An investigation into illegal talent poaching by Beijing-based Bitmain Technologies Ltd (比特大陸) has revived fears that Chinese companies would target Taiwan’s top engineers as their country works to build a world-class chipmaking industry.
Investigators on Tuesday descended on the offices of Bitmain’s two Taiwanese units — New Taipei City-based WiseCore Technology Co Ltd (智鈊科技) and Hsinchu-based IC Link Ltd (芯道互聯) — and interviewed 19 people in a probe into whether the cryptomining start-up had contravened the law, New Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office spokeswoman Chang Jui-chuan (張瑞娟) said.
The Chinese firm, which develops semiconductors for mining and other purposes, is suspected of illegally recruiting hundreds of engineers from Taiwanese firms over a period of three years.
Photo: Reuters
Taiwan prohibits firms from China from doing business or recruiting locally without prior approval, a measure intended to limit Beijing’s influence on Taiwan.
The accusations against Bitmain spur concerns that Chinese firms would accelerate efforts to hire Taiwan’s best engineers in a bid to achieve semiconductor self-sufficiency.
Beijing has pledged to develop its own advanced chip manufacturing to dominate future technologies and cut its dependence on US$300 billion of annual semiconductor imports.
Taiwan’s deep pool of expertise revolves around Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (台積電), the world’s leading chip fabricator and a supplier to most US tech giants, from Apple Inc to Nvidia Corp.
US and European companies, such as Alphabet Inc’s Google and ASML Holding NV, have set up engineering hubs and research bases to tap local talent.
“China’s poaching of Taiwanese engineers undermines Taiwan’s semiconductor industry,” said Carol Lin (林志潔), a law professor at National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University in Hsinchu. “Through the maneuver, Chinese competitors can learn about Taiwanese companies’ progress. If these engineers bring trade secrets with them, Chinese rivals can have a firm grasp of Taiwan companies’ past success and failure in technological developments, and this could result in unfair competition and even endanger national security.”
Beijing has denied Washington’s claims that it demands technology or talent transfers, or targets the intellectual property of overseas firms.
Bitmain representatives did not respond to multiple requests for comment.
Bitmain’s actions are suspected of breaching the Act Governing Relations Between the People of the Taiwan Area and the Mainland Area (臺灣地區與大陸地區人民關係條例), Chang said.
An article in the act stipulates that for-profit Chinese firms cannot set up units in Taiwan and conduct business activities — including headhunting — without approval from local authorities, she added.
A separate news release from Chang’s office, while not identifying Bitmain by name, shed light on the allegations:
To develop artificial intelligence chips, the Chinese start-up created a new entity in China with a Taiwanese engineer as chairman. This engineer then recruited colleagues from his former company in Taiwan and formed a headhunting team to set up a research and development (R&D) center in Taiwan, the statement said.
Chang confirmed that the company in the news release was Bitmain.
The team offered potential recruits double their existing salaries and advertised openly on Taiwanese job sites, prosecutors said.
In 2018, IC Link recruited 200 R&D engineers from local IC design companies, such as MediaTek Inc (聯發科), MStar Semiconductor Inc (晨星半導體) and Global Unichip Corp (創意電子), by offering double the normal local salary equivalents — ranging from NT$7 million to NT$11 million (US$247,123 to US$388,336 at the current exchange rate) per annum, local media reports said.
DRAM maker Nanya Technology Corp (南亞科技) president Lee Pei-ing (李培瑛) in 2018 said that some of his engineers were being offered three to five times their salaries by Chinese competitors.
The typical practice was to first lure away a manager who would then go on to recruit more of his former colleagues, Lee said.
Prosecutors said that the chief executives of WiseCore, surnamed Yen (顏), and IC Link, surnamed Huang (黃), were freed yesterday on bail of NT$100,000 and NT$200,000 respectively.
The vice president of a joint venture set up by WiseCore and IC Link, surnamed Tsao (曹), was also freed on bail of NT$100,000, the prosecutors added.
Additional reporting by CNA
The military yesterday showed off its latest domestically produced armored vehicle, the CM-34 Clouded Leopard, at a remote manufacturing site in the nation’s central mountains. Taiwan has been eager to demonstrate its resolve to defend itself should China ever attack. Those fears have become more pronounced over the past few years as Beijing has stepped up military activities near Taiwan. While Taiwan relies on the US for many of its weapons, such as fighter jets, President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) has been pushing for a greater emphasis on Taiwanese-designed and made armaments, the most high profile of which is new submarines. The eight-wheeled CM-34,
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs yesterday denounced Russian President Vladimir Putin for disparaging Taiwan’s sovereignty by saying that Taiwan issues are “China’s internal affairs.” The ministry strongly condemned Putin’s “false” remarks that “undermined the sovereignty of the Republic of China,” ministry spokeswoman Joanne Ou (歐江安) told a news briefing. Xinhua news agency cited Putin as telling Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) during a telephone call on Wednesday that Russia opposed any interference from external forces in China’s internal affairs, such as in Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Taiwan. Ou said that Taiwanese elect their government in free and fair elections, adding that only the
‘DEMOCRATIC FISH’: Soichiro Hayashi said he wants to return Taiwan’s kindness after it helped with relief efforts after the March 11, 2011, earthquake and tsunami Japanese fish farmers are ready to help Taiwan after China banned Taiwanese grouper imports, the Sankei Shimbun reported yesterday. The Chinese General Administration of Customs suspended imports of the fish on Monday last week, citing prohibited chemicals and excessive levels of oxytetracycline allegedly found in grouper imports since December last year. Soichiro Hayashi, president of the Hayashi Trout Farm in Japan’s Fukushima Prefecture, is leading the push for Taiwanese grouper imports, the newspaper said. His call has caught the attention of several large sushi chains, the report said. Hayashi, who is the Fukushima branch head of the Friends of Lee Teng-hui Association in Japan,
‘TROJAN HORSE’ SCHEME: The comment that a bridge would allow China’s PLA to easily launch an attack shows ‘a lack of backbone,’ Taipei Mayor Ko Wen-je said Critics accused Taipei Mayor Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) of being oblivious to national security concerns after he proposed constructing a bridge to link Kinmen and China’s Xiamen (廈門). Ko, who is also the Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) chairman, made the proposal when presiding over the opening ceremony of the party’s office in Kinmen on Saturday. He said the bridge could solve Kinmen’s population, electricity and garbage problems, as well as serve as a shortcut for leaving or entering Taiwan without traveling via Taipei International Airport (Songshan airport). He also proposed building a hospital in Kinmen to attract people who are seeking medical treatment in
RSS