A legal ruling says DuPont violated its contract with rival Monsanto by developing genetically modified soybeans created with Monsanto’s technology, but leaves open DuPont’s challenge of the contract on antitrust grounds.
The ruling in St Louis federal court is the latest turn in a lawsuit between the world’s two biggest seed companies. At issue is how much freedom Monsanto Co’s competitors have to develop crops containing their own biotech traits using Monsanto’s patented Roundup Ready gene, which is inserted in the vast majority of US corn and soybean crops.
The Roundup Ready gene makes crops resistant to its Roundup herbicide, making weed control cheaper and easier for farmers because they can spray the herbicide without hurting their crop.
The trait has become the industry standard since Monsanto introduced it in 1996.
Monsanto sued DuPont last spring, claiming it was illegal for DuPont to sell its new line of biotech seeds called Optimum GAT.
That line of seeds adds a new DuPont gene to the older line of Roundup Ready corn and soybean plants that DuPont developed under a license with Monsanto.
US District Judge Richard Webber said in Friday’s ruling that Monsanto’s licensing agreement clearly prohibits DuPont from inserting its Optimum GAT gene into corn and soybean plants with Monsanto traits.
But Webber said his ruling was narrow and didn’t consider whether Monsanto has the right under antitrust laws to restrict how competitors breed and sell plants with Monsanto traits.
DuPont is challenging its licensing agreement with Monsanto on antitrust grounds, in the midst of a US Department of Justice antitrust investigation into Monsanto that is examining whether there is anticompetitive behavior in the seed industry.
“This litigation is just beginning; we will now vigorously pursue our antitrust, license and patent fraud claims,” DuPont senior vice president and general counsel Thomas Sager said in a statement on Saturday.
Monsanto spokesman Lee Quarles said DuPont’s claims of antitrust violations in the contract are a “continued smoke screen and effort to obscure the significance of the court’s ruling on their license violation.”
“As we’ve stated clearly over the last several months, DuPont negotiated and signed a contract with a specific set of rights, at the financial terms they preferred, and the rights they licensed did not include making” Optimum GAT, Quarles said in an e-mail on Saturday.
Monsanto announced this week that the Justice Department demanded internal documents related to the company’s soybean business.
Quarles said the company has done nothing wrong and is cooperating with the department, providing the millions of pages of documents it requested.
DuPont spokesman Dan Turner said Friday’s ruling would not change or delay the company’s efforts to commercialize its Optimum GAT seeds, which the company says will be an alternative to Monsanto’s products.
RISK REMAINS: An official said that with the US presidential elections so close, it is unclear if China would hold war games or keep its reaction to angry words The Ministry of National Defense said it was “on alert” as it detected a Chinese aircraft carrier group to Taiwan’s south yesterday amid concerns in Taiwan about the possibility of a new round of Chinese war games. The ministry said in a statement that a Chinese navy group led by the carrier Liaoning had entered waters near the Bashi Channel, which connects the South China Sea and the Pacific Ocean and separates Taiwan from the Philippines. It said the carrier group was expected to enter the Western Pacific. The military is keeping a close watch on developments and “exercising an
FIVE-YEAR WINDOW? A defense institute CEO said a timeline for a potential Chinese invasion was based on expected ‘tough measures’ when Xi Jinping seeks a new term Most Taiwanese are willing to defend the nation against a Chinese attack, but the majority believe Beijing is unlikely to invade within the next five years, a poll showed yesterday. The poll carried out last month was commissioned by the Institute for National Defense and Security Research, a Taipei-based think tank, and released ahead of Double Ten National Day today, when President William Lai (賴清德) is to deliver a speech. China maintains a near-daily military presence around Taiwan and has held three rounds of war games in the past two years. CIA Director William Burns last year said that Chinese President Xi Jinping
REACTION TO LAI: A former US official said William Lai took a step toward stability with his National Day speech and the question was how Beijing would respond US Secretary of State Antony Blinken yesterday warned China against taking any “provocative” action on Taiwan after Beijing’s reaction to President William Lai’s (賴清德) speech on Double Ten National Day on Thursday. Blinken, speaking in Laos after an ASEAN East Asia Summit, called the speech by Lai, in which he vowed to “resist annexation,” a “regular exercise.” “China should not use it in any fashion as a pretext for provocative actions,” Blinken told reporters. “On the contrary, we want to reinforce — and many other countries want to reinforce — the imperative of preserving the status quo, and neither party taking any
President William Lai (賴清德) yesterday said that China has “no right to represent Taiwan,” but stressed that the nation was willing to work with Beijing on issues of mutual interest. “The Republic of China has already put down roots in Taiwan, Penghu, Kinmen and Matsu,” Lai said in his first Double Ten National Day address outside the Presidential Office Building in Taipei. “And the Republic of China and the People’s Republic of China [PRC] are not subordinate to each other.” “The People’s Republic of China has no right to represent Taiwan,” he said at the event marking the 113th National Day of
RSS