declaration of origin starting on May 7, the Bureau of Foreign Trade announced yesterday. US President Donald Trump on April 2 imposed a 32 percent tariff on imports from Taiwan, but one week later announced a 90-day pause on its implementation. However, a universal 10 percent tariff was immediately applied to most imports from around the world. On April 12, the Trump administration further exempted computers, smartphones and semiconductors from the new tariffs. In response, President William Lai’s (賴清德) administration has introduced a series of countermeasures to support affected
CROSS-STRAIT: The vast majority of Taiwanese support maintaining the ‘status quo,’ while concern is rising about Beijing’s influence operations More than eight out of 10 Taiwanese reject Beijing’s “one country, two systems” framework for cross-strait relations, according to a survey released by the Mainland Affairs Council (MAC) on Thursday. The MAC’s latest quarterly survey found that 84.4 percent of respondents opposed Beijing’s “one country, two systems” formula for handling cross-strait relations — a figure consistent with past polling. Over the past three years, opposition to the framework has remained high, ranging from a low of 83.6 percent in April 2023 to a peak of 89.6 percent in April last year. In the most recent poll, 82.5 percent also rejected China’s
PLUGGING HOLES: The amendments would bring the legislation in line with systems found in other countries such as Japan and the US, Legislator Chen Kuan-ting said Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) Legislator Chen Kuan-ting (陳冠廷) has proposed amending national security legislation amid a spate of espionage cases. Potential gaps in security vetting procedures for personnel with access to sensitive information prompted him to propose the amendments, which would introduce changes to Article 14 of the Classified National Security Information Protection Act (國家機密保護法), Chen said yesterday. The proposal, which aims to enhance interagency vetting procedures and reduce the risk of classified information leaks, would establish a comprehensive security clearance system in Taiwan, he said. The amendment would require character and loyalty checks for civil servants and intelligence personnel prior to