A Changhua man has been fined NT$12,000 in a civil suit for calling a woman an “idiot.”
The man, surnamed Chen (陳), last year was involved in a quarrel with a woman surnamed Liu (劉) over right of way in a parking lot at a hypermarket in Taichung, the Changhua District Court said in its ruling on Friday.
Chen called Liu an “idiot” after she refused to move her car for him, the court said.
Photo: Taipei Times
He was fined NT$3,000 in a criminal case of public insult.
Liu pressed a claim for civil compensation, saying that Chen’s name-calling resulted in anxiety and depression, the ruling said.
She was frightened to drive or go out and was diagnosed with depression at Yuanlin Christian Hospital, the court said, adding that she was on sick leave for six months due to the condition.
Her monthly wage was NT$60,000, it said.
She sought NT$590,680, with NT$330,000 for loss of salary, NT$250,000 in solatium, NT$6,500 for medical expenses and more than NT$4,100 for transportation to the hospital, the ruling said.
Chen offered NT$50,000 in compensation in exchange for immunity from criminal complaint, but Liu rejected the offer, it said.
The civil compensation claim did not meet the principle of proportionality, he told the court.
The word “idiot” would not cause a target of the insult to have depression, while such serious mental problems from a one-off incident seems questionable, the ruling said.
Given that the two parties did not know each other prior to the incident, the defendant would not have known the plaintiff had a mental disease, it said.
As the plaintiff could not prove that her depression was a result of a one-off incident of being called an “idiot,” her claim for compensation for medical expenses, transportation and salary loss was groundless, it said, adding that NT$12,000 in solatium was proper.
Taiwan is to commence mass production of the Tien Kung (天弓, “Sky Bow”) III, IV and V missiles by the second quarter of this year if the legislature approves the government’s NT$1.25 trillion (US$39.78 billion) special defense budget, an official said yesterday. Commenting on condition of anonymity, a defense official with knowledge of the matter said that the advanced systems are expected to provide crucial capabilities against ballistic and cruise missiles for the proposed “T-Dome,” an advanced, multi-layered air defense network. The Tien Kung III is an air defense missile with a maximum interception altitude of 35km. The Tien Kung IV and V
The disruption of 941 flights in and out of Taiwan due to China’s large-scale military exercises was no accident, but rather the result of a “quasi-blockade” used to simulate creating the air and sea routes needed for an amphibious landing, a military expert said. The disruptions occurred on Tuesday and lasted about 10 hours as China conducted live-fire drills in the Taiwan Strait. The Civil Aviation Administration (CAA) said the exercises affected 857 international flights and 84 domestic flights, affecting more than 100,000 travelers. Su Tzu-yun (蘇紫雲), a research fellow at the government-sponsored Institute for National Defense and Security Research, said the air
A strong continental cold air mass is to bring pollutants to Taiwan from tomorrow, the Ministry of Environment said today, as it issued an “orange” air quality alert for most of the country. All of Taiwan except for Hualien and Taitung counties is to be under an “orange” air quality alert tomorrow, indicating air quality that is unhealthy for sensitive groups. In China, areas from Shandong to Shanghai have been enveloped in haze since Saturday, the ministry said in a news release. Yesterday, hourly concentrations of PM2.5 in these areas ranged from 65 to 160 micrograms per cubic meter (mg/m³), and pollutants were
Taiwan’s armed forces have established response protocols for a wide range of sudden contingencies, including the “Wan Chun Plan” to protect the head of state, the Ministry of Defense (MND) said today. After US President Donald Trump on Saturday launched a series of airstrikes in Venezuela and kidnapped Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro, concerns have been raised as to whether China would launch a similar “decapitation strike” on Taiwan. The armed forces regularly coordinate with relevant agencies and practice drills to ensure preparedness for a wide range of scenarios, Vice Minister of National Defense Hsu Szu-chien (徐斯儉) told reporters before a
RSS