The Constitutional Court yesterday struck down some penalties for failing to pay National Health Insurance (NHI) premiums, after finding the formula disproportionately harsh to the offense.
Five of the justices ruled on the matter, while the remaining three opted to abstain.
The absentees were the same justices who dissented from a previous ruling against a Legislative Yuan bill to change the quorum of judges, which with its current number would deem the Constitutional Court unable to function.
Photo: Taipei Times
The latest case, the court’s second of the year, concerned Article 85 of the National Health Insurance Act (全民健康保險法), which authorizes the government to fine policyholders double the amount owed, or triple if they fail to pay the first time by a deadline.
The justices said using multiples of the sum owed as the sole criterion for calculating fines breached the constitutional right to property and due process, including proportionality of punishments.
The law must be amended so that regulators would take the circumstances surrounding missed premiums into account before imposing a fine, it said.
The Ministry of Health and Welfare must follow the spirit of the court’s ruling to the best of its ability until the law is changed, the court said.
The plaintiff, a business owner surnamed Chen (陳), did not pay the insurance premium for some of their employees and received the triple fine as a result.
Chen filed a lawsuit against the ministry, saying the penalties contravened articles 15, 23 and 153 of the Constitution, respectively governing the right to property, due process and labor protections.
Chen lost at every level of the administrative courts before appealing to the Constitutional Court.
Department of Social Insurance Director Chang Yu-hsuan (張鈺璇) said the ministry is to change the act to comply with the judgement.
The ministry would exercise discretion to reduce the amount of fines if the situation warrants it, she said.
Reliable payment of premiums is a cornerstone of the nation’s health insurance system, Chang added.
The absentee justices told a news conference that they do not believe the Constitutional Court could be lawfully convened, as the amendments to the Constitutional Court Procedure Act (憲法訴訟法) — which the court struck down — require nine judges to make a quorum.
They additionally said the NHI law already includes a provision limiting the maximum amount of fines that could be imposed for missed payments, which satisfies the constitutional benchmarks for proportionality.
The manufacture of the remaining 28 M1A2T Abrams tanks Taiwan purchased from the US has recently been completed, and they are expected to be delivered within the next one to two months, a source said yesterday. The Ministry of National Defense is arranging cargo ships to transport the tanks to Taiwan as soon as possible, said the source, who is familiar with the matter. The estimated arrival time ranges from late this month to early next month, the source said. The 28 Abrams tanks make up the third and final batch of a total of 108 tanks, valued at about NT$40.5 billion
Travel agencies in Taiwan are working to secure alternative flights for travelers bound for New Zealand for the Lunar New Year holiday, as Air New Zealand workers are set to strike next week. The airline said that it has confirmed that the planned industrial action by its international wide-body cabin crew would go ahead on Thursday and Friday next week. While the Auckland-based carrier pledged to take reasonable measures to mitigate the impact of the workers’ strike, an Air New Zealand flight arriving at Taipei from Auckland on Thursday and another flight departing from Taipei for Auckland on Saturday would have to
A group from the Taiwanese Designers in Australia association yesterday represented Taiwan at the Midsumma Pride March in Melbourne. The march, held in the St. Kilda suburb, is the city’s largest LGBTQIA+ parade and the flagship event of the annual Midsumma Festival. It attracted more than 45,000 spectators who supported the 400 groups and 10,000 marchers that participated this year, the association said. Taiwanese Designers said they organized a team to march for Taiwan this year, joining politicians, government agencies, professionals and community organizations in showing support for LGBTQIA+ people and diverse communities. As the first country in Asia to legalize same-sex
MOTIVES QUESTIONED The PLA considers Xi’s policies toward Taiwan to be driven by personal considerations rather than military assessment, the Epoch Times reports Chinese President Xi Jinping’s (習近平) latest purge of the Chinese People’s Liberation Army (PLA) leadership might have been prompted by the military’s opposition to plans of invading Taiwan, the Epoch Times said. The Chinese military opposes waging war against Taiwan by a large consensus, putting it at odds with Xi’s vision, the Falun Gong-affiliated daily said in a report on Thursday, citing anonymous sources with insight into the PLA’s inner workings. The opposition is not the opinion of a few generals, but a widely shared view among the PLA cadre, the Epoch Times cited them as saying. “Chinese forces know full well that
RSS