US and Chinese officials were in Germany over the weekend looking to patch up a rift opened by the response to a Chinese balloon shot down over US territory, but a meeting between their top diplomats showed how difficult it might be to compromise.
US Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Chinese Central Foreign Affairs Commission Director Wang Yi (王毅) traded barbs on everything from the balloon and Taiwan to North Korea and Russia in their first meeting since the high-altitude craft traversed the US and provoked an acrimonious round of finger pointing.
Blinken also said China was weighing whether to give Russia weapons for its war in Ukraine, a move that would ratchet up tension even further.
Photo: AP
It all underscored how, for all the claims from US President Joe Biden and Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) about their desire to steady ties, neither side seems capable of doing so. The meeting was meant to pave the way for a visit by Blinken to Beijing — he canceled a visit once the balloon was spotted — but only seemed to make prospects more remote.
“The relationship is becoming more brittle,” said Kori Schake, director of foreign and defense policy studies at the American Enterprise Institute, who has previously worked in the US Department of State and at the Pentagon.
“If China mirrors to Russia the assistance the West is providing Ukraine, it will cement the Russo-Chinese alliance and also Western perceptions of China as a malevolent international force,” she said.
Leaders from places such as Brazil and Singapore have warned about the military and economic spillovers of a prolonged clash between the world’s two biggest economies — and expressed their unwillingness to choose between them.
The rocky meeting and sharp rhetoric around it demonstrated just how sour the US-China relationship is, and how both sides appear willing to squabble over petty issues. In its readout of the talks, China refused even to call it a meeting, referring to it as an “informal contact.”
Wang rejected what he called US “finger-pointing” regarding Russia, and said China would release a new peace proposal for Ukraine in the coming days that would be in keeping with previous efforts by Xi.
Wang, who was set to fly to Moscow for meetings with top Russian officials after his stay in Munich, also met Ukrainian Minister of Foreign Affairs Dmytro Kuleba, and condemned attacks on nuclear power stations.
What the world heard from Blinken about China’s role “underscores that we’re going to have to really up our diplomatic game,” Brookings Institution senior fellow Fiona Hill said in a US television interview. “A lot of other countries just don’t buy that there’s as big an issue as we see with Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.”
What is unclear is whether the squabble on the sidelines of the Munich Security Conference represented some healthy venting that they can now get past, or yet another signal that the US and China remain stuck in a cycle of recriminations that could push them closer to conflict.
There are areas where the two sides would benefit from cooperation, such as climate change and nuclear proliferation, observers have said.
In a readout from the meeting, US Department of State spokesman Ned Price said Blinken had condemned a new intercontinental ballistic missile launch by North Korea “and emphasized the need for responsible powers to respond to such significant international challenges” — a diplomatic request for China exert its influence and curb such launches.
“A meeting is always better than nothing,” said Henry Wang Huiyao (王輝耀), founder of the Center for China and Globalization. “Both sides appeared to be tough. They both have domestic audiences to cater to.”
The Coast Guard Administration’s (CGA) new Yunlin patrol vessel would enhance maritime patrol capabilities in the south, President William Lai (賴清德) yesterday told a commissioning ceremony in Kaohsiung for the 4,000-tonne vessel. The Yunlin, one of four Chiayi-class offshore patrol vessels ordered from shipbuilder CSBC Corp, Taiwan (台灣國際造船), would join the coast guard’s Southern Sector Flotilla based in Kaohsiung, bolstering the unit’s ability to conduct patrols along with searches and rescues, Lai said. The ship is equipped with three high-pressure water cannons with a range of 120m for dispersal tasks, the Ocean Affairs Council said. In his speech, Lai said that the government’s
FREEDOM SEEKER? While the intruder, identified as an ex-Chinese navy captain, looked different from previous ‘defectors,’ it could be China testing Taiwan’s limits, an official said Taiwan has stepped up national security measures, Premier Cho Jung-tai (卓榮泰) said yesterday, after a former Chinese navy captain was arrested for illegally entering the nation on a motorboat. “National security cannot be neglected for a minute,” he said, adding that security units had been instructed to “immediately strengthen protective measures.” Coast guard personnel arrested the man, surnamed Ruan (阮), on Sunday after his boat collided with other vessels at a ferry terminal on the Tamsui River (淡水河) in the north. Before that, he reportedly sailed the vessel into a harbor near the mouth of the river. Ruan is a retired member of
‘SAFER TAIWAN’: The president told ‘Time’ magazine that the new government under his administration ‘is willing to assist China and advance peace and prosperity’ A prosperous Taiwan can bring about progress in China, and Taipei seeks peace and prosperity across the Taiwan Strait, President William Lai (賴清德) told Time magazine in an exclusive interview published yesterday, his first since becoming president. Taiwan wishes for a stable and prosperous China, as it would help maintain peace and stability in the region, he said. “I have always believed that a stable China leads to a safer Taiwan. A prosperous Taiwan can also bring about progress in China,” he was quoted as saying, while asked if China’s problematic economy could be an opportunity for further engagement across strait.
HU GE NEWS: The actor visited Taipei and was on the same flight as an official Shanghai delegation, leading to accusations Taipei City was doing ‘united front’ work Taiwan is open to healthy interactions with China, but Beijing should not engage in “united front” campaigns, a Cabinet official said yesterday following a report that China is paying influencers to produce content it approves of. YouTuber Potter King (波特王) said that the Chinese government has been paying Taiwanese content creators to travel to China and produce videos favorable to Beijing. Cabinet spokesman Chen Shih-kai (陳世凱) said that the government welcomes healthy and sustainable interactions between the two sides of the Taiwan Strait, but China should not use “united front” tactics in the culture and entertainment sphere to target young Taiwanese. Potter King