Apple Inc on Wednesday was told to pay US$625.6 million to VirnetX Holding Corp for using its patented technology related to secure communications, by a federal jury in Tyler, Texas.
Of that figure, US$334.9 million covers royalties on older versions of Apple’s VPN on Demand, which allows for remote connections and were found to infringe patents in a 2012 trial.
The jury said other Apple products also infringe the patents, including newer VPN, as well as its FaceTime video-calling feature and iMessage system to send messages to other Apple users. For those, Apple was told to pay US$290.7 million.
VirnetX had been seeking between US$532 million and US$740 million, saying that Apple had widely used its inventions without permission. Apple said it developed its own technology and that VirnetX overvalued what it did invent, adding that the most VirnetX should get was US$44.4 million.
VirnetX lawyer Brad Caldwell of the firm Caldwell Cassady said jurors were able to clearly understand the case.
He said the company’s witnesses were “believable” while Apple’s witnesses “varied” under questioning.
VirnetX soared as high as US$8.81, an 84 percent jump over its closing share price on Wednesday. During regular trading, shares jumped about 30 percent as investors bet that the daylong jury deliberations would mean a big win for the company.
Apple said it will appeal and it has a history of success in getting big verdicts overturned.
A judge in the same Texas court district in July last year threw out a US$533 million damage award Apple lost to Smartflash LLC. A damages retrial in that case is pending the appeal of the underlying infringement finding.
Wednesday’s decision ranks in the top 10 among damage awards issued by juries in patent cases, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
“We are surprised and disappointed by the verdict and we’re going to appeal,” Apple said in an e-mailed statement. “Our employees independently designed this technology over many years and we received patents to protect this intellectual property. All four of VirnetX’s patents have been found invalid by the patent office. Cases like this simply reinforce the desperate need for patent reform.”
This is the second go-around for VirnetX and Apple. VirnetX had previously won a US$368.2 million verdict against Apple only to see it thrown out by an appeals court.
The infringement finding regarding VPN on Demand was upheld, while a new trial was ordered on damages and whether FaceTime infringed the patents.
This case is a retrial on those issues plus some newer generations of Apple products. The dispute is over secure networks, known as virtual private networks, through which a Web site owner can interact with customers, employees can work at home and access company files, or people can see each other as they talk over the phone.
Since VirnetX has been unable to commercialize its own products, investors were counting on a big victory against Apple.
The stock lost half its value last year and rises or falls based on news in this case. Shares rose 54 percent on Jan. 12 after the judge said the case would go forward and rejected Apple’s bid to narrow the legal issues.
BUSINESS UPDATE: The iPhone assembler said operations outlook is expected to show quarter-on-quarter and year-on-year growth for the second quarter Hon Hai Precision Industry Co (鴻海精密) yesterday reported strong growth in sales last month, potentially raising expectations for iPhone sales while artificial intelligence (AI)-related business booms. The company, which assembles the majority of Apple Inc’s smartphones, reported a 19.03 percent rise in monthly sales to NT$510.9 billion (US$15.78 billion), from NT$429.22 billion in the same period last year. On a monthly basis, sales rose 14.16 percent, it said. The company in a statement said that last month’s revenue was a record-breaking April performance. Hon Hai, known also as Foxconn Technology Group (富士康科技集團), assembles most iPhones, but the company is diversifying its business to
Apple Inc has been developing a homegrown chip to run artificial intelligence (AI) tools in data centers, although it is unclear if the semiconductor would ever be deployed, the Wall Street Journal reported on Monday. The effort would build on Apple’s previous efforts to make in-house chips, which run in its iPhones, Macs and other devices, according to the Journal, which cited unidentified people familiar with the matter. The server project is code-named ACDC (Apple Chips in Data Center) within the company, aiming to utilize Apple’s expertise in chip design for the company’s server infrastructure, the newspaper said. While this initiative has been
GlobalWafers Co (環球晶圓), the world’s No. 3 silicon wafer supplier, yesterday said that revenue would rise moderately in the second half of this year, driven primarily by robust demand for advanced wafers used in high-bandwidth memory (HBM) chips, a key component of artificial intelligence (AI) technology. “The first quarter is the lowest point of this cycle. The second half will be better than the first for the whole semiconductor industry and for GlobalWafers,” chairwoman Doris Hsu (徐秀蘭) said during an online investors’ conference. “HBM would definitely be the key growth driver in the second half,” Hsu said. “That is our big hope
The consumer price index (CPI) last month eased to 1.95 percent, below the central bank’s 2 percent target, as food and entertainment cost increases decelerated, helped by stable egg prices, the Directorate-General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics (DGBAS) said yesterday. The slowdown bucked predictions by policymakers and academics that inflationary pressures would build up following double-digit electricity rate hikes on April 1. “The latest CPI data came after the cost of eating out and rent grew moderately amid mixed international raw material prices,” DGBAS official Tsao Chih-hung (曹志弘) told a news conference in Taipei. The central bank in March raised interest rates by