Two of the world's biggest brand names, known for wooing customers around the world, are facing a credibility crisis in one of their crucial emerging markets.
This month, India's Center for Science and the Environment announced that drinks manufactured by Coca-Cola and PepsiCo contained on average more than 24 times the safe limit for pesticides, which could come from sugar, water and other ingredients.
When those reports appeared on the front pages of newspapers in India, Coke and Pepsi executives expressed confidence that they could handle the situation, but they have stumbled since.
PHOTO: AP
They underestimated how quickly events would spiral into a nationwide scandal, misjudged the speed with which local politicians would seize on an Indian environmental group's report to attack their global brands, and did not respond swiftly to quell the anxieties of their customers.
Three weeks later, Coke and Pepsi are still struggling to win back the confidence of consumers. Partial bans on their products remain in a quarter of India's states, and a complex legal battle to overturn the bans is just beginning. The companies acknowledge that things have not gone smoothly.
The battle offers a cautionary tale for multinational corporations doing business in developing countries, especially one like India, where the market for soft drinks is about US$1.6 billion, with Coke holding about a 60 percent market share.
PHOTO: AP
In some ways, the immediate response from Coke and Pepsi came right out of crisis management textbooks.
The companies formed committees in India and the US, working in tandem on legal and public relations issues. They worked around the clock fashioning rebuttals. They commissioned their own laboratories to conduct tests and waited until the results came through before commenting in detail.
Their approaches backfired. Their reluctance to give details fanned consumer suspicion. They became bogged down in the technicalities of the charges instead of focusing on winning back the support of their customers.
"They got behind the curve, and now they are chasing the crisis," said Richard Levick, president and chief executive of Levick Strategic Communications, which is based in the US and specializes in advising businesses in crises.
Coke and Pepsi executives have said repeatedly that their soft drinks meet "international standards" but concede this is a difficult fight.
"We have some way to go to restore consumer confidence in our brands," said Kari Bjorhus, Coca-Cola's communications director.
Rajeev Bakshi, chairman of PepsiCo India, agreed. "Has our side of the story got across to the consumer yet? Not really. I am concerned about that."
On Tuesday, the companies got a lift with the publication of a study by India's health ministry that said the Center for Science and Environment's findings did not conclusively prove that the soft drinks contained pesticide residue.
The center, however, was skeptical. "The minister of health is clearly more concerned with industrial health -- and not people's health," it said in a statement.
At the start, both companies were unprepared, when one state after another in India announced partial bans on Coke and Pepsi products, preventing the drinks from being sold in government offices, hospitals, and schools. Politicians exploited the populist potential.
"We were a little surprised and disappointed by the bans," said Kenth Kaerhoeg, group communications director for Coca-Cola Asia, who flew in from Hong Kong to work on the situation.
Suhel Seth, a public relations expert in India and an adviser to Coca-Cola India, said Coke and Pepsi should have known better: "Fringe politicians will continue to be publicly hostile to big Western companies, regardless of how eager they are for their investment," he said.
In hindsight, Bjorhus, the Coke communications director, said she could now see how the environmental group had picked Coca-Cola as a way of attracting attention to the broader problem of pesticide contamination in Indian food products.
Sunita Narain, who heads the group, "has serious concerns about pesticides in the food chain," Bjorhus said.
"By focusing her attention on the soft drinks industry, she gets a lot of attention," she said.
Failing to anticipate the political potency of the incident, Coke and Pepsi initially hoped that the crisis would blow over and they adopted a policy of silence.
"Here people interpret silence as guilt," said Seth, the Indian public relations expert.
"You have to roll up your sleeves and get into a street fight. Coke and Pepsi didn't understand that," he said.
The companies also failed to realize how fast news travels in modern India.
"We are living in a new, very aware India," said Amit Agnihotri, a public relations analyst in Delhi.
"We have 36 news channels. People are interested in what is happening around them. Coke and Pepsi haven't understood the power of this new India," he said.
Coca-Cola eventually decided to go on the attack, though indirectly, giving detailed briefings by executives, who questioned the scientific credentials of their products' accusers.
The executives pointed reporters to Internet blogs full of entries that were uniformly pro-Coke and they handed out the phone number for the director of an organization called the Center for Sanity and Balance in Public Life.
Beijing’s continued provocations in the Taiwan Strait reveal its intention to unilaterally change the “status quo” in the area, the US Department of State said on Saturday, calling for a peaceful resolution to cross-strait issues. The Coast Guard Administration (CGA) reported that four China Coast Guard patrol vessels entered restricted and prohibited waters near Kinmen County on Friday and again on Saturday. A State Department spokesperson said that Washington was aware of the incidents, and urged all parties to exercise restraint and refrain from unilaterally changing the “status quo.” “Maintaining peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait is in line with our [the
EXTENDED RANGE: Hsiung Sheng missiles, 100 of which might be deployed by the end of the year, could reach Chinese command posts and airport runways, a source said A NT$16.9 billion (US$534.93 million) project to upgrade the military’s missile defense systems would be completed this year, allowing the deployment of at least 100 long-range Hsiung Sheng missiles and providing more deterrence against China, military sources said on Saturday. Hsiung Sheng missiles are an extended-range version of the Hsiung Feng IIE (HF-2E) surface-to-surface cruise missile, and are believed to have a range of up to 1,200km, which would allow them to hit targets well inside China. They went into mass production in 2022, the sources said. The project is part of a special budget for the Ministry of National Defense aimed at
READY TO WORK: Taiwan is eager to cooperate and is hopeful that like-minded states will continue to advocate for its inclusion in regional organizations, Lai said Maintaining the “status quo” in the Taiwan Strait, and peace and stability in the Indo-Pacific region must be a top priority, president-elect William Lai (賴清德) said yesterday after meeting with a delegation of US academics. Leaders of the G7, US President Joe Biden and other international heads of state have voiced concerns about the situation in the Strait, as stability in the region is necessary for a safe, peaceful and prosperous world, Lai said. The vice president, who is to be inaugurated in May, welcomed the delegation and thanked them for their support for Taiwan and issues concerning the Strait. The international community
COOPERATION: Two crewmembers from a Chinese fishing boat that sank off Kinmen were rescued, two were found dead and another two were still missing at press time The Coast Guard Administration (CGA) was yesterday working with Chinese rescuers to find two missing crewmembers from a Chinese fishing boat that sank southwest of Kinmen County yesterday, killing two crew. The joint operation managed to rescue two of the boat’s six crewmembers, but two were already dead when they were pulled from the water, the agency said in a statement. Rescuers are still searching for two others from the Min Long Yu 61222, a boat registered in China’s Fujian Province that capsized and sank 1.03 nautical miles (1.9km) southwest of Dongding Island (東碇), it added. CGA Director-General Chou Mei-wu (周美伍) told a