Royal Bank of Canada officials’ conflicts of interest tainted a US$438 million buyout of Rural/Metro Corp and the national ambulance service’s former investors deserved more for their shares, a judge ruled.
Bankers at RBC Capital Markets misled Rural/Metro directors in 2011 about the company’s value to push the board into a quick sale to buy out firm Warburg Pincus LLC, Delaware Chancery Court Judge Travis Laster concluded in a ruling. RBC officials also did not tell directors they were touting their financial-adviser work on the deal to secure financing roles on other acquisitions, the judge said.
Those conflicts led Rural/Metro investors to be shortchanged in the US$17.25-a-share deal, Laster found. The judge said he would decide later how much in damages RBC must pay former stockholders of the company, the largest US ambulance service operator and provider of emergency room doctors.
Investors are seeking as much as US$172 million from Canada’s second-largest lender by assets, according to court filings.
“The combination of RBC’s behind-the-scenes maneuvering” and its bankers’ failure to disclose their conflicting interests clouded the deal, Laster said.
“For improper motives of its own,” RBC misled Rural/Metro directors and prevented the board from getting the best price for investors, he said.
The decision reached on Friday is the latest in a series of Delaware corporate-law rulings reining in banks’ and investment firms’ conflicts in buyout cases.
Laster ruled in 2011 that Barclays PLC had conflicting interests while serving as Del Monte Foods Co’s adviser in a US$5.3 billion sale, because it also arranged financing for buyer KKR & Co without telling Del Monte’s directors.
Since Delaware is the corporate home of more than half of the US’ publicly traded companies and 63 percent of Fortune 500 firms, chancery court rulings resonate beyond the state’s borders, Larry Hamermesh, a Widener University professor who specializes in corporate law issues, said in a telephone interview on Saturday.
Laster’s ruling is a stark reminder that “directors have the right to expect disclosure of significant conflicts” by their advisers, Hamermesh said.
If bankers withhold conflicting interests in a deal, that “can raise loyalty questions and may mean they have to pay damages,” he said.
Scottsdale, Arizona-based Rural/Metro provides ambulance and firefighting services to about 700 communities in 21 states. Its directors sold the company to New York-based Warburg, a private-equity firm, for US$438 million in March 2011.
Rural/Metro sought bankruptcy protection from creditors in Delaware last year to cut its debt and arrange a cash infusion. The company, which also offers industrial fire-protection services to airports, oil refineries and plants, won court approval of its restructuring plan on Dec. 17 last year. It raised US$135 million in new funding as part of the Chapter 11 case.
Rural/Metro shareholders sued over the buyout, claiming the company’s board accepted a low-ball offer from Warburg after getting advice from conflicted RBC bankers, who botched the effort to shop around the emergency services company to the highest bidder.
Rural/Metro directors and Moelis & Co, an investment bank that also advised the company in the Warburg deal, agreed to pay a total of US$11.6 million to settle investors claims that they did not get enough for their shares.
From the customer’s perspective, car rental is a straightforward business. The only uncertainty is whether the hire company will charge you for the scratch they discover when you hand back the vehicle. Hertz Global Holdings Inc’s bankruptcy protection filing on Friday last week was a reminder that today even the simplest business models are underpinned by a lot more financial complexity than meets the eye. The proximate cause of Hertz’s demise was of course the sudden collapse in bookings caused by COVID-19 travel restrictions. The company’s monthly revenue last month fell 73 percent year-on-year, a shortfall that even the most resilient
Uber Technologies Inc, Lyft Inc and Airbnb Inc have slashed thousands of jobs. Salesforce.com Inc and Visa Inc are letting employees work remotely for months; Twitter Inc and Square Inc are allowing them to do so for good. For the companies’ hometown of San Francisco, the moves are early signs of a dire blow. In a city with a long history of booms, busts and natural calamities, the COVID-19 pandemic has suddenly upended nearly a decade of prosperity. While municipalities across the US are grappling with economic fallout from the virus, San Francisco stands to take a deeper hit given its high
BULK PURCHASE: The French chain and Hong Kong-based Dairy Farm International reached a deal covering 224 stores, which is expected to be finalized by year’s end Carrefour SA yesterday announced it would acquire Wellcome Taiwan Co (惠康百貨) for 97 million euros (US$108.33 million), and bring all the Wellcome supermarkets (頂好超市) and Jasons Market Place stores nationwide under its banner within 12 months of the deal closing. The France-based hypermarket chain reached an agreement with Hong Kong-based Dairy Farm International Holdings (牛奶國際控股), the pan-Asian retailer that launched Wellcome Taiwan in 1987. The transaction involves 199 Wellcome supermarkets, which have average sales areas of 420m2 and 25 high-end Jasons Market Place stores, which have an average sales area of 820m2, as well as a warehouse in Taoyuan, Carrefour Taiwan (家樂福)
‘ONE-STOP SHOP’: A Miaoli official said that the factory in the Jhunan section of the Hsinchu Science Park would create more than 1,000 jobs and boost prosperity A new high-end IC packaging and testing plant planned by contract chipmaker Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) in Miaoli County is expected to start operations in the middle of next year, Miaoli County Commissioner Hsu Yao-chang (徐耀昌) said. Hsu wrote on Facebook that TSMC, the world’s largest pure wafer foundry operator, would invest NT$303.2 billion (US$10.1 billion) to build the plant, the largest-ever single investment in Taiwan. However, TSMC declined to disclose the financial terms of the deal, while a company board meeting on May 12 approved a spending plan worth NT$168.2 billion as part of its investment plans. Construction of the