Tue, Apr 05, 2022 page14

• British Museum facing legal action over Parthenon sculptures 3D scan refusal 帕德嫩神廟雕像禁掃描　大英博物館挨告

  • • 
    • 
    • 

  The British Museum is facing legal action from one of the UK’s leading heritage preservation organizations over its refusal to allow the 3D scanning of a piece in its Parthenon sculptures collection.

  The Institute for Digital Archaeology (IDA) said it would serve an injunction against the museum imminently, raising the stakes in the dispute between the two.

  “We will be filing a complaint by the end of the week requesting the court to order the British Museum to grant our request,” Roger Michel, the IDA’s executive director, told the Guardian. “We want them to treat our application in exactly the same fashion that they would treat similar requests. Their refusal has been capricious and arbitrary.”

  

  The ancient temple of Parthenon on the Acropolis hill in Athens, Greece is pictured on June 4, 2021. The pediment on the east side of the Parthenon was removed by Thomas Bruce, 7th Earl of Elgin in the early 19th century, and subsequently became a collection at the British Museum, known as the Elgin Marbles. 希臘雅典衛城山丘上之帕德嫩神廟，攝於二○二一年六月四日。神廟東面頂部山形牆上之雕像，在十九世紀初被英國埃爾金伯爵湯馬斯‧布魯斯拆下，運往英國，即為現藏於大英博物館之「埃爾金大理石雕像」部份。

  Photo: AFP 照片：法新社

  The Oxford-based institute had hoped, with the museum’s blessing, to reproduce one of the high relief metopes from the Acropolis temple’s south facade as “proof of concept.” In 2016 it reconstructed Syria’s Palymyra arch of triumph out of Egyptian marble based on photographs following the monument’s destruction by Islamic State.

  Advocates believe 3D imaging could be employed to not only create replicas of the classical treasures but help resolve the longstanding row between Athens and London over patrimony of the Parthenon sculptures. Scans would allow a robot sculptor to reproduce the artworks with sub-millimetre accuracy using the same Pentelic marble from which the originals were chiselled, according to the IDA, a supporter of the sculptures’ repatriation to Greece.

  The antiquities, regarded as the high point of classical art, have been in the British Museum’s possession since 1816 after their removal from the Parthenon at the behest of Lord Elgin, the British ambassador to the Ottoman empire, which then controlled what is now modern Greece.

  

  The Parthenon Marbles, a collection of stone objects, inscriptions and sculptures, also known as the Elgin Marbles, are displayed at the British Museum in London, UK on Oct. 16, 2014. 帕德嫩神廟大理石雕像（亦被稱為「埃爾金大理石雕像」）為一系列石像、銘文及雕塑。二○一四年十月十六日攝於英國倫敦大英博物館。

  Photo: Reuters 照片：路透

  Successive Greek governments have argued that the antiquities were illegally hacked from the temple at a time when it was a subject nation without voice or sovereignty. The British Museum says they were legally acquired.

  (The Guardian)

  大英博物館正面臨一項訴訟，因其拒絕英國一重要遺產保護組織對其館藏帕德嫩神廟雕像系列中之一件作品進行3D掃描。

  數位考古研究所（IDA）表示，它將立即請求對博物館之禁令，這讓兩造之爭端加劇。

  「本週末之前我們會提出申訴，要求法院命令大英博物館批准我們的請求」，IDA執行董事羅傑‧米歇爾告訴衛報。「我們希望他們用處理類似請求完全相同的方式來處理我們的申請。他們的拒絕是反覆無常和武斷的」。

  這家位於牛津的研究所曾希望取得大英博物館的支持，複製雅典衛城神廟南面的一件排檔間飾高浮雕，作為「概念驗證」。敘利亞帕米拉遺跡中的凱旋門被伊斯蘭國摧毀後，IDA在二○一六年依據照片用埃及大理石將其重建。

  倡導者認為，3D成像不僅可用來複製經典寶藏，還可以對解決雅典和倫敦之間長期以來對於帕德嫩神廟雕像遺產的爭執有所幫助。支持將雕像送回希臘的IDA表示，掃描將可讓雕刻機器人在與原雕像相同材質的彭特利庫斯山大理石上，以次毫米的精密度複製藝術品。

  這些被視為古典藝術最高峰的文物，自一八一六年──當時希臘是由鄂圖曼土耳其帝國所控制──被英國駐鄂圖曼帝國大使埃爾金勳爵命令由帕德嫩神廟拆下後，一直收藏在大英博物館。

  歷任希臘政府皆爭辯說，這些文物是趁希臘還是一個沒有發言權或主權的從屬國時，由神廟中非法盜取的。大英博物館則說它們是合法取得的。

  （台北時報林俐凱編譯）
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Air quality to deteriorate nationwide from tomorrow

  • 2

    Taiwan conflict ‘catastrophic’ for China: US report

  • 3

    Bucks defeat Hornets in final seconds

  • 4

    Taiwan closely monitoring Venezuela developments

  • 5

    Paris sees first derby in almost 36 years