One of Rupert Murdoch’s most senior European executives has resigned following inquiries by the Guardian about a controversial circulation scheme at News Corp’s flagship newspaper, the Wall Street Journal (WSJ).
The Guardian found evidence that the WSJ had been channeling money through European companies in order to secretly buy thousands of copies of its own paper at a knock-down rate, misleading readers and advertisers about the WSJ’s true circulation.
The bizarre scheme included a contract in which the WSJ persuaded one company to cooperate by agreeing to publish articles that promoted its activities, a move which led some staff to accuse the paper’s management of violating journalistic ethics and jeopardizing its treasured reputation for editorial quality.
Internal e-mails and documents suggest the scam was promoted by Andrew Langhoff, European managing director of the WSJ’s parent company, Dow Jones and Co, which was bought by Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp in July 2007. Langhoff resigned on Tuesday.
The highly controversial activities were organized in London and focused on the WSJ’s European edition. Top executives in New York, including Murdoch’s right-hand man, Les Hinton, were alerted to the problems last year by an internal whistleblower and apparently chose to take no action. The whistleblower was then made redundant in January.
In what appears to have been a damage limitation exercise following the Guardian’s inquiries, Langhoff resigned, citing only the complaints of unethical interference in editorial coverage. Neither he nor an article published in the WSJ on Wednesday made any reference to the circulation scam nor to the fact that the senior management of Dow Jones in New York failed to act when they were alerted last year.
The affair will add weight to shareholder fears that News Corp has become a “rogue corporation.” Some of them have launched a legal action in the US, attacking the Murdochs after the News of the World phone-hacking scandal and following lawsuits in which News Corp subsidiaries were accused of hacking into competitors’ computers and stealing their customers.
The WSJ’s decision secretly to buy its own papers began with an unusual circulation-boosting scheme called the Future Leadership Institute. In January 2008, the WSJ linked up with European firms who sponsored seminars for university students who were likely to be future leaders. The WSJ rewarded the sponsors by publishing their names in the paper. The sponsors paid for that publicity by buying copies of the WSJ at no more than US$0.05 each. Those papers were then distributed to students.
The scheme was controversial. However, the UK’s Audit Bureau of Circulation ruled the scheme was legitimate and by last year, it was responsible for 41 percent of the European edition’s 75,000 daily sale.
Early last year the scheme began to face trouble when its biggest single sponsor, Dutch firm Executive Learning Partnership (ELP), threatened to back out. ELP was responsible for 16 percent of the WSJ’s European circulation, sponsoring 12,000 copies a day at US$0.01 per copy.
Over the year it sponsored 3.1 million copies costing 31,080 euros (US$42,470). ELP said the publicity it received was not enough of a return on its investment.
On April 9 last year, Langhoff e-mailed ELP with a new deal, offering to “provide a well-branded showcase for ELP’s valuable services.”
That deal included a new eight-page addendum, which the Guardian has seen: The WSJ would give ELP free advertisements and, in exchange, ELP would produce “leadership videos” for them; they would jointly organize more seminars and workshops; but, crucially, Langhoff agreed the WSJ would publish “a minimum of three special reports” based on surveys of the European market that ELP would run with the WSJ’s help.
Two such stories were then published in October last year and in March without any warning that they were the product of a business deal. The paper now has disclaimers on the online versions owning up to that fact.
Last autumn, ELP complained the WSJ was failing to deliver its end of the deal and threatened to withhold a 15,000 euro payment, due in December, for copies of the WSJ they had sponsored since April 30. Without the payment, the paper could not record the sales and its circulation would dive by 16 percent.
So Langhoff set up a complex scheme to channel money to ELP to pay for papers it had agreed to buy — effectively buying the papers with the WSJ’s own cash. This involved the use of other firms but it is not suggested that they were aware they were taking part in a scam.
On Wednesday Dow Jones said it initiated the original investigation into the deals in question and the employees involved late last year.
“The circulation programs and the copies associated with ELP were legitimate and appropriate, and the agreement was shared with ABC UK before the deal was signed,” the statement said. “All circulation periods during the ELP arrangement have been certified.”
Meanwhile, the WSJ has slammed the Guardian story as “inflammatory” and “replete with untruths and malign interpretations” in a statement to The Associated Press.
Additional reporting by AP
Among the rows of vibrators, rubber torsos and leather harnesses at a Chinese sex toys exhibition in Shanghai this weekend, the beginnings of an artificial intelligence (AI)-driven shift in the industry quietly pulsed. China manufactures about 70 percent of the world’s sex toys, most of it the “hardware” on display at the fair — whether that be technicolor tentacled dildos or hyper-realistic personalized silicone dolls. Yet smart toys have been rising in popularity for some time. Many major European and US brands already offer tech-enhanced products that can enable long-distance love, monitor well-being and even bring people one step closer to
Malaysia’s leader yesterday announced plans to build a massive semiconductor design park, aiming to boost the Southeast Asian nation’s role in the global chip industry. A prominent player in the semiconductor industry for decades, Malaysia accounts for an estimated 13 percent of global back-end manufacturing, according to German tech giant Bosch. Now it wants to go beyond production and emerge as a chip design powerhouse too, Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim said. “I am pleased to announce the largest IC (integrated circuit) Design Park in Southeast Asia, that will house world-class anchor tenants and collaborate with global companies such as Arm [Holdings PLC],”
Sales in the retail, and food and beverage sectors last month continued to rise, increasing 0.7 percent and 13.6 percent respectively from a year earlier, setting record highs for the month of March, the Ministry of Economic Affairs said yesterday. Sales in the wholesale sector also grew last month by 4.6 annually, mainly due to the business opportunities for emerging applications related to artificial intelligence (AI) and high-performance computing technologies, the ministry said in a report. The ministry forecast that retail, and food and beverage sales this month would retain their growth momentum as the former would benefit from Tomb Sweeping Day
Thousands of parents in Singapore are furious after a Cordlife Group Ltd (康盛人生集團), a major operator of cord blood banks in Asia, irreparably damaged their children’s samples through improper handling, with some now pursuing legal action. The ongoing case, one of the worst to hit the largely untested industry, has renewed concerns over companies marketing themselves to anxious parents with mostly unproven assurances. This has implications across the region, given Cordlife’s operations in Hong Kong, Macau, Indonesia, the Philippines and India. The parents paid for years to have their infants’ cord blood stored, with the understanding that the stem cells they contained