Former president Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁) and his lawyers yesterday rebutted the testimony of former Chinatrust Financial Holding Co vice chairman Jeffrey Koo Jr (辜仲諒).
The rebuttal came during the latest pre-trial hearing in his money-laundering and corruption trial at the Taipei District Court.
Chen also questioned whether the court had violated his human rights by extending his detention period.
The court began by verifying whether the statements given by Koo in the video recordings were consistent with the transcriptions as Koo spoke in a mixture of Mandarin, Hoklo (also known as Taiwanese) and English.
Chen's lawyers and prosecutors disagreed about the content on many occasions.
During the questioning, Koo said: “I don't know Tsai Ming-che (蔡銘哲) [another defendant] ... A friend introduced Tsai Ming-chieh (蔡銘杰) [Tsai Ming-che's brother] to me as [former first lady] Wu Shu-jen's (吳淑珍) chief financial officer.”
Koo said he introduced Tsai Ming-chieh to Taiwan Cement Group (台泥) chairman Leslie Koo (辜成允). Prosecutors allege Chen received kickbacks from the sale of a plot of Leslie Koo-owned land in Longtan (龍潭), Taoyuan County, to the Hsinchu Science Park Administration.
After the deal was completed, Wu allegedly told Jeffrey Koo: “You owe me NT$400 million [US$11.4 million].”
Koo said Wu became angry when she discovered that she should have received NT$400 million, but only received NT$200 million.
“Wu said, 'I think Tsai Ming-chieh stole money from me.' I would never forget this sentence,” Jeffrey Koo said.
He added that the former first lady had “become kind of strange from being cooped up [at home].”
He said that ever since Chen became mayor of Taipei, Chen would tell him the “big picture,” while the former first lady would tell him the actual amount of money to be paid.
“The president would never tell you how much money he wants,” he said.
Prosecutors allege that the Koo's Group had secured billions of NT dollars in kickbacks from selling land to the government for the development of an industrial park after giving NT$400 million to Chen and his wife.
Wu has admitted taking NT$200 million and insisted it was a political donation.
After reviewing about an hour of the video recording, Cheng Wen-lung (鄭文龍), one of Chen's lawyers, accused the Special Investigation Panel (SIP) of not transcribing certain parts of Jeffrey Koo's testimony.
Cheng used the example of when Jeffrey Koo said: “[Wu Shu-jen] doesn't like it when Chen Shui-bian meddles in her affairs.”
Cheng said this rebuts the part in the petition that said whatever the first lady knew, Chen also knew.
Cheng also quoted Jeffrey Koo as saying, “this door has closed,” which he said proved that the former president did not accept lobbying by enterprises.
In his own defense, Chen said: “Jeffrey Koo's relationship with my wife has exceeded my relationship with my wife by far.”
Chen said Jeffrey Koo should not be a witness, but a suspect, because he is heavily involved in the case. He also questioned the validity of Koo's testimony and suspected that prosecutors asked leading questions to produce the answers they wanted. He added that prosecutors violated protocol by revealing the testimony of others to Jeffrey Koo.
Throughout his rebuttal of the statements, Chen made several comments about Presiding Judge Tsai Shou-hsun's (蔡守訓) decision to extend his detention.
“Today, you indict me, keep me detained and extend my detention ... What about my human rights?” he said.
“Where in the Code of Criminal Procedure does it state that a detainee may not publish books?” he asked.
Chen spoke for more than an hour before Tsai ordered a one-hour lunch recess at 2:30pm.
When the hearing resumed at 3:30pm, the court went through video recordings of testimonies by Leslie Koo and the former president's bookkeeper, Chen Chen-hui (陳鎮慧).
Chen Shui-bian's lawyers accused the SIP of tampering with the recording to erase testimony that supported the defendants.
Prosecutors responded by saying that some parts of the recording had no sound because the equipment malfunctioned. They also insisted that the testimonies would still be admissible and the fact that the time written on the transcription and the video recording was inconsistent was not enough to dismiss the testimony.
The next hearing, scheduled for Tuesday, will examine the testimony of James Lee (李界木), the former director-general of the Hsinchu Science Park Administration.
Meanwhile, in response to Chen office's plan to highlight the former president's case in an international press conference, Minister of Justice Wang Ching-feng (王清峰) urged the office not to “discredit Taiwan's judicial system.”
“Taiwan's judicial system is not as ugly [as Chen's office says],” Wang said when approached outside the legislature.
“We expect everyone to respect the judiciary while the judiciary also deserves our respect. Discrediting our own country will not do anybody any good,” she said.
Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Legislator Chiu Yi (邱毅) said it would be useless for the former president to “complain” to international reporters, adding that Chen Shui-bian's detention might be extended again if his office held the conference.
ADDITIONAL REPORTING BY FLORA WANG
CLEAR BEFORE LEAVING: Two baby boys and a woman in her 30s tested negative before departing for Japan, but tests taken after their arrival came back postive Three Taiwanese tested positive for COVID-19 when they arrived in Japan earlier this month, the Central Epidemic Command Center (CECC) said yesterday as it reported a new imported case. Minister of Health and Welfare Chen Shih-chung (陳時中), head of the center, said that one of the three cases in Japan is a Taiwanese baby under the age of one, whose parents work in Japan. The infant came to Taiwan with his parents in January, and the parents paid for the family’s COVID-19 tests on Oct. 10 ahead of their planned return to Japan on Monday last week, he said. The boy and his
‘BACKED BY ENEMY’: CTi News is one of the few channels promoting unification, the New Party chairman said, while pro-Taiwan groups called it a propaganda outlet Pan-blue camp supporters yesterday lodged a protest at the National Communications Commission (NCC) against what they say is a possible move by the government to shut down CTi News, adding that politics should not interfere with freedom of the press. Protesters included representatives from the New Party, the Blue Sky Action Alliance, the 333 Political Party Alliance and other pan-blue groups. “We stand here today because CTi News is one of the few media outlets in Taiwan that is still willing to give groups supporting unification with China a voice. If the news channel is gone, there would only be
NEW YEAR’S EVE: Examples from South Korea and Japan show that 15 local COVID-19 infections could emerge in a short period if measures are not taken The Taipei City Government would cancel its New Year’s Eve Party and all large events if 15 or more confirmed cases of COVID-19 are reported in the city within a week, Taipei Mayor Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) said yesterday. Addressing the Taipei Cross Border E-Commerce Annual Convention, Ko said the COVID-19 pandemic has brought many uncertainties to society, and that e-commerce is on a path of no return and would continue to grow. Many countries have not effectively controlled their COVID-19 outbreaks, and although Taiwan implements strict border controls and there have been few inbound passengers, the pandemic is unlikely to end soon,
The Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) yesterday accused CTi News of trying to mislead the public by publishing a half-page advert claiming that the party interfered in the National Communications Commission’s (NCC) review of its application for a license renewal. CTi News is distorting the commission’s review process by painting it as a political conflict and turning it into a smear campaign against the DPP, party spokeswoman Yen Juo-fang (顏若芳) said. “The NCC is an independent body, which carries out reviews and makes decisions based on its members’ professional expertise, as well as regulations and legal requirements governing media operations,” Yen said. “We condemn