The rise and fall of Dbtel Inc (大霸電子), the first Taiwanese handset vendor to obtain Beijing's approval to sell branded phones in China, has shown in less than five years how important the company's integrity is to its business, no matter how big its original vision for a share of the China market.
The Chinese dream had sent shares of Dbtel skyrocketing to an all-time high of NT$149.5 on the Taiwan Stock Exchange in April of 2000. But dismal financial results along with recent insider-trading probes drove down its shares on Friday to the junk-bond level of NT$2.89 on the over-the-counter GRETAI Securities Market.
"Now we are facing similar difficulties to those that Acer Inc encountered when it operated a brand in the first few years," Dbtel Chairman Michael Mou (
The insider-trading investigation brought Dbtel back under the media spotlight, but dealt a further blow to investors' confidence in the stock.
"We haven't covered Dbtel for a long period of time and we have no plan to put the stock on our investment list," said Jonathan Liao (
"Untrustworthy financial forecasts have upset investors' stomachs," he said.
Apart from Dbtel, BenQ Corp (明基) and Inventec Appliances Corp (英華達) were granted approval in May to officially tap into the Chinese market.
But another analyst said investors have now expressed reservations about China's investment climate, citing vast market uncertainties and economic cyclical changes.
"It was seen as an advantage for local companies to get Beijing's approval for selling handsets in China, with an eye to potential growth. But now investors are not so excited anymore about tapping into the market," said an analyst surnamed Liao, an analyst with KGI Securities (中信證券).
Forecasts slashed
According to Dbtel's statements to the Taiwan Stock Exchange over the past five years, the company has sharply slashed its financial forecasts every year. In the latest adjustment of its financial projection, Dbtel said it would lose NT$898 million last year, rather than recording earnings of NT$1.37 billion like it estimated earlier.
Regarding China, not Taiwan, as its home market, Dbtel attributed the drastic cut to intensifying competition in China as well as weakening consumption after Beijing implemented measures to control the overheating economy, according to a statement to the Taiwan Stock Exchange.
Starting out as a contract manufacturer for telephony and communications equipment in 1979, Dbtel decided to expand into the brand business after ending its partnership with Motorola Inc, the world's No. 2 mobile-phone vendor in 2000. Motorola turned to BenQ and later Compal Communications Corp (華寶通訊) for its handset supplies.
Dbtel then kicked off its own-brand mobile phone business in China, which consumes 80 million units a year, in early 2001. With initial success on the mainland, the company had vowed to challenge Nokia Ojy's No. 1 position in the global handset market.
Shares rally
Rallies in its share price had helped the company raise more funds from local capital markets for further expansion in China, but some also started to question the company's sustained profitability as its business is absolutely connected to swings in China's economy.
A series of dramatic financial adjustments along with other factors drew the attention of investigators and the stock regulator. Government agencies recently joined forces to look into alleged abnormal trading of Dbtel shares during the period ahead of a proposed share sale last year.
RSS