Researchers claimed on Wednesday that the common estimate of 5.4 million deaths because of the war in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DR Congo) was vastly inflated.
The Human Security Report 2009: The Shrinking Costs of War, released on Wednesday at the UN in New York, challenged the research used to arrive at the figure, saying “estimates of the Democratic Republic of the Congo’s war death toll are at least twice as high as they should be.”
The shocking death toll estimate has been used worldwide to bolster political support for a massive UN peacekeeping mission and humanitarian aid in the heart of Africa.
The estimate of 5.4 million war deaths — most from indirect causes, including starvation and disease, since war began in 1998 — was calculated from a series of five surveys by the International Rescue Committee (IRC) and, in two of the surveys, by the Burnet Institute of Australia.
But Andrew Mack, former strategic planning director to former UN secretary-general Kofi Annan and now director of the Human Security Report Project at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, criticized the survey methods.
For example, the IRC assumed the DR Congo’s mortality rate before the war was the same as the average rate in sub-Saharan Africa — but in fact, conditions in the DR Congo were far worse than the regional average even before the war, he said.
By substituting a “more appropriate” pre-war mortality rate in the IRC data, Mack estimated 900,000 people died between 2001 and 2007 who would have lived had there been no war — far fewer than the IRC estimate of 2.83 million, which Mack suggested included deaths that would have occurred anyway.
Mack did not give his own estimate for a death toll.
But he noted the first two of the IRC surveys were not done in a randomly selected area on a representative population, as is standard in statistical research.
The IRC and the Burnet Institute responded with a joint e-mail to Agence France-Presse that they “strongly affirm” findings “based on standard and scientifically grounded methodology [and which] remain the best estimates available of conflict-related mortality in Congo.”
The e-mail said researchers previously acknowledged the criticisms raised by the Human Security Report, which “do not invalidate our findings ... our estimates have been supported by numerous other studies.”
“We believe this information is valid and that it has been and continues to be of essential value to public health and political decision-makers,” the IRC and Burnet said.
The Human Security Report 2009 said estimates of war death tolls in Iraq, Sudan and now the DR Congo have become controversial and highly politicized.
Mack said disputes put billions of dollars in humanitarian aid at risk by “discrediting population health surveys as a whole.”
“Policy makers need to have hard data ... anything that questions the credibility of these surveys is a bad thing,” he said.
In the sweltering streets of Jakarta, buskers carry towering, hollow puppets and pass around a bucket for donations. Now, they fear becoming outlaws. City authorities said they would crack down on use of the sacred ondel-ondel puppets, which can stand as tall as a truck, and they are drafting legislation to remove what they view as a street nuisance. Performances featuring the puppets — originally used by Jakarta’s Betawi people to ward off evil spirits — would be allowed only at set events. The ban could leave many ondel-ondel buskers in Jakarta jobless. “I am confused and anxious. I fear getting raided or even
Eleven people, including a former minister, were arrested in Serbia on Friday over a train station disaster in which 16 people died. The concrete canopy of the newly renovated station in the northern city of Novi Sad collapsed on Nov. 1, 2024 in a disaster widely blamed on corruption and poor oversight. It sparked a wave of student-led protests and led to the resignation of then-Serbian prime minister Milos Vucevic and the fall of his government. The public prosecutor’s office in Novi Sad opened an investigation into the accident and deaths. In February, the public prosecutor’s office for organized crime opened another probe into
RISING RACISM: A Japanese group called on China to assure safety in the country, while the Chinese embassy in Tokyo urged action against a ‘surge in xenophobia’ A Japanese woman living in China was attacked and injured by a man in a subway station in Suzhou, China, Japanese media said, hours after two Chinese men were seriously injured in violence in Tokyo. The attacks on Thursday raised concern about xenophobic sentiment in China and Japan that have been blamed for assaults in both countries. It was the third attack involving Japanese living in China since last year. In the two previous cases in China, Chinese authorities have insisted they were isolated incidents. Japanese broadcaster NHK did not identify the woman injured in Suzhou by name, but, citing the Japanese
RESTRUCTURE: Myanmar’s military has ended emergency rule and announced plans for elections in December, but critics said the move aims to entrench junta control Myanmar’s military government announced on Thursday that it was ending the state of emergency declared after it seized power in 2021 and would restructure administrative bodies to prepare for the new election at the end of the year. However, the polls planned for an unspecified date in December face serious obstacles, including a civil war raging over most of the country and pledges by opponents of the military rule to derail the election because they believe it can be neither free nor fair. Under the restructuring, Myanmar’s junta chief Min Aung Hlaing is giving up two posts, but would stay at the
RSS