If anything positive has come out of Jaw Shaw-kong's (
On the day before the Lunar New Year holidays, the commission ruled that the nation's largest radio station must fulfill several requirements before its application for a change in ownership could be approved.
The ruling dictated that the company must first return the frequencies that were previously used to broadcast political propaganda to China to the government.
PHOTO: LIU HSIN-DE, TAIPEI TIMES
BCC must also strive to raise the percentage of self-produced programs. And to prevent a potential monopoly in the media market, the commission asked Liang Lei (
Also, BCC and UFO must operate as two separate organizations.
The results were surprising to many, since the commission found no serious breaches of the regulations when Jaw was interviewed by the commission in January.
But the controversies surrounding the BCC case went beyond the unexpected verdict. Because it involved the purchase of an asset previously owned by the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT), the case had the potential to generate more shouting matches between the Government Information Office (GIO) and NCC than any other case the latter has handled, with the GIO demanding that BCC return the previously mentioned radio frequencies immediately.
Meanwhile, the four companies that possess the majority of BCC's shares are said to be affiliated with Jaw, and have been alleged to be fake operations established to enable him to buy BCC without violating regulations in the Broadcasting and Television Law (
To media observers, the BCC case exposed the commission's passivity when it handled such a controversial case.
"Jaw was no fool when he purchased BCC, knowing that he couldn't be touched as long as he fulfilled the minimum requirements of the [Broadcasting and Television] law," said Wei Ti (
"The commission should have proactively investigated this dubious transaction in the first place. Unfortunately, it only began to question Jaw after the commission had been criticized by the public for doing almost nothing," he said.
Wei pointed to a bigger issue that lies at the center of all broadcasting disputes.
"We have not seen any fundamental changes in communications policies, particularly with regard to the reappropriation and readjustment of the nation's television broadcasters, and telecommunications resources," he added.
workload
The size of the commission's workload and the time a review process consumes perhaps explain the lack of a proactive stance in the BCC case.
Since last year, the commission has had its hands full reviewing cases previously handled by the GIO and the Directorate-General of Telecommunications.
The nine commission members have discussed the application for a Multimedia-On-Demand (MOD) service from Chunghwa Telecom; ETTV-S and Long Shong Movie Station's applications to renew their broadcasting licenses; applications to launch TV stations for mobile phones; reshuffles of channels on the cable television service; and constructing a new formula to determine the base charge for local telephone calls. In every single one of the cases -- whether large or small -- the commission is required to deliver a ruling resulting from a consensus among its members.
In the case of the MOD service, it took the commission nine months to reach a settlement. The case revolved around whether an online television service run by a government-affiliated company would violate the regulation forbidding the government, political parties and the military operating media organizations.
While the NCC's operational model guarantees a thorough consideration of each case, it compromises the efficiency required to mediate over disputes in the rapidly-changing media and telecommunications markets. The urgency and time spent on these cases left hardly any time for the commission to consider overhauling outdated policies and regulations.
NCC chairman Su Yeong-ching (蘇永欽) said in an press conference before the Lunar New Year that the commission's main task this year was to amend three important communications laws -- the Satellite and Broadcasting Law (衛星廣播電視法), Cable Radio and Television Law (有線廣播電視法) and Broadcasting and Television Law (廣播電視法).
The task, he said, "would take a lot of their time."
Wei, however, said that the commission's capacity to handle such a big project was questionable.
"I am not too optimistic about it [the amendments], given that the Grand Council of Justices ruled that the NCC's formation was unconstitutional and its members have expressed their wish to resign by January next year," Wei said. "It seems unlikely that they would begin any long-term policy reviews. They would probably just keep their fingers crossed that they won't make any mistakes or cause any trouble."
muscle
Criticism notwithstanding, many have noted that the commission has begun to flex its under-utilized administrative muscle during some of the recent issues. When the Executive Yuan accused the NCC of making an out-of-court settlement with BCC regarding the unreturned frequencies and threatened to annul its ruling, the NCC fought back with legal documents and said bluntly that the Executive Yuan had no right to interfere in the ruling.
Another incident was the MBK Partners' purchase of China Network Systems (CNS), the nation's second largest cable TV operator.
NCC spokesperson Howard Shyr (石世豪) said in an interview with the Chinese-language Economic Daily News that MBK had to clearly state the source of its funding and demonstrate to the commission plans to create a digital TV system in the next few years, or the commission would rule "that it [the deal] was not in CNS' interests."
Despite the more hardline attitude, the specter of an unregulated media market when the commission members resign in January next year has left the Executive Yuan with a problem.
In a statement last month Su urged the Executive Yuan to quickly start amending the organic law of the National Communications Commission (國家通訊傳播委員會組織法).
Chen Yaw-shyang (陳耀祥), assistant professor of the public administration and policy department at the National Taipei University, said the amendment must allow the Premier to nominate candidates for the commission.
Chen said the NCC, even as an independent organization, must still be under the supervision of the Executive Yuan.
"The `independence' here simply means it functions independently, but it is still considered as an entity within the group of government administrative organizations," Media Watch president Kuan Chung-hsiang (
Kuan added that since it has proven politically unviable to choose commission members based on the representation of political parties in the legislature, the Executive Yuan should consider the model used by the Public Television Service Foundation, where directors are first nominated by the Executive Yuan and then reviewed by a special panel authorized by the Legislative Yuan.
He also stressed the importance of including a "revolving-door" article in the amendment, which would prevent former commission members from accepting key positions in the private sector immediately after their resignation.
Kuan suggested that in addition to legal experts and media academics, the commission should include ordinary citizens in the decision-making process.
The amendment should also cut the number of members who serve on the commission and delegate some of the less important tasks to second-tier officials.
"Having nine is way too many. The Federal Communications Commission in the US only has five," he said. "They [commission members] all seem to be busy, but when you look closely at some of the cases, a lot of them are minute."
An alleged US government plan to encourage Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC) to form a joint venture with Intel to boost US chipmaking would place the Taiwanese foundry giant in a more disadvantageous position than proposed tariffs on imported chips, a semiconductor expert said yesterday. If TSMC forms a joint venture with its US rival, it faces the risk of technology outflow, said Liu Pei-chen (劉佩真), a researcher at the Taiwan Industry Economics Database of the Taiwan Institute of Economic Research. A report by international financial services firm Baird said that Asia semiconductor supply chain talks suggest that the US government would
Starlux Airlines on Tuesday announced it is to launch new direct flights from Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport to Ontario, California, on June 2. The carrier said it plans to deploy the new-generation Airbus A350 on the Taipei-Ontario route. The Airbus A350 features a total of 306 seats, including four in first class, 26 in business class, 36 in premium economy and 240 in economy. According to Starlux’s initial schedule, four flights would run between Taoyuan and Ontario per week: Monday, Wednesday, Friday and Saturday. Flights are to depart from Taoyuan at 8:05pm and arrive in California at 5:05pm (local time), while return flights
Nearly 800 Indian tourists are to arrive this week on an incentive tour organized by Indian company Asian Painted Ltd, making it the largest tour group from the South Asian nation to visit since the COVID-19 pandemic. The travelers are scheduled to arrive in six batches from Sunday to Feb. 25 for five-day tours, the Tourism Administration said yesterday. The tour would take the travelers, most of whom are visiting Taiwan for the first time, to several tourist sites in Taipei and Yilan County, including tea houses in Taipei’s Maokong (貓空), Dadaocheng (大稻埕) and Ximending (西門町) areas. They would also visit
HOSPITAL VISITS: Shin Kong Mitsukoshi pledged to give the families of the four people who died NT$11m each and provide support for staff working at the time The central government would assist local governments to enhance public safety, President William Lai (賴清德) said yesterday as he visited people in hospital who were injured in an explosion at a department store in Taichung on Thursday. A suspected gas explosion occurred on the 12th floor of the Shin Kong Mitsukoshi Zhonggang department store in Taichung at 11:33am on Thursday, killing four people and injuring 36. Of the 40 casualties, 39 were hospitalized, Ministry of Health and Welfare data showed. Three died after out-of-hospital cardiac arrests, the data showed. As of 6am yesterday, 25 of those injured had been discharged from hospital, leaving 11