The High Court’s Tainan branch this month upheld a lower court’s ruling denying a man’s claim of self-defense after he pepper-sprayed his neighbor. The ruling is final and cannot be appealed.
On Aug. 10 last year, the defendant, surnamed Chuang (莊), was standing in the courtyard of his residence, arguing with his neighbor, court documents said.
The neighbor approached the gate and at one point extended his left hand over the top of the gate, pointing his finger at Chuang, the documents said.
Photo: CNA
Chuang took out pepper spray and sprayed the neighbor in his face, they said.
The neighbor experienced a burning sensation and sought medical attention before pressing charges against Chuang.
The judge in the initial trial in May concluded that while the neighbor had provoked Chuang and extended his hand over the gate, he did not actually open the gate and enter, nor did he physically assault Chuang.
If Chuang had genuinely been concerned for his personal safety, he could have kept his distance or called the police, the court concluded, adding that Chuang chose to confront the neighbor and pepper spray them.
This was not self-defense, but constituted assault, the court ruled.
In an appeal, Chuang said he had been repeatedly harassed by the neighbor for an extended period, and had often called the police and filed complaints.
During the incident last year, the neighbor yelled in front of his door, approached and grabbed the iron gate, Chuang said, adding that his elderly and infirm grandmother was standing near the gate, and he was concerned the neighbor might break in and harm her.
He used the pepper spray after repeatedly shouting “leave” and warning the neighbor that it was pepper spray, he said, adding that he believed he was protecting himself and his family.
After reviewing the surveillance footage, the High Court said the footage did not show the neighbor opening the gate or attacking.
Chuang did not experience any physical confrontation, nor was there any unlawful invasion, it said.
Chuang used the pepper spray, believing he was about to be attacked, but this did not meet the requirements for legitimate self-defense, it said, adding that the situation did not justify assault.
The Central Weather Administration (CWA) today issued a sea warning for Typhoon Fung-wong effective from 5:30pm, while local governments canceled school and work for tomorrow. A land warning is expected to be issued tomorrow morning before it is expected to make landfall on Wednesday, the agency said. Taoyuan, and well as Yilan, Hualien and Penghu counties canceled work and school for tomorrow, as well as mountainous district of Taipei and New Taipei City. For updated information on closures, please visit the Directorate-General of Personnel Administration Web site. As of 5pm today, Fung-wong was about 490km south-southwest of Oluanpi (鵝鑾鼻), Taiwan's southernmost point.
A magnitude 5.3 earthquake struck Kaohsiung at 1pm today, the Central Weather Administration said. The epicenter was in Jiasian District (甲仙), 72.1km north-northeast of Kaohsiung City Hall, at a depth of 7.8km, agency data showed. There were no immediate reports of damage. The earthquake's intensity, which gauges the actual effects of a temblor, was highest in Kaohsiung and Tainan, where it measured a 4 on Taiwan's seven-tier intensity scale. It also measured a 3 in parts of Chiayi City, as well as Pingtung, Yunlin and Hualien counties, data showed.
Nearly 5 million people have signed up to receive the government’s NT$10,000 (US$322) universal cash handout since registration opened on Wednesday last week, with deposits expected to begin tomorrow, the Ministry of Finance said yesterday. After a staggered sign-up last week — based on the final digit of the applicant’s national ID or Alien Resident Certificate number — online registration is open to all eligible Taiwanese nationals, foreign permanent residents and spouses of Taiwanese nationals. Banks are expected to start issuing deposits from 6pm today, the ministry said. Those who completed registration by yesterday are expected to receive their NT$10,000 tomorrow, National Treasury
Taiwan next year plans to launch its first nationwide census on elderly people living independently to identify the estimated 700,000 seniors to strengthen community-based healthcare and long-term care services, the Ministry of Health and Welfare (MOHW) said yesterday. Minister of Health and Welfare Shih Chung-liang (石崇良) said on the sidelines of a healthcare seminar that the nation’s rapidly aging population and declining birthrate have made the issue of elderly people living alone increasingly pressing. The survey, to be jointly conducted by the MOHW and the Ministry of the Interior, aims to establish baseline data and better allocate care resources, he
RSS