In certain ways, this autumn in the US has recalled the autumn of 1938 in Nazi Germany, when mass deportation of undocumented people was one of Hitler’s most ambitious coercive policies before the start of World War II. In the US, too, the connection between domestic repression and foreign aggression is coming into focus.
That fall, the German police and SS rounded up 17,000 Jews with Polish citizenship and dumped them across the border into neighboring Poland. This set off a chain of events which provides a useful perspective on where the US is now. A family was deported; a desperate refugee took revenge; the government organized a pogrom and reorganized its police; war followed.
The family was the Grynszpans. The father and mother had moved to Germany in 1911 from the Russian Empire. Their children were born in Germany, spoke German and saw themselves as Germans. Their son Herschel had left to stay with relatives in Paris, where he faced a series of disappointments with his documentation, including the loss of his citizenship.
Denied permanent residence in France in the summer of 1938, Herschel Grynszpan was hiding in an attic to avoid deportation when a postcard from his sister arrived: “Everything is finished for us.”
Herschel Grynszpan took revenge. On Nov. 7, 1938, he walked into the German embassy in Paris and shot the diplomat Ernst vom Rath. A policy of mass deportation had led to a reaction that, although unpredictable in its details, was not surprising.
In Berlin, the Nazis saw an opportunity. Joseph Goebbels invoked a conspiracy and conflated the actions of one person with the responsibility of a group, and Hitler allowed Goebbels to organize a nationwide pogrom — Kristallnacht — two days later. The Sturm Abeilung, the SS and the Hitler Youth, joined by many other Germans, destroyed Jewish businesses, burned Jewish books, desecrated Torah scrolls and invaded Jewish homes — 91 Jews were killed and hundreds died by suicide. Tens of thousands of Jewish men were sent to concentration camps.
Nine decades later, no one could foresee exactly what would happen when the administration of Us President Donald Trump made deportation of the undocumented its basic policy, with the National Guard deployed in Los Angeles and Washington — cities that should be seen as “training grounds for our military” and “war zones,” but it was predictable that there would be some consequence. It arrived in the form of the shooting of two National Guard soldiers patrolling in Washington. One subsequently died from her wounds.
The accused is a refugee from Afghanistan who had assisted the US war effort in his homeland. Like Herschel Grynszpan, he is someone who experienced trauma and dehumanization. Having fought and killed for a foreign government in his own nation, the assassin had reason to expect some sort of shelter after he and his family were evacuated from Afghanistan to the US. It appears he faced only a series of disappointments.
His experience, as reported by the New York Times, was eerily similar to Herschel Grynszpan’s. While “it was unclear what exactly triggered” the attacker, a volunteer who worked with the family “sensed part of it was his frustrations with the uncertainty of America’s immigration process” and his family’s fear that they would be “deported to Afghanistan as his application for a Special Immigrant Visa dragged on.”
This is not an excuse for a horrible act. It is a fact that is necessary to understand the structure of the historical moment.
It was foreseeable that Trump would seek to exploit such violence. He announced his intention to target “Third World countries,” blamed all of the US’ problems on migrants and called Somalis “garbage.” Trump expressed his desire to deport millions of people and to denaturalize — strip citizenship from — Americans whose values he disparages or whom he deems incompatible with “Western civilization.” Life will be made even harder for non-citizens in the US.
What comes next?
For the Nazis, the mass deportation and pogrom of autumn 1938 were steps toward creating a centralized national police agency, the Reich Security Main Office, the following year. In the US, something similar is unfolding with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) — initially tasked to carry out deportations, ICE has taken on espionage roles, provoked citizens and been reinforced by soldiers of the National Guard. In these respects, it is becoming something like a national police force, with ideological propaganda and links to the armed forces.
In one way, mass deportations and Kristallnacht advanced the consolidation of the Nazi regime, but this kind of instability was unpopular in Germany — much as ICE raids are unpopular in US cities. The radical next steps were possible only under cover of war. That would be the classic next step in the regime change that Trump seems determined to carry out in the US. War is the easy way to eliminate internal enemies by identifying them with an external enemy.
For Trump, starting a war with Venezuela (or another nation) would be the next logical move in advancing regime change at home. It is not hard to see that Trump understands this, given his escalating provocations since the summer, when the US began attacking alleged drug smugglers in the Caribbean Sea, including shipwrecked survivors killed in an obvious breach of international law.
The past never repeats, but it does instruct — and it instructs everyone. The people who want authoritarianism in the US know that seizing on the emotions associated with political belonging can lead to turmoil and regime change, and the people who want democracy in the US can see the pattern and, by naming it, take the crucial first step toward bringing the process to a halt.
Timothy Snyder, the inaugural chair in Modern European History at the Munk School of Global Affairs and Public Policy at the University of Toronto and a permanent fellow at the Institute for Human Sciences in Vienna, is the author or editor of 20 books.
Copyright: Project Syndicate
The image was oddly quiet. No speeches, no flags, no dramatic announcements — just a Chinese cargo ship cutting through arctic ice and arriving in Britain in October. The Istanbul Bridge completed a journey that once existed only in theory, shaving weeks off traditional shipping routes. On paper, it was a story about efficiency. In strategic terms, it was about timing. Much like politics, arriving early matters. Especially when the route, the rules and the traffic are still undefined. For years, global politics has trained us to watch the loud moments: warships in the Taiwan Strait, sanctions announced at news conferences, leaders trading
The saga of Sarah Dzafce, the disgraced former Miss Finland, is far more significant than a mere beauty pageant controversy. It serves as a potent and painful contemporary lesson in global cultural ethics and the absolute necessity of racial respect. Her public career was instantly pulverized not by a lapse in judgement, but by a deliberate act of racial hostility, the flames of which swiftly encircled the globe. The offensive action was simple, yet profoundly provocative: a 15-second video in which Dzafce performed the infamous “slanted eyes” gesture — a crude, historically loaded caricature of East Asian features used in Western
Is a new foreign partner for Taiwan emerging in the Middle East? Last week, Taiwanese media reported that Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Francois Wu (吳志中) secretly visited Israel, a country with whom Taiwan has long shared unofficial relations but which has approached those relations cautiously. In the wake of China’s implicit but clear support for Hamas and Iran in the wake of the October 2023 assault on Israel, Jerusalem’s calculus may be changing. Both small countries facing literal existential threats, Israel and Taiwan have much to gain from closer ties. In his recent op-ed for the Washington Post, President William
A stabbing attack inside and near two busy Taipei MRT stations on Friday evening shocked the nation and made headlines in many foreign and local news media, as such indiscriminate attacks are rare in Taiwan. Four people died, including the 27-year-old suspect, and 11 people sustained injuries. At Taipei Main Station, the suspect threw smoke grenades near two exits and fatally stabbed one person who tried to stop him. He later made his way to Eslite Spectrum Nanxi department store near Zhongshan MRT Station, where he threw more smoke grenades and fatally stabbed a person on a scooter by the roadside.
RSS