Lax enforcement and judicial negligence resulted in the death of a woman and her sister in New Taipei’s Tucheng District (土城) on Monday, the father of the two victims said yesterday.
The father, surnamed Chang (張), told reporters that a restraining order had been issued against the suspect, surnamed Hsieh (謝), who had abused one of the victims, who was his wife, for many years.
“She [the wife] had applied for a restraining order [in May] because of Hsieh’s violent temper and constant beatings. He had no income and depended on our family to provide for him,” Chang said.
Photo: Wu Jen-chieh, Taipei Times
“When Hsieh learned that she had filed for divorce and obtained a restraining order, he got angry and issued death threats, saying he would kill her, as well as her father,” Chang said.
After a court hearing on Monday, Hsieh allegedly rammed his car into a scooter carrying the two female riders and used a large kitchen knife to stab them to death in broad daylight.
The prosecutors and the judge are also to blame for failing to enforce the restraining order and allowing Hsieh to go free after Monday’s divorce hearing at the New Taipei City Family Court (家事庭), which led to the tragedy, the father said.
Hsieh had already violated the restraining order many times, which was granted on June 25, he said.
“Hsieh took no heed and continued to come and threaten our family, as he did last week. He forced his way [into our house] and broke things. We called the police to take him away, but the officers said they could only detain him for eight hours, and must then release him. They advised us to careful and to go outside only when necessary,” he said.
“The Family Court session on Monday was to finalize the divorce ... The judge questioned Hsieh first and then let him go, and then questioned my daughter,” Chang said.
“My daughter requested protection when she applied for a restraining order to stop Hsieh from stalking or approaching her. He was required to maintain a distance of at least 100m from our family. However, prosecutors did not make him wear an electronic leg monitor and he kept on violating the terms of the restraining order also, uttering threats against us. The police failed to provide us with adequate protection,” he said.
Legal experts have cited repeated failures by the judiciary, judges and police in upholding the terms of a restraining order in domestic abuse cases, resulting in tragic deaths in many cases.
They said that about 80 percent of restraining orders were effective, but in 20 percent of the cases, abusers repeatedly broke the terms. Victims’ families have said that law enforcement agencies lack an effective response, fail to provide protection and only act upon after someone is killed.
Lawyer Chen Yu-an (陳宇安) said that Hsieh ignoring the restraining order is in breach of the Domestic Violence Prevention Act (家庭暴力防治法).
“Even when a restraining order is issued by a judge, people cannot depend on it for full protection. It is useful in restraining normal and sensible people, but it is useless against someone with a record of violence and assault or mentally ill people,” Chen said.
“When clients request for help to obtain a restraining order, I always ask them if they feel in immediate danger, or if their life is under threat. If they say yes, I would tell them to leave their home, and go stay in another place for the time being. They should do everything to stay away and hide from domestic abusers, and to do so quickly, as a restraining order is useless when they have been threatened with death. It also takes time police to respond to emergency calls, so people should hide, stay with a friend or at a relative’s place,” Chen said.
The Central Weather Administration (CWA) today issued a "tsunami watch" alert after a magnitude 8.7 earthquake struck off the Kamchatka Peninsula in northeastern Russia earlier in the morning. The quake struck off the east coast of the Kamchatka Peninsula at 7:25am (Taiwan time) at a depth of about 19km, the CWA said, citing figures from the Pacific Tsunami Warning Center. The CWA's Seismological Center said preliminary assessments indicate that a tsunami could reach Taiwan's coastal areas by 1:18pm today. The CWA urged residents along the coast to stay alert and take necessary precautions as waves as high as 1m could hit the southeastern
The National Museum of Taiwan Literature is next month to hold an exhibition in Osaka, Japan, showcasing the rich and unique history of Taiwanese folklore and literature. The exhibition, which is to run from Aug. 10 to Aug. 20 at the city’s Central Public Hall, is part of the “We Taiwan” at Expo 2025 series, highlighting Taiwan’s cultural ties with the international community, National Museum of Taiwan Literature director Chen Ying-fang (陳瑩芳) said. Folklore and literature, among Taiwan’s richest cultural heritages, naturally deserve a central place in the global dialogue, Chen said. Taiwan’s folklore would be immediately apparent at the entrance of the
“China is preparing to invade Taiwan,” Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Francois Wu (吳志中) said in an exclusive interview with British media channel Sky News for a special report titled, “Is Taiwan ready for a Chinese invasion?” the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said today in a statement. The 25-minute-long special report by Helen Ann-Smith released yesterday saw Sky News travel to Penghu, Taoyuan and Taipei to discuss the possibility of a Chinese invasion and how Taiwan is preparing for an attack. The film observed emergency response drills, interviewed baseball fans at the Taipei Dome on their views of US President
Speeding and badly maintained roads were the main causes of a school bus accident on a rainy day in Taipei last year that severely injured two people and left 22 with minor injuries, the Taiwan Transportation and Safety Board said. On March 11 last year, a Kang Chiao International School bus overturned inside the Wenshan Tunnel (文山隧道) on the northbound lane of the Xinyi Expressway. The tour bus, owned by Long Lai Co, exceeded the speed limit after entering the tunnel, the board’s investigation found. Sensing that the rear of the vehicle was swaying, the driver attempted to use the service and exhaust
RSS