The Constitutional Court yesterday heard oral arguments in a gender equality challenge to the Ancestor Worship Guild Act (祭祀公業條例), which bars married women from becoming successors in some guilds.
An ancestor worship guild is a familial organization established to govern the affairs and assets utilized for worship. Successors are members who inherited their positions from its initiators, says the act, which was promulgated in 2008.
Article 4 of the act says that if a guild established before the law was promulgated does not have membership rules, successors should be designated among the men of the family’s patrilineal lineage, the family’s unmarried women or husbands matrilocally married into the family.
Photo: Liao Hseuh-ju, Taipei Times
A woman can become a successor only if two-thirds of current successors or the entire body agrees, the article says.
The lawsuit was filed by the descendants of Chen Ao (陳奧), a married woman who in 2014 was posthumously excluded from the successor list of the Ancestor Worship Guild of Lee Lu (李祿).
Chen’s descendants say the article breaches the principles of equal treatment before the law, freedom of assembly and association, and right to property as outlined in the Constitution.
The plaintiffs said the law also contravenes Article 22 of the Constitution, which states: “All other freedoms and rights of the people that are not detrimental to social order or public welfare shall be guaranteed under the Constitution.”
The article being contested could be traced to the principle of male privilege that had been enshrined in ancient Han Chinese law, National Taiwan University professor of law Wang Tay-sheng (王泰升) told the court.
Although jurors have upheld the patrilineal succession of such guilds from the Japanese colonial period, the legal principle is not compatible with modern understandings of gender equality, Wang said.
The legislative history of the act clearly shows that the government disregarded constitutional protections for gender equality and transformed the discrimination of women from custom into law, National Taipei University law professor Kuan Hsiao-wei (官曉薇) said.
Women are excluded because they do not take part in the rites, not because of their gender, which means there is no discrimination, attorneys for the Ministry of the Interior said.
As guild assets are publicly owned, exclusion from management of a guild’s holdings cannot be said to constitute a deprivation of property rights, they said.
A ruling against the constitutionality of the act would result in the inclusion of successors into guilds in which they play no real role and difficulty in conducting ancestral rites, in addition to creating separate legal systems for guilds created before and after 2008, they said.
Striking out the successorship article would be a breach of customary law, as Taiwanese society deems married women to be members of their husband’s family for purposes of ancestral rites, they said, citing a ministry study on Taiwanese customs.
Changing the law would affect 3,555 certified guilds while imposing an unreasonable expectation that they must vet newly qualified successors with fragments of genealogy, they said.
The potential for controversy and litigation might result in administrative chaos for the ministry, compromise legal certainty and go against people’s convictions about ancestor worship, the lawyers said.
Thirty-five earthquakes have exceeded 5.5 on the Richter scale so far this year, the most in 14 years, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said on Facebook on Thursday. A large earthquake in Hualien County on April 3 released five times as much the energy as the 921 Earthquake on Sept. 21, 1999, the agency said in its latest earthquake report for this year. Hualien County has had the most national earthquake alerts so far this year at 64, with Yilan County second with 23 and Changhua County third with nine, the agency said. The April 3 earthquake was what caused the increase in
INTIMIDATION: In addition to the likely military drills near Taiwan, China has also been waging a disinformation campaign to sow division between Taiwan and the US Beijing is poised to encircle Taiwan proper in military exercise “Joint Sword-2024C,” starting today or tomorrow, as President William Lai (賴清德) returns from his visit to diplomatic allies in the Pacific, a national security official said yesterday. Commenting on condition of anonymity, the official said that multiple intelligence sources showed that China is “highly likely” to launch new drills around Taiwan. Although the drills’ scale is unknown, there is little doubt that they are part of the military activities China initiated before Lai’s departure, they said. Beijing at the same time is conducting information warfare by fanning skepticism of the US and
Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) is unlikely to attempt an invasion of Taiwan during US president-elect Donald Trump’s time in office, Taiwanese and foreign academics said on Friday. Trump is set to begin his second term early next year. Xi’s ambition to establish China as a “true world power” has intensified over the years, but he would not initiate an invasion of Taiwan “in the near future,” as his top priority is to maintain the regime and his power, not unification, Tokyo Woman’s Christian University distinguished visiting professor and contemporary Chinese politics expert Akio Takahara said. Takahara made the comment at a
DEFENSE: This month’s shipment of 38 modern M1A2T tanks would begin to replace the US-made M60A3 and indigenous CM11 tanks, whose designs date to the 1980s The M1A2T tanks that Taiwan expects to take delivery of later this month are to spark a “qualitative leap” in the operational capabilities of the nation’s armored forces, a retired general told the Liberty Times (sister paper of the Taipei Times) in an interview published yesterday. On Tuesday, the army in a statement said it anticipates receiving the first batch of 38 M1A2T Abrams main battle tanks from the US, out of 108 tanks ordered, in the coming weeks. The M1 Abrams main battle tank is a generation ahead of the Taiwanese army’s US-made M60A3 and indigenously developed CM11 tanks, which have
RSS