Sheffield United on Monday sought to overturn its demotion from the Premier League, citing relegation rival West Ham's illegal signing of Argentina stars Carlos Tevez and Javier Mascherano.
West Ham was fined ?5.5 million (US$10.8 million) in April by an independent panel for breaking Premier League rules by signing Tevez and Mascherano on third-party contracts in August last year. However, the panel stopped short of docking points from West Ham.
Sheffield United pressed its case against the Premier League at a two-day arbitration hearing that opened on Monday.
"It's been a busy day," Sheffield United chairman Kevin McCabe said at the close of the day's session. "Tomorrow there will be further evidence and then the panel will opine and decide. The arbitration is going well and I think the panel recognize all the points of the case."
Sheffield United wants the three-man panel to decide if the original decision to only fine the club was "legally flawed" and, if so, for a disciplinary commission to hear the case.
Sheffield United also wants the panel to rule on whether the Premier League acted unlawfully by not stripping Tevez of his league registration. Fulham, which successfully avoided relegation, is backing Sheffield United on the second point.
"The arbitral panel have no power to decide what the penalty to be imposed upon West Ham should be," the arbitration panel said in a statement. "This will be within the exclusive remit of the disciplinary commission, if one is convened as a result of the arbitral panel's decision."
West Ham said it correctly changed Tevez's contract in April. Mascherano was sold to Liverpool in January on a Premier League-approved contract.
Although West Ham accepted the fine and acknowledged that it broke the rules, Tevez continued to play and his goals helped the London side avoid relegation.
Sheffield United dropped down instead to the League Championship, and the Blades insist West Ham should have been docked points as well as fined.
The fixtures have already been released for the 2007-2008 season, with West Ham in the Premier League and Sheffield United in the League Championship.
McCabe said relegation would cost Sheffield United ?50 million, but stressed its appeal was based on principle.
"It's not so much the money, it's the fact that one club that has not breached the rules has been relegated whilst another club that has breached the rules has retained its Premiership status and that's the key argument," McCabe said.
Fickle winds produced farcical scenes yesterday on day two of the America’s Cup challenger series in Auckland, as the so-called “flying” yachts spent almost as much time in the water as above it. “I’m not sure today is a really accurate read because it’s so puffy, it’s shifty,” British sailing legend Ben Ainslie said after his Ineos Team UK maintained their perfect start to the Prada Cup series with a third straight win. The series would determine which of the 23m yachts — which fly above the water balanced on hi-tech foil arms — would challenge defending champion Team New Zealand for
VIRUS RISK: India’s Saina Nehwal tested positive for COVID-19 at the Yonex Thailand Open, while three other players were being retested after receiving conflicting results Taiwanese badminton star Tai Tzu-ying yesterday returned to international competition after an eight-month break with a victory at the Yonex Thailand Open in Bangkok. Twenty-six-year-old Tai, 26, the top-seeded player at the tournament, met 18-year-old Thai player Benyapa Aimsaard in the opening round and narrowly won 21-18, 26-24. Her previous tournament was the Yonex All England Open in March last year, where she won the women’s singles title, before the BWF World Tour was disrupted by the COVID-19 pandemic. Benyapa was a last-minute replacement after another Thai player pulled out of the event. It was a rollercoaster match for Tai.
NO FAIRY TALE: Non-league Marine tried to bridge the biggest gap between opponents in FA Cup history, but the part-timers fell to a 5-0 defeat to Tottenham Hotspur Leeds United on Sunday suffered a humiliating FA Cup exit against Crawley Town as the League Two side swept to a stunning 3-0 win, while eighth-tier Marine’s hopes of causing the competition’s greatest shock were crushed in a 5-0 defeat against Tottenham Hotspur. After the spiking COVID-19 pandemic wreaked havoc with matches across the third round on Friday and Saturday, the FA Cup was back on more familiar ground on Sunday as Leeds became the competition’s latest big name to be knocked out by feisty underdogs. While Marine’s romantic adventure was cut short by a Carlos Vinicius hat-trick, and Chelsea and Manchester
DOUBLES VICTORY: The men’s doubles pairing of Taiwanese Lee Yang and Wang Chi-lin downed Malaysians Ong Yew Sin and Teo Ee Yi, and face South Koreans today Men’s badminton world No. 2 Chou Tien-chen yesterday marched into the semi-finals of the Thailand Open, defeating younger opponent Lee Zii-jia 21-17, 21-15 after a rally, while Tai Tzu-ying had no trouble getting past her Canadian opponent in the women’s singles. The top male Taiwanese credited calm and focus in securing his win after briefly falling behind against his 22-year-old Malaysian opponent. “I think I had more patience against him and I won most of the long rallies,” the 31-year-old Chou said of Lee. “He wanted to attack [too much] and maybe he lost some focus,” Chou said. In today’s semi-finals, second-seeded Chou faces