When COVID-19 hit Belize, its economy nosedived: Closed borders meant fisheries and farmers had no export markets, and tourism centered on the tiny Central American nation’s warm waters and wonders of biodiversity came to a halt.
“We lost approximately 14 percent of GDP,” Belizean Prime Minister John Antonio Briceno said in an interview. Nearly one-third of the workforce of the nation’s 400,000 people were unemployed and there was not enough money “to keep the lights on,” let alone maintain onerous debt repayments.
Then came a lifeline: Environmental nonprofit The Nature Conservancy (TNC) offered to lend Belize money to pay off creditors if it promised to put part of the savings into marine protection.
Photo: AFP
So-called “debt-for-nature-swaps” are being hailed as an innovative financial tool for preserving ecosystems from climate change and overexploitation, even as critics warn their generosity is overstated and they are far from a cure-all.
Finalized in November 2021, a year after Briceno took office, the deal involved TNC buying back a US$553 million “superbond,” which held the government’s entire commercial debt, negotiating a discount of 45 percent.
This was converted into a US$364 million loan “blue bonds” in a sale arranged by Credit Suisse, unlocking US$180 million for marine conservation over 20 years.
“For us, it was a win-win, it gave us a breather,” Briceno said.
Notably, the buyback reduced the country’s debt-to-GDP ratio by more than 10 percent.
OLD IDEA, BIGGER SCALE
Belize’s coastline is home to the largest barrier reef in the northern hemisphere, providing significant habitat for threatened species, including manatees, turtles and crocodiles. However, warming oceans from climate change, excessive fishing and coastal development all pose major challenges.
Under the terms of the deal, Belize agreed to expand protection to 30 percent of its territorial waters and spend US$4.2 million annually on marine conservation.
Since then, TNC has signed similar agreements with Barbados and Gabon. Ecuador negotiated the biggest swap of all in May, reducing its debt obligations by about US$1.1 billion to benefit the Galapagos Islands under an arrangement overseen by Pew Bertarelli Ocean Legacy Project.
Slav Gatchev, managing director of sustainable debt at TNC, said that although the first debt-for-nature swaps happened in the 1980s, now they operate at a far larger scale.
“A third of the outstanding commercial debt to lower and middle income countries is in some form of distress,” he said, meaning environmental ministry budgets are stretched and it is hard for governments to invest in nature. He sees an opportunity to refinance up to US$1 trillion of the commercial and bilateral debt, in turn generating US$250 billion for climate and nature.
PAPER PARKS?
Andre Standing, a researcher for groups including the Coalition for Fair Fisheries Arrangements, said that the Belize deal was only possible because the country was about to default and it was therefore better for creditors to accept a lump sum — rather than the altruistic act it was portrayed as by some.
Moreover, such deals do nothing to address the debt crisis plaguing developing countries, he added.
“That’s true, but it’s not intended to,” said Esteban Brenes, who leads conservation finance for the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF), which is also looking to organize new debt swaps.
“We’re going to take a piece of the debt and use some proceeds for something better, but by no means are we going to solve the big problem,” he said.
Another concern has been that countries might agree to lofty commitments to secure concessions, but then fall to “paper park syndrome” where protections exist only in theory.
However, Gatchev said the commitments are legally binding and governments could incur fees for breaking them.
“Our reputation as the world’s largest conservation organization is on the line here, and we have no incentive to sugarcoat lack of compliance,” he said.
Briceno, for his part, said the high-profile deal had increased environmental consciousness among his people, who were now quick to report illegal mangrove dredging, for instance.
The debt restructure was “a very good start,” he said, but his country needed far more assistance from the Global North.
“Developed countries destroyed their environment to be able to have development: high-rises, big vehicles, nice fancy homes,” Briceno said.
“Now we want the same and you’re telling us: ‘We can’t afford you to destroy what we have destroyed’ — then pay us,” he said.
Malaysia yesterday installed a motorcycle-riding billionaire sultan as its new king in lavish ceremonies for a post seen as a ballast in times of political crises. The coronation ceremony for Malaysia’s King Sultan Ibrahim, 65, at the National Palace in Kuala Lumpur followed his oath-taking in January as the country’s 17th monarch. Malaysia is a constitutional monarchy, with a unique arrangement that sees the throne change hands every five years between the rulers of nine Malaysian states headed by centuries-old Islamic royalty. While chiefly ceremonial, the position of king has in the past few years played an increasingly important role. Royal intervention was
X-37B COMPARISON: China’s spaceplane is most likely testing technology, much like US’ vehicle, said Victoria Samson, an official at the Secure World Foundation China’s shadowy, uncrewed reusable spacecraft, which launches atop a rocket booster and lands at a secretive military airfield, is most likely testing technology, but could also be used for manipulating or retrieving satellites, experts said. The spacecraft, on its third mission, was last month observed releasing an object, moving several kilometers away and then maneuvering back to within a few hundred meters of it. “It’s obvious that it has a military application, including, for example, closely inspecting objects of the enemy or disabling them, but it also has non-military applications,” said Marco Langbroek, a lecturer in optical space situational awareness at Delft
The Philippine Air Force must ramp up pilot training if it is to buy 20 or more multirole fighter jets as it modernizes and expands joint operations with its navy, a commander said yesterday. A day earlier US National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan said that the US “will do what is necessary” to see that the Philippines is able to resupply a ship on the Second Thomas Shoal (Renai Shoal, 仁愛暗沙) that Manila uses to reinforce its claims to the atoll. Sullivan said the US would prefer that the Philippines conducts the resupplies of the small crew on the warship Sierra Madre,
AIRLINES RECOVERING: Two-thirds of the flights canceled on Saturday due to the faulty CrowdStrike update that hit 8.5 million devices worldwide occurred in the US As the world continues to recover from massive business and travel disruptions caused by a faulty software update from cybersecurity firm CrowdStrike, malicious actors are trying to exploit the situation for their own gain. Government cybersecurity agencies across the globe and CrowdStrike CEO George Kurtz are warning businesses and individuals around the world about new phishing schemes that involve malicious actors posing as CrowdStrike employees or other tech specialists offering to assist those recovering from the outage. “We know that adversaries and bad actors will try to exploit events like this,” Kurtz said in a statement. “I encourage everyone to remain vigilant