Sun, Jul 16, 2006 page3

• Taiwanese agent helped FBI case against Keyser

  DANGEROUS LIAISON An FBI memo contains details from an NSB agent on her relations with a former US diplomat, and allegations that the two had an affair

  • By Charles Snyder / STAFF REPORTER IN WASHINGTON
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  Isabelle Cheng Nian-tzu (程念慈), a Taiwanese intelligence officer formerly based in Washington, provided the FBI with a trove of secret cables and e-mail messages related to her relationship with former State Department official Donald Keyser, after Keyser was arrested in September 2004, an FBI memorandum to a federal court in Virginia shows.

  The FBI released the documents in a 43-page filing seeking the court's permission to bring new charges against Keyser in what a government prosecutor has called an "espionage-related case."

  The documents produced by the FBI allegedly demonstrate that Keyser provided "extensive" information to Cheng that "was valuable to her work as an intelligence officer," the FBI says. The bureau also says the information proves Keyser was not honest in his dealings with investigators in the case.

  Keyser's lawyer, Robert Litt, rebutted those contentions.

  "Mr. Keyser denies that he was ever acting on behalf of Taiwan's intelligence agency," he said. "The government's submission contains numerous inaccuracies and misinterpretations of innocuous facts."

  Keyser was arrested after having lunch at a suburban Washington restaurant with Cheng and her boss, Huang Kuang-hsun (黃光勳), reputedly the National Security Bureau's (NSB's) top intelligence operative at the Taipei Economic and Cultural Representative Office (TECRO), during which Keyser was seen handing them an envelope.

  The FBI had followed Keyser for some time, observing his relationship with Cheng between 2002 and 2004, after Keyser allegedly failed to report to his superiors a rendezvous he had in Taipei with Cheng the previous September.

  In a plea bargain reached last December, Keyser pleaded guilty to three charges related to that incident, failing to report his relationship with Cheng and the possession of thousands of classified and secret documents, found during an FBI raid of his home. In return for guilty pleas, the FBI said it would not pursue additional charges.

  Revisiting the deal

  However, in a court hearing before District Court Judge T.S. Ellis last month, the prosecution asked the judge to be released from the agreement, alleging that Keyser did not keep his end of the bargain, but lied to investigators in subsequent questioning.

  Litt, in a 29-page rebuttal filed with the court on Friday, said that all the information in the latest FBI filing was known to the agency before it agreed to the plea bargain. It also asserted that Keyser's constitutional right to a fair trial was being violated because the FBI has refused to show him much of the information on which its contentions are based, most of which is secret and cannot be shared with him.

  The defense response refers to "the government's stubborn and erroneous belief that Mr. Keyser was a spy."

  It said that Keyser "disclosed no classified information to Ms. Cheng or her superior, Mr. Huang, and his communications were all in furtherance of US government interests."

  Sexual allegations

  In the new memorandum, the FBI for the first time specifically alleged that Keyser and Cheng engaged in sexual relations. Although the FBI says Keyser denied that Cheng had offered "sex for information," the memorandum cites a series of encounters in Keyser's car, Cheng's apartment and elsewhere.

  At one point, after the pair spent 20 minutes in Keyser's car in a side street in which Cheng's head was said to be "leaning toward the defendant and disappearing in front of him," Keyser allegedly said in an intercepted cellphone call to Cheng, "The food was good, the wine was good, the champagne was good and you were good."

  At another point, Keyser drove Cheng home and stayed in her apartment for nearly an hour close to midnight. He told investigators that in the apartment "she removed all of her clothes and he touched her all over her body," but said that they did not have sex.

  The FBI also allegedly observed the couple in his car on a reclined seat moving below the sight line of the door frame. Regarding one instance, Keyser contended the two did not remove their seat belts and engaged only in "heavy petting."

  In the cables, which were marked "secret" and sent in Chinese from Cheng at TECRO to the NSB headquarters, Cheng recounted Keyser's analysis, comments and details of US policy toward Taiwan and of his discussions with leaders, including Chinese President Jiang Zeming (江澤民) when Jiang met with President Bush in his Texas ranch.

  The cables also dealt with the runup to President Chen Shui-bian's (陳水扁) transit visit in New York in October 2003, the Bush meeting with Vice Premier Wen Jiabao (溫家寶), when Bush took Chen to task over Chen's plans for constitutional changes and a referendum coinciding with the May 2004 presidential election.

  One cable discloses that the State Department wanted to send Deputy Assistant Secretary of State Randy Schriver to greet Chen at the airport during the New York transit, but that Assistant Secretary James Kelly blocked the move, feeling that Taiwan would misconstrue Schriver's appearance as a sign that the US approved of Chen's constitution and referendum plans.

  Prosecutors say that Keyser lied in his statements to investigators and failed to fully cooperate with them, which they say is grounds for freeing the government from its plea bargain obligations.

  One e-mail indicates that Cheng may have been trying to recruit a former State Department official as a spy and that Keyser seemed to be providing information about him.

  That person, who was described as having been frustrated by the State Department and later becoming a think tank academic, had his name blacked out in the publicly released version of the e-mail.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Alcaraz struggles to 4th round in Paris

  • 2

    PSG crush Inter to win trophy

  • 3

    Control Yuan member quits over misuse of vehicle

  • 4

    Greek basketball finals suspended following scuffles

  • 5

    Taipei ranks 60 in ‘Global Cities Index,’ up five spots