Thu, Mar 08, 2007 page11

• Clevo Computer shrugs off two Lenovo lawsuits

  LICENSING ROYALTIES OWED The Chinese company is pressing for payments owed for two IBM patents. Clevo said it spent most of last year negotiating the fees

  • By Jason Tan / STAFF REPORTER
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  Clevo Computer Co (藍天電腦), one of the nation's smaller computer makers, said yesterday that its business would not be affected by two patent lawsuits filed by Lenovo Group Ltd (聯想).

  Lenovo, the world's No. 3 personal computer maker, sued Clevo in New York last Friday, claiming the Taiwanese firm had infringed on two patents for PC functions and therefore owed millions of dollars in licensing royalties.

  One patent, issued in 1996, was for a computer system with a single switch to turn it on or off, or to suspend or resume functions. The other, also issued in 1996, was for power management within a computer. Both were originally issued to IBM.

  "We already listed the payment in our finances and the lawsuit will not affect us," a Clevo spokeswoman, who requested anonymity, said in a telephone interview yesterday.

  IBM Corp granted Lenovo the right to collect licensing fees after selling its PC business to the Chinese company in 2005, and Clevo held discussions with Lenovo about a new contract for payment last year, she said.

  "We are puzzled by the lawsuit filing as the negotiations on the new contract were nearly completed," she said.

  Clevo wanted to have a new contract sealed by Lenovo instead of IBM after the rights transfer, because both IBM and Lenovo pursued the payments last year, she said.

  According to the filing with the US District Court for the Southern District of New York, Lenovo claims Clevo has not made payments under a 1999 agreement with IBM scheduled to run through Dec. 31.

  Clevo was supposed to pay US$3 million on Aug. 31 last year and another US$3 million by Aug. 31 this year. It owes a portion of the payment for this year, about US$41,000, in addition to last year's fee, Lenovo said.

  Lenovo said in the complaint that Clevo had failed to pay ``despite repeated demands for payment from IBM and Lenovo, and despite repeated assurances of payment by Clevo.''

  In response, the Taipei-based company said lawyers from both sides had held rational communications on the issue last year, by e-mail, telephone and in face-to-face meetings, and so it was surprised to learn of the lawsuit.

  But since Clevo will settle the payment, the lawsuit should not impact on the companies' future relationship, the Clevo spokeswoman said.

  Shares of Clevo, which is now running 10 outlets of Buynow (百腦匯), a computer and electronics retail chain in China, closed down 1.1 percent to NT$28 on the Taiwan Stock Exchange yesterday.

  Lenovo has joined LG Electronics Inc and Samsung Electronics Co in the ranks of foreign companies who have filed lawsuits against Taiwanese computer makers for patent infringement.

  Last July, South Korea's LG won a suit against Quanta Computer Inc (廣達電腦) and Compal Electronics Inc (仁寶電腦).

  Compal is also involved in a dispute with Samsung over software used to output data from notebook keyboards.

  Taiwanese companies make about four out of five notebook computers shipped, including those by Hewlett-Packard Co, Dell Inc and Apple Computer Inc, according to researcher DisplaySearch.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Air quality to deteriorate nationwide from tomorrow

  • 2

    Taiwan conflict ‘catastrophic’ for China: US report

  • 3

    Bucks defeat Hornets in final seconds

  • 4

    Taiwan closely monitoring Venezuela developments

  • 5

    Paris sees first derby in almost 36 years