The Supreme Court today remanded the case of a man sentenced to death for fatally shooting four people in central Taiwan in 2022, amid a tightening of the nation's criteria for imposing capital punishment.
The court ruled that the High Court must separately assess the sentences for multiple crimes committed by Lee Hung-yuan (李鴻淵), a former employee of Nantou County-based biotech contract manufacturer Kang Jian, citing Judgement No. 113-Hsien-Pan-8, issued in September last year.
Photo: Chang Wen-chuan, Taipei Times
In that judgement, the Constitutional Court ruled that the death penalty is constitutional only for the "most serious" premeditated crimes that result in death — widely interpreted as a "de facto" step toward abolition of capital punishment.
Today's ruling marked a major shift in the case, after both the Nantou District Court and the Taichung branch of the High Court had previously imposed and upheld the death sentences against Lee.
On July 14, 2022, Lee killed the brother and daughter of Kang Jian chairman Lai Min-nan (賴敏男), as well as two employees surnamed Chang (張) and Liu (劉).
He also shot Lai in the head, although Lai survived.
The district court sentenced Lee to three death sentences and one life sentence for the murders.
Despite pleading guilty, the culprit appealed the ruling.
The Taichung branch of the High Court upheld the verdict in December 2023, ruling that Lee's actions constituted "the most serious crimes" defined by the UN.
Citing a forensic psychiatric evaluation indicating a low likelihood of rehabilitation, the High Court concluded that the death penalty was the only means to uphold justice and maintain social order.
Lee filed another appeal.
In March last year, the Supreme Court upheld his life sentence, but it did not immediately review the death sentences.
Instead, the court awaited a Constitutional Court ruling on the legality of capital punishment, following petitions for extraordinary appeals filed by 37 death row inmates.
Since President William Lai (賴清德) took office in May last year, only one inmate, Huang Lin-kai (黃麟凱) — one of the 37 petitioners — has been executed.
Huang was sentenced to death in 2017 for the Oct. 1, 2013, rape and murder of his ex-girlfriend and the murder of her mother in New Taipei City's Sanchong District (三重).
Two death row inmates were executed during former president Tsai Ing-wen's (蔡英文) two terms from 2016 to last year, while 33 executions were carried out during former president Ma Ying-jeou's (馬英九) administration from 2008 to 2016.
“China is preparing to invade Taiwan,” Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Francois Wu (吳志中) said in an exclusive interview with British media channel Sky News for a special report titled, “Is Taiwan ready for a Chinese invasion?” the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said today in a statement. The 25-minute-long special report by Helen Ann-Smith released yesterday saw Sky News travel to Penghu, Taoyuan and Taipei to discuss the possibility of a Chinese invasion and how Taiwan is preparing for an attack. The film observed emergency response drills, interviewed baseball fans at the Taipei Dome on their views of US President
ECONOMIC BENEFITS: The imports from Belize would replace those from Honduras, whose shrimp exports have dropped 67 percent since cutting ties in 2023 Maintaining ties with Taiwan has economic benefits, Ministry of Foreign Affairs officials said yesterday, citing the approval of frozen whiteleg shrimp imports from Belize by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) as an example. The FDA on Wednesday approved the tariff-free imports from Belize after the whiteleg shrimp passed the Systematic Inspection of Imported Food, which would continue to boost mutual trade, the ministry said. Taiwan’s annual consumption of whiteleg shrimps stands at 30,000 tonnes, far exceeding domestic production, the ministry said. Taiwan used to fill the gap by importing shrimps from Honduras, but purchases slumped after Tegucigalpa severed diplomatic ties with Taiwan
The Executive Yuan yesterday approved a southwestern extension of the Sanying MRT Line from New Taipei to Bade District (八德) in Taoyuan, with a goal of starting construction by late 2026. The 4.03-kilometer extension, featuring three new stations, will run from the current terminus at Yingtao Fude Station (LB12) in New Taipei City to Dannan Station (LB14), where it will connect with Taoyuan’s Green Line, New Taipei City Metro Corp said in a statement. This extension will follow the completion of core Sanying Line, a 14.29-kilometer medium-capacity system linking Tucheng (土城), Sansia (三峽)
CARGO LOSS: About 50 containers at the stern of the ‘Ever Lunar’ cargo ship went overboard, prompting the temporary closure of the port and disrupting operations Evergreen Marine Corp, Taiwan’s largest container shipper, yesterday said that all crew members aboard the Ever Lunar (長月) were safe after dozens of containers fell overboard off the coast of Peru the previous day. The incident occurred at 9:40am on Friday as the Ever Lunar was anchored and waiting to enter the Port of Callao when it suddenly experienced severe rolling, Evergreen said in a statement. The rolling, which caused the containers to fall, might have been caused by factors including a tsunami triggered by an earthquake in Russia, poor winter sea conditions in South America or a sudden influx of waves,
RSS