Google and Meta would never learn to value news content unless legislation mandating the two platforms to negotiate with Taiwanese news media over the pricing of content is passed, media experts said yesterday.
Taiwan’s print and broadcast news media outlets have negotiated with Google and Meta in four meetings in December last year and this week.
Following negotiations in December, Google on March 8 launched a Taiwan News Digital Co-Prosperity Fund, in which it pledged to spend NT$300 million (US$9.85 million) in the next three years to facilitate the digital transformation of Taiwan’s news industry.
Photo: Reuters
However, at a negotiation meeting on Monday, Google claimed that it does not generate profits from news content and merely offers links that bring online traffic to news Web sites.
On Tuesday, Meta told a negotiation meeting that it would not offer a similar co-prosperity plan and argued that it does not post news links on Facebook. Less than 3 percent of Facebook posts contains links to news, it said.
“Minister of Digital Affairs Audrey Tang (唐鳳) has repeatedly said that offering co-prosperity plans and stipulating laws requiring platforms to negotiate with news media over the pricing of the content are not mutually exclusive,” National Taiwan University Graduate Institute of Journalism professor Lin Chao-chen (林照真) said.
“Since Meta rejected any co-prosperity plan and Google refused to acknowledge that news has value, it is time to seriously consider making negotiations over news content mandatory through legislation,” she said.
Google’s claim that it does not generate profits through news content is incorrect, Lin said.
“Google does not produce any content, and yet it has created the brand ‘Google News,’ in which it presents content from different news media. In its search results, it shows headlines, photographs and links to news stories, but Google has never paid to use any of these materials. That is a fact,” she said.
National Cheng Kung University law professor Hsu Hsiao-feng (許曉芬) said that Google’s claim downplayed the “indirect profits” it generates by displaying news content.
“Google can draw users to the platform by showing news headlines and photographs. The traffic has enabled it to gather all sorts of user data, which in turn become incentives for advertisers to place advertisements,” Hsu said, adding that lawsuits between the French Competition Authority and online platforms have all taken their indirect profits into account.
Indirect profits include advertising revenue generated from content on search engines, gathering user data and commission that platforms can collect as intermediaries, Hsu said, adding that one can only accurately gauge profits that a platform earns by taking all these sources of income into consideration.
“Google’s co-prosperity plan requires media outlets to submit proposals, and mandates that each outlet can receive funding for only one project each year. The funding that each outlet receives is no match for the indirect profits that Google earns by posting news headlines and photographs on its platform,” Hsu said.
“The plan looks more like a subsidy program to compensate for the costs that news media spend on digital transformation. Whether the fund can be distributed in an objective, fair, transparent and nondiscriminatory manner remains to be seen,” she added.
National Chengchi University law professor Richard Wang (王立達) has drafted a bill requiring news media and digital platforms to undergo mandatory arbitration if they fail to reach an agreement over the pricing of news content published on digital platforms.
He said he was glad that similar bills have been proposed by Democratic Progressive Party legislators Lin Chu-yin (林楚茵) and Chang Liao Wan-chien (張廖萬堅), and that the legislature’s Transportation Committee would soon review these bills.
The Ministry of Education (MOE) is to launch a new program to encourage international students to stay in Taiwan and explore job opportunities here after graduation, Deputy Minister of Education Yeh Ping-cheng (葉丙成) said on Friday. The government would provide full scholarships for international students to further their studies for two years in Taiwan, so those who want to pursue a master’s degree can consider applying for the program, he said. The fields included are science, technology, engineering, mathematics, semiconductors and finance, Yeh added. The program, called “Intense 2+2,” would also assist international students who completed the two years of further studies in
Former president Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) departed for Europe on Friday night, with planned stops in Lithuania and Denmark. Tsai arrived at Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport on Friday night, but did not speak to reporters before departing. Tsai wrote on social media later that the purpose of the trip was to reaffirm the commitment of Taiwanese to working with democratic allies to promote regional security and stability, upholding freedom and democracy, and defending their homeland. She also expressed hope that through joint efforts, Taiwan and Europe would continue to be partners building up economic resilience on the global stage. The former president was to first
Taiwan will now have four additional national holidays after the Legislative Yuan passed an amendment today, which also made Labor Day a national holiday for all sectors. The Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) used their majority in the Legislative Yuan to pass the amendment to the Act on Implementing Memorial Days and State Holidays (紀念日及節日實施辦法), which the parties jointly proposed, in its third and final reading today. The legislature passed the bill to amend the act, which is currently enforced administratively, raising it to the legal level. The new legislation recognizes Confucius’ birthday on Sept. 28, the
MORE NEEDED: Recall drives against legislators in Miaoli’s two districts and Hsinchu’s second district were still a few thousand signatures short of the second-stage threshold Campaigners aiming to recall Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) legislators yesterday said they expect success in 30 out of 35 districts where drives have passed the second-stage threshold, which would mark a record number of recall votes held at once. Hsinchu County recall campaigners yesterday announced that they reached the second-stage threshold in the recall effort against Legislator Lin Szu-ming (林思銘). A total of 26,414 signatures have been gathered over the past two months, surpassing the 10 percent threshold of 23,287 in Hsinchu County’s second electoral district, chief campaigner Hsieh Ting-ting (謝婷婷) said. “Our target is to gather an additional 1,500 signatures to reach
RSS