Beware of Swedes bearing lecture notes. So might be the watchword of Hakuo Yanagisawa, Japan's minister of financial services and a vigorous opponent of government intervention to solve his nation's banking crisis.
Tokyo's bureaucrats may have ramped the Japanese stock market with stunning success over the past month, and for this let us tip our caps. But as many a banking analyst has already pointed out, they have not averted a crisis in the banking sector. They have merely deferred the day of reckoning. The most likely way out of it remains public intervention, however little Yanagisawa-san and his colleagues wish to discuss it just now.
Let us tip our caps, then, to Bo Lundgren, for his timing could not be better. The current leader of Sweden's parliamentary opposition and a former minister for fiscal and financial affairs arrived in Tokyo in late February, just as the froth was rising in the share market, to tell the Japanese about the banking crisis he helped resolve a decade ago -- by way of public intervention.
I don't know whether Yanagisawa or anyone else in Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi's government heard or has read Lundgren's speech. But I'd wager they've weighed its substance carefully, given its striking relevance to Japan's predicament.
The speech is available through the Swedish Embassy in Tokyo; my copy came, with an astute commentary, via J. Brian Waterhouse, the Tokyo banking analyst at HSBC Securities.
Lundgren was a central figure in resolving the banking crisis that hit Sweden in the early 1990s. Sluggish and given to denial, the Japanese have already let pass some of his lessons -- be swift, be accountable. Nonetheless, as a blueprint from which to borrow, the Swedish solution as Lundgren outlines it offers the Japanese a chance to learn from the best kind of experience -- experience painfully acquired.
Sweden's crisis was not nearly as big as Japan's: troubled loans were 20 percent of outstanding credit, 12 percent of gross domestic product, compared with (by estimates other than those officially advanced in Tokyo) 20 to 25 percent of credit outstanding and not quite half of GDP.
But the similarities are many. Swedish banks got into trouble when a speculative bubble that inflated during the second half of the 1980s lost its air. Then property prices collapsed. The markets crashed, overexposed banks headed toward the wall, and the economy was imperiled.
Given that all this began in 1990, just as Japan's bubble started deflating, the divergence in responses in Stockholm and Tokyo adds piquancy to Lundgren's account.
Sweden took less than a year to commit itself to a solution once crisis conditions were identified in October 1991. Enabling legislation was in place six months after that. The Bank Support Authority, the politically independent body set up to manage the crisis, was an artifact of history by 1997. Six years, start to finish, and clean as a Nordic household.
It went like this. In the beginning was the word and the word was transparency. "A very important principle for the work was to be very open when accounting for the situation in the financial sector and in banks applying for support," Lundgren says. "This was essential to gain sufficient confidence from the outside world in a wide sense -- not least popular legitimacy." While the amount of capital required was unclear, an incorrect assessment carried the risk of damaged confidence: Too large a commitment, Lundgren says, "might be taken to imply that the banks were in much greater difficulty than had been acknowledged." Too small, and the agency would have had to go back for more money, "which could be seen as implying that the situation had not been under control." This latter is exactly the result Yanagisawa-san got in 1999, when he committed insufficient funds -- ?7.5 trillion, about US$57 billion -- to a bailout. In the end, Stockholm simply made an open-ended commitment to saving the nation's banks however much it took.
Then came the BSA, which enabled the government to avail itself of independent expertise and avoid potential conflicts of interest. The authority divided banks into three categories: long- term profitable with short-term problems; long-term profitable with uncertain capital-adequacy ratios and medium-term problems; basket cases likely to be beyond reconstruction.
These classifications allowed the BSA to decide quite easily how to handle each bank: Some might require no more than increased capital contributions from shareholders, some might be nationalized, and some might close. Troubled loans were transferred to a separate company. In all, the government's intervention was devised on a commercial basis to minimize the cost to the taxpayer.
Lundgren and his colleagues got less than they had braced for. By the spring of 1993, favorable winds in the international economy enabled some banks to withdraw their applications for support, and the bad loans were disposed of more swiftly than anticipated.
"Altogether, support of the banking sector amounted to the equivalent of 4 percent to 5 percent of GDP," Lundgren says. The World Bank put the figure at 6.4 percent, but even at that, the cost was half the size of the original problem. It's no wonder the Swedish solution is now viewed as a model of probity and intelligence.
Brian Waterhouse identifies eight key features of the Swedish method:
1. Early recognition of a crisis.
2. Acknowledgment that action is pressing.
3. Unconditional official support for the banking system.
4. Political leadership and unified public opinion.
5. Intervening legislation.
6. Independent supervision of the reconstruction process.
7. Nationalization if necessary.
8. Determination to denationalize as soon as possible.
It's full of Scandinavian rectitude, as I read it -- but a grim list when put against Japan's performance over the past decade. "The Swedes finished the race," Waterhouse observes.
"The Japanese are still stuck in the starting gate." Plenty of lessons here for Tokyo, then, before the International Monetary Fund begins its evaluation of the financial system this spring.
"Government intervention is unavoidable if nonperforming loans and loan losses are mounting in an economy." That is among Lundgren's more salient conclusions. Had he stayed home in Stockholm and advanced this thought to friends over aquavit and cigars, it would have been one thing. To articulate it in Tokyo in the winter of 2002 is pointedly another.
As Lundgren recounts, the Swedes learned from others when they set out to climb out of their crisis. It's a habit for which the Japanese are noted, and they ought not break it now.
Beijing’s continued provocations in the Taiwan Strait reveal its intention to unilaterally change the “status quo” in the area, the US Department of State said on Saturday, calling for a peaceful resolution to cross-strait issues. The Coast Guard Administration (CGA) reported that four China Coast Guard patrol vessels entered restricted and prohibited waters near Kinmen County on Friday and again on Saturday. A State Department spokesperson said that Washington was aware of the incidents, and urged all parties to exercise restraint and refrain from unilaterally changing the “status quo.” “Maintaining peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait is in line with our [the
EXTENDED RANGE: Hsiung Sheng missiles, 100 of which might be deployed by the end of the year, could reach Chinese command posts and airport runways, a source said A NT$16.9 billion (US$534.93 million) project to upgrade the military’s missile defense systems would be completed this year, allowing the deployment of at least 100 long-range Hsiung Sheng missiles and providing more deterrence against China, military sources said on Saturday. Hsiung Sheng missiles are an extended-range version of the Hsiung Feng IIE (HF-2E) surface-to-surface cruise missile, and are believed to have a range of up to 1,200km, which would allow them to hit targets well inside China. They went into mass production in 2022, the sources said. The project is part of a special budget for the Ministry of National Defense aimed at
READY TO WORK: Taiwan is eager to cooperate and is hopeful that like-minded states will continue to advocate for its inclusion in regional organizations, Lai said Maintaining the “status quo” in the Taiwan Strait, and peace and stability in the Indo-Pacific region must be a top priority, president-elect William Lai (賴清德) said yesterday after meeting with a delegation of US academics. Leaders of the G7, US President Joe Biden and other international heads of state have voiced concerns about the situation in the Strait, as stability in the region is necessary for a safe, peaceful and prosperous world, Lai said. The vice president, who is to be inaugurated in May, welcomed the delegation and thanked them for their support for Taiwan and issues concerning the Strait. The international community
COOPERATION: Two crewmembers from a Chinese fishing boat that sank off Kinmen were rescued, two were found dead and another two were still missing at press time The Coast Guard Administration (CGA) was yesterday working with Chinese rescuers to find two missing crewmembers from a Chinese fishing boat that sank southwest of Kinmen County yesterday, killing two crew. The joint operation managed to rescue two of the boat’s six crewmembers, but two were already dead when they were pulled from the water, the agency said in a statement. Rescuers are still searching for two others from the Min Long Yu 61222, a boat registered in China’s Fujian Province that capsized and sank 1.03 nautical miles (1.9km) southwest of Dongding Island (東碇), it added. CGA Director-General Chou Mei-wu (周美伍) told a