The High Court yesterday ordered former Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) legislator Lee De-wei (李德維) to pay NT$600,000 (US$19,023) to former minister of health and welfare Hsueh Jui-yuan (薛瑞元) and former Centers for Disease Control (CDC) director-general Chou Jih-haw (周志浩) each for defamation.
Lee cannot appeal the sentence, while Hsueh and Chou can, the ruling said.
In 2022, Lee said Hsueh and Chou attempted to benefit Medigen by purchasing COVID-19 vaccines from the company.
Photo: Wang Yi-song, Taipei Times
After the investigation, prosecutors did not indict Hsueh or Chou, both of whom later filed defamation lawsuits against Lee, demanding NT$2 million in compensation.
Hsueh and Chou said that, as a legislator, Lee was aware as legislator that the vaccine effectiveness report submitted by the company was not made with CDC assistance, but he nonetheless accused the ministry of favoring Medigen with policies and the amendment of the Regulations for Approval of Specific Medicinal Products’ Manufacturing or Importing as a Special Case (特定藥品專案核准製造及輸入辦法).
They said that Lee’s suit, filed with the Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office on Nov 9, 2022, which said that Hsueh and Chou had “knowingly contravened the law” and were “despicable,” had damaged their reputations.
The incident was in the public interest, Lee said, adding that there were media reports at the time that could support his queries.
The Taipei District Court said that Lee’s defamatory comments without reasonable verification had damaged Hsueh’s and Chou’s reputations, and ruled that Lee should pay them each NT$600,000.
Hsueh and Chou appealed the ruling, and the High Court ruled that the CDC was within its authority to file for emergency authorization for the vaccines under Article 3 of the act, as well as that the CDC’s request was not related to Medigen’s own application.
CDC information compiled for its emergency authorization was based on Article 3 of the Human Subject Research Act (人體研究法), which was not related to the ministry’s amendment for the special case approval regulations, the High Court ruling said.
Lee’s accusations incorrectly linked the legal amendments and Medigen’s report submission date, misleading the public into believing that the CDC had helped draft Medigen’s report, it said.
Lee’s efforts were a deliberate attempt to undermine the public’s trust in Hsueh and Chou by smearing their reputations, it said, upholding the district court’s ruling.
UNREASONABLE SURVEILLANCE: A camera targeted on an road by a neighbor captured a man’s habitual unsignaled turn into home, netting him dozens of tickets The Taichung High Administrative Court has canceled all 45 tickets given to a man for failing to use a turn signal while driving, as it considered long-term surveillance of his privacy more problematic than the traffic violations. The man, surnamed Tseng (曾), lives in Changhua County and was reported 45 times within a month for failing to signal while driving when he turned into the alley where his residence is. The reports were filed by his neighbor, who set up security cameras that constantly monitored not only the alley but also the door and yard of Tseng’s house. The surveillance occurred from July
A Japan Self-Defense Forces vessel entered the Taiwan Strait yesterday, Japanese media reported. After passing through the Taiwan Strait, the Ikazuchi was to proceed to the South China Sea to take part in a joint military exercise with the US and the Philippines, the reports said. Japan Self-Defense Force vessels were first reported to have passed through the strait in September, 2024, with two further transits taking place in February and June last year, the Asahi Shimbun reported. Yesterday’s transit also marked the first time since Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi took office that a Japanese warship has been sent through the Taiwan
‘SAME OLD TRICK’: Even if Beijing resumes individual travel to Taiwan, it would only benefit Chinese tourism companies, the Economic Democracy Union convener said China’s 10 new “incentives” are “sugar-coated poison,” an official said yesterday, adding that Taiwanese businesses see them clearly for what they are, but that Beijing would inevitably find some local collaborators to try to drums up support. The official, speaking on condition of anonymity, made the remark ahead of a news conference the General Chamber of Commerce is to hold today. The event, titled “Industry Perspectives on China’s Recent Pro-Taiwan Policies,” is expected to include representatives from industry associations — such as those in travel, hotels, food and agriculture — to request the government cooperate with China’s new measures, people familiar with
ANOTHER OPTION: The 13-year-old, whose residency status was revoked for holding a Chinese passport, could still apply for residency on humanitarian grounds, the government said The Executive Yuan has rejected an appeal from a 13-year-old Chinese student surnamed Lu (陸), whose permanent residency was revoked after immigration officers discovered he held a Chinese passport. Lu in December 2023 applied to settle in Taiwan to be with his mother, surnamed Lin (林), who is a Taiwan resident, an appeal decision released this month by the Executive Yuan showed. Lin settled in Taiwan after marrying a Taiwanese man in 2003, but the two divorced in 2011, and after marrying a Chinese man, she had Lu, the Executive Yuan’s appeals committee said. Lu’s application was approved in December 2024, and in
RSS