The Taipei District Court threw out an injunction request by Alstom-Siemens Eurotrain yesterday, deciding that negotiations between Taiwan High Speed Rail Corpora-tion (THSRC) and Japanese-backed Taiwan Shinkansen Consortium (TSC) did not constitute a basis for legal action by the European consortium.
The judge in the case ruled that Eurotrain failed to provide sufficient evidence for an injunction against THSRC.
The court decision came a day after reports of a letter to Premier Vincent Siew (
The Eurotrain consortium, led by Germany's Siemens AG and France's Alstom, has yet to decide whether to appeal the decision in Taiwan court or to file a request with an international arbitration court in Singapore.
Both the Eurotrain consortium and THSRC agreed in a 1997 accord to seek resolutions to any disputes in the arbitration court.
"Both an appeal and international arbitration could be possibilities. The decision will be made after Chinese New Year," said Phai Hua Way (
Furious at losing the construction bid to the Mitsubishi Heavy Industries-led Shinkansen consortium, Eurotrain requested a court order in mid-January to suspend any further negotiations and prevent the signing of a contract between THSRC and the TSC.
The filing of the injunction request was prompted by THSRC's announcement on Dec. 28 that it was awarding priority negotiating rights to TSC.
Eurotrain alleged the dramatic switch was in breach of the 1997 Eurotrain-THSRC agreement, which it claimed had obliged THSRC to sign a contract with it as long as its construction prices were considered reasonable.
In the 1997 deal, THSRC cited Eurotrain as its "preferred bidder" for the supply of train cars, locomotives, electronics and communication systems, and maintenance for the NT$440 billion rail project.
The court found, however, that the agreement did not give Eurotrain a guarantee on obtaining the construction contract, nor did it give the Europeans "exclusive" rights to negotiate with THSRC.
Furthermore, the court said, the provision on reasonable pricing implied that THSRC's negotiations with other parties could continue.
"The agreement does not exclude any other parties from negotiating with THSRC. And the plaintiff [Eurotrain], as a result, cannot assume it had the right to deter THSRC from signing contracts with other parties," the court reasoned.
"The agreement also required continuing negotiations for the parties to reach a common ground and to sign a binding contract. And in the course of negotiations, any disagreements could possibly prevent the contract from being signed," it added.
The court said Eurotrain still might have grounds to assert its negotiating rights on the basis of the 1997 agreement. It ruled, however, that the documents that Eurotrain had presented failed to provide grounds for blocking THSRC and TSC from signing contracts.
Eurotrain has used various means to protest THSRC's switch to the Shinkansen consortium. Prior to Patten's letter, Siemens AG chairman Heinrich von Pierer and heads of the German, French and British trade offices in Taipei had all met with high-ranking Taiwan officials to discuss the deal.
Three cases of Candida auris, a fungus that can cause a yeast infection known as candidiasis in humans, have been reported in Taiwan over the past few years, but they did not display drug resistance, Centers for Disease Control (CDC) Deputy Director-General Philip Lo (羅一鈞) said yesterday. Lo made the statement at a news conference in Taipei, one day after the Washington Post reported that the potentially deadly fungus is spreading in US hospitals. The fungus was first discovered in Japan in 2009 and poses a danger to immunocompromised people, with an estimated mortality rate of 30 to 60 percent, Lo
‘COINCIDENCE’: The former president should keep in mind local and global response to his actions and abide by the law to safeguard national interests, the MAC said The Presidential Office yesterday confirmed that it has received an application from former president Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) to visit China next week and would be discussing his security detail. “As the travel restrictions on former president Ma have expired, we respect his plan to pay respect to his ancestors in China,” Presidential Office spokeswoman Lin Yu-chan (林聿禪) said. “We will review his travel plan and consult concerned agencies to assist him in arranging his security detail.” “We also hope that Ma, as a former commander in chief of Taiwan, acts in a manner that aligns with national interests and does not hurt
‘DIRE’: Taiwan would not engage in ‘dollar diplomacy,’ the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said, after China reportedly offered Honduras up to US$3 billion to establish relations The government yesterday recalled its ambassador to Honduras after the Central American nation sent its foreign minister to China, signaling that it would sever diplomatic ties with Taiwan. Suspicions concerning ties with Honduras are rife after Honduran President Xiomara Castro on Tuesday last week wrote on Twitter that her country would pursue diplomatic ties with China. Honduran Minister of Foreign Affairs Eduardo Enrique Reina traveled to China on Wednesday “to promote efforts for the establishment of diplomatic relations” on instructions from Castro, Reuters yesterday quoted Honduran presidential spokesman Ivis Alvarado as saying. The government “has decided to immediately recall the ambassador to Honduras
‘NOTHING NEW’: China should not use Tsai Ing-wen’s transits through the US as a pretext to step up aggressive activity in the Taiwan Strait, a Washington official said President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) is to stop over in the US on her way to and from Central America next week, but her administration would not confirm a meeting with US House of Representatives Speaker Kevin McCarthy. Tsai’s delegation is to leave Taipei on Wednesday next week and stop over in New York City, Presidential Office spokeswoman Lin Yu-chan (林聿禪) told a news conference yesterday. Tsai is then to head to Guatemala on Saturday next week for talks with Guatemalan President Alejandro Giammattei and to meet with Taiwanese expatriates, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said. On April 3, Tsai is scheduled to travel
RSS