Healthcare professionals are divided on whether psychiatric counseling should be paid by the National Health Insurance (NHI), as voices calling for expanded coverage grow louder in the wake of high-profile incidents.
The issue was recently thrust back into the spotlight, when a man with schizophrenia, who had long been known have violent episodes, on Sept. 26 attacked a convenience store clerk in Pingtung County, potentially blinding her.
While certainly an outlier, the case has again highlighted the weak spots in mental health coverage.
Photo: CNA
Under the first article of the National Health Insurance Act (全民健康保險法), benefits are to be provided in the event of “illness, injury or maternity,” which excludes non-therapeutic psychiatric counseling.
However, some inroads have been made since a proposal calling for coverage of counseling and psychotherapy was raised earlier this year on the government’s online public policy participation platform.
The petition, which gathered 5,882 signatures, resulted in a forum on Tuesday last week held by the National Health Insurance Administration for experts and the signatories to share their thoughts.
The agency also issued a response on July 13 outlining the steps it has taken since 2013 to address the “major issue” of mental health in the absence of clear legal coverage.
In addition to the 1925 suicide prevention hotline, the agency emphasized the establishment of 385 community mental health centers nationwide, which provide counseling at no or a reduced cost to more than 20,000 people annually.
However, Association of Taiwan Clinical Psychologists member Lin Tzu-yin (林姿吟) said that many psychologists do not see a single patient during their office hours at community clinics, showing that people are unaware of the service.
In 2014, the agency also revised coverage policy for “deep psychotherapy” to eliminate disease discrimination, allowing treatment to be covered regardless of a person’s condition, it said.
Despite these efforts, critics have pointed out that treatment, even when it is covered, often takes months to receive due to limited resources, while other forms of counseling are prohibitively expensive.
The woman who posted the petition, surnamed Wu (吳), referenced her mother’s experience as an example of the need for universal coverage.
Suspecting she had a hoarding disorder, Wu’s mother years ago visited a psychiatric division at a hospital where she was prescribed medication, she said.
As it seemed to have no effect, she wanted to visit a psychologist for counseling, but the NHI would not cover it, Wu said, asking why benefits seem to be available only some of the time.
A signatory surnamed Liu (劉) said he had consulted a dozen psychologists since he was diagnosed with depression more than a decade ago.
Even after finding a suitable one, Liu said that the price was hard to swallow.
Psychiatric treatment covered by the NHI is mainly performed by psychiatrists and clinical psychologists, said Li Yu-chan (李玉嬋), president of the Taiwan Mental Health Counseling and Psychological Association.
However, there are only about 1,800 clinical psychologists in Taiwan, resulting in wait times of three to six months for a consultation, she said.
On the other hand, there are nearly 3,200 counseling psychologists who are only available to those able to afford the sessions, Li added.
The nation has 1,662 clinical psychologists, 1,233 of whom are registered to work in hospitals, Ministry of Health and Welfare figures show. Of the 2,718 counseling psychologists in Taiwan, only 344 are able to work in hospitals.
Taiwan Counseling Psychology Association president Hsu Hsi-sen (徐西森) is a staunch advocate for his colleagues’ inclusion in the NHI system, considering the preventive effect of counseling.
Psychiatric issues involve not just the individual, but entire families and societies, Hsu said.
A lack of coverage harms outcomes by not only keeping patients from treatment that could prevent deterioration into a psychiatric disorder, but also by making psychiatrists less willing to write prescriptions, he added.
In practice, psychiatrists, clinical psychologists and counseling psychologists are hard to differentiate as they all utilize the same psychiatric principles, said Tsai Hsiao-wen (蔡曉雯), a representative of the Taiwan Counseling Psychologist Union.
All three can provide psychiatric counseling and treatment, distinguished only by the recipient, work setting and treatment goal, she said.
However, not everyone agrees.
Psychiatrist Kuo Hsi-ching (郭錫卿), who represents the Taiwanese Society of Psychiatry, said that psychological issues, mental illness and serious psychiatric disorders are separate issues.
Mental disorders are caused by abnormalities in neurotransmitter activity, and are treatable with medication in conjunction with psychiatric treatment, Kuo said, adding that this is already covered by the NHI.
As for mental health counseling, Kuo equated the situation to having high blood pressure, a precursor to a disease, but not yet a medical condition.
“Maybe one day you had a fight with your boss or wife that puts you in a bad mood or you have adaptive or interpersonal issues,” he said.
“These are all a part of mental health, but as it has not progressed into a disease, by definition they are not covered by the NHI,” he said, recommending that it stay that way.
NATIONAL SECURITY: Authorities are working to confirm the identities of the military personnel involved and investigating possible illegal conduct and regulatory violations Authorities are probing possible national security implications after Kinmen police and immigration officers on Sunday found a Chinese woman allegedly posing as a tourist while engaging in prostitution involving more than 10 military personnel. The woman, surnamed Chen (陳), has since been deported, authorities said, adding that investigators are still working to confirm the identities of those implicated, as the records only listed code names and aliases. The case stemmed from a report received by the Kinmen District Prosecutors’ Office on Friday last week from the Jinhu Precinct of the Kinmen County Police Bureau. On Sunday, police, along with the National Immigration
GLOBALGIVING: ‘ Caving to external pressure is not acceptable for an organization that has cultivated justice reform and human rights for 30 years,’ one NGO said A slew of non-government organizations (NGOs) have withdrawn from the GlobalGiving fundraising platform after it announced it would use “Chinese Taipei” instead of “Taiwan” from next month. The Taiwan Good Rice Association wrote on Facebook on Friday that it was informed on April 28 via a teleconference call of the change, which was made because the platform wanted to operate in China. Taiwan Good Rice is to terminate all cooperative relationships with GlobalGiving in response to the platform’s “unilateral and non-negotiable” decision to remove references to Taiwan, the NGO said. “Taiwan is in the official name of Taiwan Good Rice Association and the
HEAVY WEATHER: Typhoon Jangmi is due to crash straight into the Ryukyus as airlines look to shift flights to larger aircraft or cancel flights to Okinawa entirely Taiwan’s international air carriers announced flight adjustments over the weekend as Typhoon Jangmi is forecast to hit the Ryukyu Islands today and tomorrow. The Central Weather Administration (CWA) upgraded Jangmi from a tropical storm to a typhoon at 8am yesterday, with the eye located 580km south of Naha city. It was moving north at 19kph. Today, China Airlines’ CI-120, CI-121, CI-122 and CI-123 flights between Taoyuan and Naha, Okinawa, have been canceled as well as CI-132 and CI-133 between Kaohsiung and Naha. EVA Air’s BR-112, BR-113, BR-186 and BR-185 flights between Taoyuan and Naha are also canceled. Low-cost carrier Tigerair Taiwan canceled IT-230,
REASONS FOR TRAVEL: An assistant professor said that proposed amendments to penalize drivers if they used drugs overseas would not deter people from traveling People who operate a motor vehicle under the influence of marijuana would have their driver’s license revoked, even if they used the substance while overseas, the Ministry of Transportation and Communications said yesterday, citing proposed amendments to the Road Traffic Management and Penalty Act (道路交通管理處罰條例). The amendments would also authorize the government to revoke the licenses of people determined to have used Category 1 or Category 2 narcotics, even if they were not operating a vehicle while under the influence of drugs, as well as ban them from taking the license test for three years, the ministry said. People aged 18 or
RSS