The three telecom services that would be opened to Chinese investment under the cross-strait service trade agreement would not put the nation’s information security at risk, the National Communications Commission (NCC) said, adding that the nation’s major telecom carriers are banned from hiring Chinese-funded computer maintenance service contractors.
The commission made the remarks at a public hearing on Tuesday after a few of the nation’s telecom and electrical engineering experts repeatedly said the pact would allow Chinese nationals to access telecom facilities and enable them to steal the personal information of Taiwanese.
The experts also announced their displeasure with NCC Chairperson Howard Shyr (石世豪), who said last week that the commission only knew three college professors who oppose the plans for telecom services. The experts said the list of qualified people opposed to the policy has expanded to nearly 200.
While the commission held a public hearing at 2pm, the experts held a press conference at the same time at a separate venue to voice their objections.
Asked why they chose not to debate the viability of the policy at the commission’s hearing, the experts said their initial task was to educate the public and they would consider discussing the issue with the commission at a later date.
Ferng Huei-wen (馮輝文), who teaches computer science and information engineering at National Taiwan University of Science and Technology, said that to ban Chinese from entering telecom facilities would be useless.
Taiwanese director Doze Niu (紐承澤) easily provided access for a Chinese photographer to take pictures at a naval base in Taiwan, so Chinese will be able to sneak into telecom facilities under false pretenses, the experts said.
Lin Tsung-nan (林宗男) of National Taiwan University’s Electrical Engineering department said the commission’s claims that the three telecom services are mostly used by corporations and operate on closed networks was just “a way of talking.”
“There is no such thing as a closed network,” Lin said.
The commission reiterated in its presentation at the hearing that the trade pact will only permit Chinese companies to invest in three services offered by Type II telecom businesses, including store and forward network services, store and retrieve network services, and data exchange communication services.
The commission added that Chinese telecom carriers investing in any of these three services must be a publicly listed firm in China or overseas and must not hold more than 50 percent of shares in the firms. Taiwanese carriers must also hold valid security certifications if they want to receive the investment from Chinese investors. Chinese nationals, on the other hand, are banned from entering the network facilities owned by Taiwanese carriers
Though Taiwan allows Chinese investment in computer maintenance companies, Taiwanese telecom carriers are not allowed to hire their services, nor are they allowed to ask any Chinese-funded companies to manage telecommunication facilities on their behalf.
China allows Taiwanese companies to invest in Internet access services, domestic and offshore call centers and online data transaction centers that are for electronic commerce (e-Commerce) Web sites only.
Some of the participants at the hearing said the telecom business should be considered a part of the national defense system and should not be opened to China.
They also questioned whether businesses would gain any competitive edge if their Web sites were allowed to be viewed in China. Some said that Beijing could force the Taiwanese businesspeople to turn over customer data if they want to do business in China.
NCC Spokesperson Yu Hsiao-cheng (虞孝成) said in response that subscribers to the telecom services are mostly corporate customers and will want their networks to be accessed by designated users only.
They buy the specialized services because they care more than anybody else about the security and reliability of the system, he said, adding that most of corporate users will also encrypt their messages to prevent any confidential information from being stolen.
“As far as I am concerned, the Chinese online shopping Web site Taobao has approximately 1 million users in Taiwan. Taiwanese buyers have already left their information there. We cannot ask people to stop their going to their Web sites for fear that their information might be stolen because that will make us no different from China,” he said.
Yu added that small and medium-sized businesses in Taiwan can benefit from the agreement because their creative products could have a legitimate way to directly reach a market of 1.3 billion people through their e-Commerce Web sites without fear of being blocked by the Chinese government.
TRICKED INTO MOVING: Local governments in China do not offer any help, and Taiwanese there must compete with Chinese in an unfamiliar setting, a researcher said Beijing’s incentives for Taiwanese businesspeople to invest in China are only intended to lure them across the Taiwan Strait, after which they receive no real support, an expert said on Sunday. Over the past few years, Beijing has been offering a number of incentives that “benefit Taiwanese in name, while benefiting China in reality,” a cross-strait affairs expert said on condition of anonymity. Strategies such as the “31 incentives” are intended to lure Taiwanese talent, capital and technology to help address China’s economic issues while also furthering its “united front” efforts, they said. Local governments in China do not offer much practical
Police have detained a Taoyuan couple suspected of over the past two months colluding with human trafficking rings and employment scammers in Southeast Asia to send nearly 100 Taiwanese jobseekers to Cambodia. At a media briefing in Taipei yesterday, the Criminal Investigation Bureau presented items seized from the couple, including alleged victims’ passports, forged COVID-19 vaccination records, mobile phones, bank documents, checks and cash. The man, surnamed Tsai (蔡), and his girlfriend, surnamed Tsan (詹), were taken into custody last month, after police at Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport stopped four jobseekers from boarding a flight to Phnom Penh, said Dustin Lee (李泱輯),
PUBLIC POLL: More than half believe Chinese drills would make Taiwanese less willing to unify with China, while 36 percent said an invasion was highly unlikely Half of Taiwanese support independence, according to the results of a poll released yesterday by the Taiwanese Public Opinion Foundation, which also found that President Tsai Ing-wen’s (蔡英文) support rating fell by 7 percentage points. Fifty percent of respondents supported independence, 25.7 percent supported maintaining the “status quo” and 11.8 percent supported unification, while 12.1 percent had no opinion, did not know or refused to answer, the foundation said. Support for independence is the new mainstream opinion, regardless of which party is in power, foundation chairman Michael You (游盈隆) said. Insinuations that Taiwan wants to maintain the “status quo” are a fabrication that
BILINGUAL PLAN: The 17 educators were recruited under a program that seeks to empower Taiwanese, the envoy to the Philippines said The Taipei Economic and Cultural Office in the Philippines on Thursday hosted a send-off event for the first group of English-language teachers from the country who were recruited for a Ministry of Education-initiated program to advance bilingual education in Taiwan. The 14 teachers and three teaching assistants are part of the Taiwan Foreign English Teacher Program, which aims to help find English-language instructors for Taiwan’s public elementary and junior-high schools, the office said. Seventy-seven teachers and 11 teaching assistants from the Philippines have been hired to teach in Taiwan in the coming school year, office data showed. Among the first group is 57-year-old
RSS