A senior British judge said yesterday that Prime Minister Tony Blair's government did not act in a "dishonorable, underhand or duplicitous" way in its handling of a British expert on Iraqi weapons who committed suicide.
Appeals judge Lord Hutton strongly criticized the BBC for inaccurately reporting that Blair's government had "sexed up" a dossier on Iraq's weapons before the war with intelligence information it knew to be exaggerated or unreliable. The judge said the BBC report was unfounded, and he criticized BBC editors and officials for failing to fully investigate after the government had complained about it.
The nationally televised decision by Hutton after gathering months of evidence regarding the death of weapons expert David Kelly appeared to exonerate Blair after the biggest crisis of his seven years in office. The BBC report had challenged his integrity and the case he had made for British forces joining the war against Iraq.
PHOTO: REUTERS
Hutton sharply criticized the publicly funded BBC's "defective" handling of BBC reporter Andrew Gilligan's story, saying the network's editors had failed to properly check his allegations and did not properly investigate the government's complaints about his report.
Hutton criticized the governors of the BBC for failing to make their own detailed investigation to discover whether Gilligan's notes supported his report.
"If they'd had done this, they would probably have discovered that the notes did not support the allegation that the government probably knew that the 45-minutes claim was probably wrong," Hutton said.
Hutton criticized the board "for failing to give proper and adequate consideration to whether the BBC should publicly acknowledge that this very grave allegation should not have been broadcast."
The BBC report had claimed that a government statement that Iraqi forces could deploy weapons of mass destruction within 45 minutes was based on false intelligence that officials knew was unreliable. The report suggested the government "sexed up" or exaggerated its claims about Iraqi weapons to boost the case for war at a time when many people in Britain opposed going to war.
Blair's government denounced the report and demanded a retraction, setting off a huge public dispute with the nation's largest broadcaster.
Critics had accused the government and Blair personally of cynically exposing Kelly to massive media scrutiny, thereby contributing to his death. Kelly's body was found near his home in a rural area in July, his left wrist slashed.
Hutton said the government acted "reasonably" in confirming Kelly's identity after he told his superiors he was probably the source of Gilligan's story. Kelly, however, denied telling Gilligan that the 45-minute claim was false.
The judge said the government would have been guilty of a cover up if it had tried to conceal Kelly's identity.
"The issuing of the statement was not part of a dishonorable or underhand or duplicitous strategy to leak Dr. Kelly's name covertly in order to assist the government in its battle with the BBC," Hutton said.
While largely exonerating the government's handling of the matter, Hutton said Ministry of Defense officials could have given Kelly more help when they confirmed his identity to the media. But Hutton said Kelly was an intensely private man and "not easy to help."
The judge agreed with an expert witness at the inquiry that a loss of self esteem and feelings of hopelessness and despair might have contributed to Kelly's suicide.
Hutton said he was satisfied that nobody involved in the matter could have foreseen that Kelly would take his own life after he was named as the anonymous source of the controversial BBC report.
"I am satisfied that none of the persons whose decisions and actions I later describe ever contemplated that Dr. Kelly might take his own life. I'm further satisfied that none of those persons was at fault in not contemplating that Dr. Kelly might take his own life," Hutton said.
RIGHTS FEARS: A protester said Beijing would use the embassy to catch and send Hong Kongers to China, while a lawmaker said Chinese agents had threatened Britons Hundreds of demonstrators on Saturday protested at a site earmarked for Beijing’s controversial new embassy in London over human rights and security concerns. The new embassy — if approved by the British government — would be the “biggest Chinese embassy in Europe,” one lawmaker said earlier. Protester Iona Boswell, a 40-year-old social worker, said there was “no need for a mega embassy here” and that she believed it would be used to facilitate the “harassment of dissidents.” China has for several years been trying to relocate its embassy, currently in the British capital’s upmarket Marylebone district, to the sprawling historic site in the
A deluge of disinformation about a virus called hMPV is stoking anti-China sentiment across Asia and spurring unfounded concerns of renewed lockdowns, despite experts dismissing comparisons with the COVID-19 pandemic five years ago. Agence France-Presse’s fact-checkers have debunked a slew of social media posts about the usually non-fatal respiratory disease human metapneumovirus after cases rose in China. Many of these posts claimed that people were dying and that a national emergency had been declared. Garnering tens of thousands of views, some posts recycled old footage from China’s draconian lockdowns during the COVID-19 pandemic, which originated in the country in late
French police on Monday arrested a man in his 20s on suspicion of murder after an 11-year-old girl was found dead in a wood south of Paris over the weekend in a killing that sparked shock and a massive search for clues. The girl, named as Louise, was found stabbed to death in the Essonne region south of Paris in the night of Friday to Saturday, police said. She had been missing since leaving school on Friday afternoon and was found just a few hundred meters from her school. A police source, who asked not to be named, said that she had been
BACK TO BATTLE: North Korean soldiers have returned to the front lines in Russia’s Kursk region after earlier reports that Moscow had withdrawn them following heavy losses Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy on Friday pored over a once-classified map of vast deposits of rare earths and other critical minerals as part of a push to appeal to US President Donald Trump’s penchant for a deal. The US president, whose administration is pressing for a rapid end to Ukraine’s war with Russia, on Monday said he wanted Ukraine to supply the US with rare earths and other minerals in return for financially supporting its war effort. “If we are talking about a deal, then let’s do a deal, we are only for it,” Zelenskiy said, emphasizing Ukraine’s need for security guarantees