Tue, Aug 23, 2011 - Page 10 News List

Motorola patents wanted for Apple fight

PATENT WARS:Google’s ownership of more than 17,000 patents following its purchase of Motorola Mobility will help it ‘defend’ against Apple’s cornucopia of lawsuit filings


A man uses his Motorola mobile phone in Bangkok last Tuesday.

Photo: Reuters

Among Motorola Mobility Holdings Inc’s more than 17,000 patents, a group of 18 may prove most useful in Google Inc’s effort to fend off litigation targeting the Android mobile platform.

The inventions date back to 1994 and form the heart of three Motorola lawsuits against Apple Inc, making them among the stars of the portfolio, said David Mixon, a patent lawyer at Bradley Arant Boult Cummings in Huntsville, Alabama.

They cover technology essential to the mobile-device industry, including location services, antenna designs, e-mail transmission, touch-screen motions, software-application management and 3G wireless.

“Any patent owner, before they consider litigation, is going to carefully evaluate their patents to withstand an attack,” Mixon said in a telephone interview. “You don’t want to hold any back. You want to pick your strongest patents.”

Google is counting on its US$12.5 billion acquisition of Libertyville, Illinois-based Motorola Mobility to strengthen its patent lineup as Apple and Microsoft Corp challenge Android, the best-selling smartphone operating system in the second quarter.

Google had been issued fewer than 1,000 patents as of the start of this year. Motorola Mobility would add another 17,000, as well as about 7,500 pending applications.

“There are a lot of sweet patents in that portfolio,” said Dean Becker, chief executive officer of Palm Beach, Florida-based ICAP Patent Brokerage, the world’s largest.

He said Google only needs a few to bolster its legal position.

Android was introduced on handsets three years ago to further Google’s advertising business and is provided free to device makers, including Motorola Mobility, Samsung Electronics Co and HTC Corp (宏達電). The platform accounted for 43.3 percent of the smartphone market last quarter, according to Stamford, Connecticut-based research firm Gartner Inc. Cupertino, California-based Apple had an 18.2 percent share.

The US International Trade Commission (ITC), which arbitrates patent-related disputes, has fielded more than a dozen cases in the past year related to smartphones and tablets. Because Google doesn’t profit directly from Android, it has been able to sit mostly on the sidelines, while its partners were sued.

Google has been sued twice by competitors over Android — Oracle Corp and Skyhook Wireless Inc — and has never led a patent-infringement case against another company. It declined to comment for this story, as did Motorola Mobility and Apple.

An ITC judge last month found HTC’s Android phones infringed two Apple patents, which may spur a US import ban.

“We’ve been saying for some time that we intend to protect the Android ecosystem,” David Drummond, chief legal officer at Mountain View, California-based Google, said during a conference call with analysts last week. “It’s under threat.”

Motorola Mobility, which created the consumer market for mobile phones with the DynaTAC 8000X “brick” in 1983, and Apple, which reinvented the industry with the iPhone in 2007, are among the larger companies that have been battling over ownership of mobile technology. Motorola Mobility, spun off from Motorola Inc in January, picked a fight with Apple in October last year when it filed three lawsuits and an ITC complaint.

The cases target Apple products, including the iPhone 4, iPad, AppleTV and MacBook Air. Motorola Mobility used four of the 18 patents from the Apple cases to help push BlackBerry maker Research in Motion Ltd (RIM) into a cross-licensing settlement last year. That deal required Waterloo, Ontario-based RIM to make an undisclosed upfront payment and pay royalties.

This story has been viewed 3750 times.

Comments will be moderated. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned.

TOP top