A US federal judge has decided a US$324.5 million settlement is not sufficient to cover the damages done to more than 60,000 high-tech workers in a class-action lawsuit alleging Google Inc and Apple Inc conspired with other technology companies to block their top employees from getting better job offers.
The ruling on Friday by US District Judge Lucy Koh overturns a settlement reached in April, prolonging a three-year-old case that paints a mean-spirited picture of Apple founder Steve Jobs and other prominent Silicon Valley executives.
Koh estimated that the workers deserve at least US$380 million, based on the evidence indicating their earning power was undermined by collusion among their employers.
Attorneys representing the workers were originally seeking US$3 billion in damages before settling for about 10 percent of that amount in a deal reached in April.
A US$9 billion award would have paid the affected workers an average of more than US$140,000 each. Koh estimated that after subtracting lawyers’ fees and other payments, the workers would have received an average of US$3,750 had she approved the US$324.5 million settlement. That amount “falls below the range of reasonableness,” she wrote.
The settlement would have been paid by Apple Inc, Google Inc, Intel Corp and Adobe Systems Inc. The lawsuit alleges they and three other companies — Intuit Inc, Pixar Animation and Lucasfilm — secretly agreed not to recruit each other’s workers at various junctures from 2005 through 2009.
Apple and Google declined to comment on Koh’s ruling. Intel spokesman Chuck Mulloy said the company was disappointed by the decision, but had not yet decided its next step. Adobe did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
A US$20 million settlement of the claims against Intuit, Pixar Animation and Lucasfilm was approved in June.
Koh indicated that the workers at Google, Apple, Intel and Adobe had built a strong case against their employers.
“There is ample evidence of an overarching conspiracy,” she said in her 32-page ruling.
In their arguments for approving the US$324.5 million settlement, attorneys for the workers said that the conspiracy would not have been easy to prove to a jury. If the settlement had been approved, the workers’ attorneys’ would have received US$82 million in fees and expenses.
To illustrate why she believes the workers have a strong case, Koh referred to depositions and e-mails detailing some of the machinations that led to the “no-poaching” agreements.
She depicted Jobs, who died in October 2011, as the ringleader of the scheme. The ruling also chastized Google and Adobe for following Jobs’ wishes “out of fear and deference to him.”
Koh pointed to evidence showing that Google scrapped plans for an engineering center in Paris staffed by former Apple employees after Jobs strenuously objected. In another instance cited by Koh, Google’s then-CEO Eric Schmidt fired a recruiter who had contacted an Apple engineer in 2007, raising Jobs’ ire. When Schmidt e-mailed the news that the recruiter had been fired, Jobs forwarded the note to Apple’s personnel department with a smiley face above it, Koh noted.
Not all Silicon Valley executives were so submissive. Koh’s ruling cited an instance when Jobs tried to cajole now-defunct device maker Palm Inc to join the no-poaching cartel.
Palm’s then-CEO Edward Colligan warned Jobs that his no-poaching demand was “likely illegal” in an e-mail recounted in Koh’s ruling.
“We can’t dictate where someone will work, nor should we try,” Colligan wrote. “I can’t deny people who elect to pursue their livelihood at Palm the right to do so simply because they now work for Apple, and I wouldn’t want you to do that to current Palm employees.”
Palm never joined the no-poaching club and neither did Facebook Inc, despite Google’s attempts to persuade its rival to join in, evidence obtained in the lawsuit showed.
The US Justice Department opened an investigation into Silicon Valley’s no-poaching pacts in 2009, resulting in a 2010 settlement requiring the participating companies stop the practice. The companies did not acknowledge any wrongdoing.
Among the rows of vibrators, rubber torsos and leather harnesses at a Chinese sex toys exhibition in Shanghai this weekend, the beginnings of an artificial intelligence (AI)-driven shift in the industry quietly pulsed. China manufactures about 70 percent of the world’s sex toys, most of it the “hardware” on display at the fair — whether that be technicolor tentacled dildos or hyper-realistic personalized silicone dolls. Yet smart toys have been rising in popularity for some time. Many major European and US brands already offer tech-enhanced products that can enable long-distance love, monitor well-being and even bring people one step closer to
Malaysia’s leader yesterday announced plans to build a massive semiconductor design park, aiming to boost the Southeast Asian nation’s role in the global chip industry. A prominent player in the semiconductor industry for decades, Malaysia accounts for an estimated 13 percent of global back-end manufacturing, according to German tech giant Bosch. Now it wants to go beyond production and emerge as a chip design powerhouse too, Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim said. “I am pleased to announce the largest IC (integrated circuit) Design Park in Southeast Asia, that will house world-class anchor tenants and collaborate with global companies such as Arm [Holdings PLC],”
Sales in the retail, and food and beverage sectors last month continued to rise, increasing 0.7 percent and 13.6 percent respectively from a year earlier, setting record highs for the month of March, the Ministry of Economic Affairs said yesterday. Sales in the wholesale sector also grew last month by 4.6 annually, mainly due to the business opportunities for emerging applications related to artificial intelligence (AI) and high-performance computing technologies, the ministry said in a report. The ministry forecast that retail, and food and beverage sales this month would retain their growth momentum as the former would benefit from Tomb Sweeping Day
TRANSFORMATION: Taiwan is now home to the largest Google hardware research and development center outside of the US, thanks to the nation’s economic policies President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) yesterday attended an event marking the opening of Google’s second hardware research and development (R&D) office in Taiwan, which was held at New Taipei City’s Banciao District (板橋). This signals Taiwan’s transformation into the world’s largest Google hardware research and development center outside of the US, validating the nation’s economic policy in the past eight years, she said. The “five plus two” innovative industries policy, “six core strategic industries” initiative and infrastructure projects have grown the national industry and established resilient supply chains that withstood the COVID-19 pandemic, Tsai said. Taiwan has improved investment conditions of the domestic economy