The Taipei District Court on Monday ruled in favor of Japanese pornographic film studio MAX-A in an international lawsuit that accused Web site portals in Taiwan and other Taiwanese companies of making profits on films MAX-A produced through unauthorized distribution for online viewing and downloading.
MAX-A filed the lawsuit in 2010 against 12 Taiwanese companies, including Yamedia Inc (天空傳媒), alleging illegal distribution and copyright infringement and seeking compensation of NT$115 million (US$3.75 million).
The decision has been hailed as a landmark, since it is the first time a court in Taiwan backed copyright protection for pornography, with evidence indicating that Taiwanese suppliers and video download service providers signed no deals with MAX-A.
In past judgements, judges have ruled that pornographic films, known as AV (adult video) in Japan and Taiwan, do not warrant copyright protection, saying the materials violate sexual morality, contravene social order and are not in the public’s interest.
Monday’s ruling read: “Copyright law is to protect all forms of human ideas and expressions, and should protect the spirit of creativity. AV products are a manifestation of human civilization, a part of expressed speech and opinions, and therefore are protected under the Constitution.”
“Copyright law protects the intellectual creations by individuals and of their investment. It does not pass judgement on morality, social customs or if the product was good or bad... Therefore AV products are protected under copyright law,” it read.
The accused, Yamedia Inc, a Taiwanese portal best known for its yam.com (蕃薯藤) Web site, said it signed contracts and paid copyright fees to Taiwanese AV suppliers.
Taiwanese AV suppliers said they did not break the law because past judgements ruled that AV products lack copyright protection.
However, despite the ruling, MAX-A will not be able to receive financial compensation, because the court agreed with Taiwanese companies’ claim of not knowing they were breaking the law.
The ruling can be appealed.
MAX-A president Wataru Ishii came to Taiwan to testify.
Ishii said his company’s AV products are all registered with Japanese video industry authorities, each with a registered serial number, and all have copyright protection in Japan.
“We did not authorize AV product distribution to Taiwanese companies, and we have no authorizing mechanism in Taiwan. Therefore, it was not possible for Taiwanese AV suppliers and other companies to receive authorization from us,” Ishii said.
An alleged US government plan to encourage Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC) to form a joint venture with Intel to boost US chipmaking would place the Taiwanese foundry giant in a more disadvantageous position than proposed tariffs on imported chips, a semiconductor expert said yesterday. If TSMC forms a joint venture with its US rival, it faces the risk of technology outflow, said Liu Pei-chen (劉佩真), a researcher at the Taiwan Industry Economics Database of the Taiwan Institute of Economic Research. A report by international financial services firm Baird said that Asia semiconductor supply chain talks suggest that the US government would
ANNUAL LIGHT SHOW: The lanterns are exhibited near Taoyuan’s high-speed rail station and around the Taoyuan Sports Park Station of the airport MRT line More than 400 lanterns are to be on display at the annual Taiwan Lantern Festival, which officially starts in Taoyuan today. The city is hosting the festival for the second time — the first time was in 2016. The Tourism Administration held a rehearsal of the festival last night. Chunghwa Telecom donated the main lantern of the festival to the Taoyuan City Government. The lanterns are exhibited in two main areas: near the high-speed rail (HSR) station in Taoyuan, which is at the A18 station of the Taoyuan Airport MRT, and around the Taoyuan Sports Park Station of the MRT
Starlux Airlines on Tuesday announced it is to launch new direct flights from Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport to Ontario, California, on June 2. The carrier said it plans to deploy the new-generation Airbus A350 on the Taipei-Ontario route. The Airbus A350 features a total of 306 seats, including four in first class, 26 in business class, 36 in premium economy and 240 in economy. According to Starlux’s initial schedule, four flights would run between Taoyuan and Ontario per week: Monday, Wednesday, Friday and Saturday. Flights are to depart from Taoyuan at 8:05pm and arrive in California at 5:05pm (local time), while return flights
Nearly 800 Indian tourists are to arrive this week on an incentive tour organized by Indian company Asian Painted Ltd, making it the largest tour group from the South Asian nation to visit since the COVID-19 pandemic. The travelers are scheduled to arrive in six batches from Sunday to Feb. 25 for five-day tours, the Tourism Administration said yesterday. The tour would take the travelers, most of whom are visiting Taiwan for the first time, to several tourist sites in Taipei and Yilan County, including tea houses in Taipei’s Maokong (貓空), Dadaocheng (大稻埕) and Ximending (西門町) areas. They would also visit