The Constitutional Court yesterday ruled that insulting public officials is punishable under the Constitution, while defaming a public office is not.
The court sent a case about criticism of an official back to the Taiwan High Court for a retrial based on the interpretation.
The defendant, Yang Hui-ju (楊蕙如), in 2022 was found guilty of contravening Article 140 of the Criminal Code after Yang allegedly paid people to post criticism online of the Taiwan Economic and Cultural Office’s Osaka branch over its handling of evacuations of Taiwanese from Japan following a 2018 typhoon.
Photo: Wen Yu-te, Taipei Times
Su Chii-cherng (蘇啟誠), who was director-general of the office at the time, committed suicide in his residence shortly after the criticism began.
Article 140 stipulates a prison sentence of up to one year or a fine of up to NT$100,000 for “insult[ing] a public official during the discharge of his legal duties or publicly mak[ing] insults about his discharge of such legal duties.”
The office was accused by members of the public of failing to offer aid to Taiwanese when Kansai International Airport flooded when Typhoon Jebi hit Japan in 2018.
Yang sought a constitutional interpretation, saying that Article 140 contravenes constitutionally guaranteed free speech.
At a discussion at the Constitutional Court last year, a Ministry of Justice representative said that insulting public officials was not a crime unique to Taiwan and that those working on behalf of the country should be protected.
The Constitutional Court said that Article 140 has two parts, one referring to “slandering or defaming a public official” and one to “slandering or defaming a public office.”
Regarding the former part, if defamation is immediate and intended to obstruct an official, it should be punished, which would not contravene Article 11 of the Constitution, it said.
Article 11 says: “The people shall have freedom of speech, teaching, writing and publication.”
However, people are entitled to question, criticize or comment on the decisions of an office, as this is a part of democracy and civic oversight, it said.
Even if a member of the public were to simply curse the office or direct vulgar language at it as a means of venting their frustration, it would still be within their free-speech rights, it said.
It is difficult to imagine public defamation of an office having any immediate or noticeable effect on public officials carrying out their jobs, so criminalization under Article 140 would contravene the Constitution, it added.
Additional reporting by CNA
‘WORSE THAN COMMUNISTS’: President William Lai has cracked down on his political enemies and has attempted to exterminate all opposition forces, the chairman said The legislature would motion for a presidential recall after May 20, Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Chairman Eric Chu (朱立倫) said yesterday at a protest themed “against green communists and dictatorship” in Taipei. Taiwan is supposed to be a peaceful homeland where people are united, but President William Lai (賴清德) has been polarizing and tearing apart society since his inauguration, Chu said. Lai must show his commitment to his job, otherwise a referendum could be initiated to recall him, he said. Democracy means the rule of the people, not the rule of the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), but Lai has failed to fulfill his
OFF-TARGET: More than 30,000 participants were expected to take part in the Games next month, but only 6,550 foreign and 19,400 Taiwanese athletes have registered Taipei city councilors yesterday blasted the organizers of next month’s World Masters Games over sudden timetable and venue changes, which they said have caused thousands of participants to back out of the international sporting event, among other organizational issues. They also cited visa delays and political interference by China as reasons many foreign athletes are requesting refunds for the event, to be held from May 17 to 30. Jointly organized by the Taipei and New Taipei City governments, the games have been rocked by numerous controversies since preparations began in 2020. Taipei City Councilor Lin Yen-feng (林延鳳) said yesterday that new measures by
Taiwan would benefit from more integrated military strategies and deployments if the US and its allies treat the East China Sea, the Taiwan Strait and the South China Sea as a “single theater of operations,” a Taiwanese military expert said yesterday. Shen Ming-shih (沈明室), a researcher at the Institute for National Defense and Security Research, said he made the assessment after two Japanese military experts warned of emerging threats from China based on a drill conducted this month by the Chinese People’s Liberation Army’s (PLA) Eastern Theater Command. Japan Institute for National Fundamentals researcher Maki Nakagawa said the drill differed from the
A rally held by opposition parties yesterday demonstrates that Taiwan is a democratic country, President William Lai (賴清德) said yesterday, adding that if opposition parties really want to fight dictatorship, they should fight it on Tiananmen Square in Beijing. The Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) held a protest with the theme “against green communists and dictatorship,” and was joined by the Taiwan People’s Party. Lai said the opposition parties are against what they called the “green communists,” but do not fight against the “Chinese communists,” adding that if they really want to fight dictatorship, they should go to the right place and face
RSS