Economic news from China has triggered the same helpless, sinking feeling that gripped me when Japan’s property bubble collapsed from 1991 to 1992. With China heading down the same path of deflation and stagnation which Japan embarked on three decades ago, would this sense of deja vu continue?
This month, Evergrande Group — the Chinese real-estate developer that defaulted on its debt in 2021 — filed for Chapter 15 bankruptcy protection in the US in the hopes of restructuring its dollar-denominated debts. Chapter 15 allows a US court to intervene in an insolvency case involving another country. Meanwhile, property developer Country Garden has missed US$22.5 million in payments for offshore bonds and suspended trading in 11 onshore bonds, raising the prospect of a default.
These are hardly isolated incidents. China’s real-estate sector is buckling under the weight of falling prices, a large inventory of unsold housing and office buildings which is showing no signs of slowing, and highly indebted developers. A property bubble collapse seems likelier every day.
The implications for growth could be dire. Annual Japanese GDP growth amounted to 4 to 5 percent on average, from the mid-1970s through to the 1980s. After the property bubble burst, that rate sank to 0 to 2 percent. Japan’s economy has not recaptured its prebubble dynamism ever since.
China is already experiencing a sharp slowdown in its growth. While it is normal for a fast-growing emerging-market economy to slow as income per capita increases, the scale of China’s slowdown in last year and this year is notable. In the second quarter of this year, quarterly GDP grew by just 0.8 percent, compared to 2.2 percent in the first quarter.
To be sure, second-quarter growth amounted to 6.3 percent in year-on-year terms, and the government’s annual growth target of 5 percent could yet be achieved. Nonetheless, China’s economic prospects appear to be dimming rapidly. Falling inflation — the consumer price index declined last month by 0.3 percent year on year — further darkens the outlook, as it points to possible deflation.
While China’s travails can be blamed partly on its delayed exit from its “zero COVID-19” policy, investment slowdown has played a major role. Foreign portfolio investors are pulling out of Chinese capital markets, and inward foreign direct investment is declining fast.
This is partly the result of the US-China decoupling, but it is also a reaction to China’s anti-espionage law, under which foreign businesses have been prosecuted for activities that are normal everywhere else in the world. It was under that law that a Japanese employee of the drug-maker Astellas Pharma Inc was detained in March, and he has yet to be released. Unsurprisingly, foreign companies are finding it difficult to recruit employees willing to work in China.
The manipulation and obfuscation of data by Chinese authorities offers more reason for pessimism. China’s announcement that it would no longer disclose youth unemployment figures suggests that the level of joblessness among young Chinese people is dire. With even official data showing that China’s population began to decline last year, growing unemployment (and under-employment) can mean only one thing: the economy as a whole is weakening fast.
China’s demographic decline is its own cause for concern. As Japan can attest, a shrinking working-age population stokes powerful social and fiscal pressures, not least ballooning pension costs and worker shortages in labor-intensive industries, including medical and long-term care. Given decades of fertility-control policies, China would confront a much faster demographic transition than Japan did. And while it has expanded social-security protections in recent years, much more must be done to meet the demographic challenge ahead.
Two factors unique to China would affect how any economic crisis unfolds. First, because a large share of real-estate investment is carried out through so-called local government financing vehicles, the sector’s performance has a direct impact on public balance sheets. Debt held by local government financing vehicles (LGFV) reached an estimated 165.57 trillion yuan (US$22.7 trillion) — or 42 percent of GDP — at the end of last year.
Given this, if a property bubble bursts, local governments would suffer severe debt distress, and might even default, potentially delivering a sharp blow to both domestic and international investors. To help mitigate the risks, the central government has authorized local governments to issue their own bonds, revenues from which can be used to repay LGFV debts.
However, while this would improve balance sheet transparency, it is ultimately just substituting one form of debt for another.
The second factor unique to China is that its four biggest banks are state-owned, so the central bank and the government can always step in to provide capital and avert a banking crisis. Repeated capital injections might be viewed as a sign of moral hazard.
However, only 20 percent of non-performing loans (NPLs) in China are the result of risk-management failures by banks, the rest are loans that were directed by the government or issued to distressed state-owned enterprises (SOEs). Any bailout is just a case of the government taking responsibility for the lending it directed.
If the property bubble bursts, China’s banks and government must avoid the mistakes Japan made three decades ago. Full and timely disclosure of NPLs is essential. Chinese banks must not succumb to the “evergreening” temptation and extend new loans to insolvent “zombie” borrowers so that they appear healthy. Furthermore, capital injections must be delivered quickly to where they are needed.
Likewise, China’s government should take steps to stop the evergreening of SOEs and real-estate companies, and ensure that banks and LGFVs pursue debt restructuring, supported by capital injections if needed. Local governments should be allowed to raise taxes, using the added revenues to pay down their debts.
If China fails to address the risks that its economy is accumulating, a Japan-style period of stagnation and deflation would become inevitable, and the entire world would suffer.
Takatoshi Ito, a former Japanese deputy vice minister of finance, is a professor at the School of International and Public Affairs at Columbia University and a senior professor at the National Graduate Institute for Policy Studies in Tokyo.
Copyright: Project Syndicate
Xiaomi Corp founder Lei Jun (雷軍) on May 22 made a high-profile announcement, giving online viewers a sneak peek at the company’s first 3-nanometer mobile processor — the Xring O1 chip — and saying it is a breakthrough in China’s chip design history. Although Xiaomi might be capable of designing chips, it lacks the ability to manufacture them. No matter how beautifully planned the blueprints are, if they cannot be mass-produced, they are nothing more than drawings on paper. The truth is that China’s chipmaking efforts are still heavily reliant on the free world — particularly on Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing
Keelung Mayor George Hsieh (謝國樑) of the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) on Tuesday last week apologized over allegations that the former director of the city’s Civil Affairs Department had illegally accessed citizens’ data to assist the KMT in its campaign to recall Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) councilors. Given the public discontent with opposition lawmakers’ disruptive behavior in the legislature, passage of unconstitutional legislation and slashing of the central government’s budget, civic groups have launched a massive campaign to recall KMT lawmakers. The KMT has tried to fight back by initiating campaigns to recall DPP lawmakers, but the petition documents they
A recent scandal involving a high-school student from a private school in Taichung has reignited long-standing frustrations with Taiwan’s increasingly complex and high-pressure university admissions system. The student, who had successfully gained admission to several prestigious medical schools, shared their learning portfolio on social media — only for Internet sleuths to quickly uncover a falsified claim of receiving a “Best Debater” award. The fallout was swift and unforgiving. National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University and Taipei Medical University revoked the student’s admission on Wednesday. One day later, Chung Shan Medical University also announced it would cancel the student’s admission. China Medical
Construction of the Ma-anshan Nuclear Power Plant in Pingtung County’s Hengchun Township (恆春) started in 1978. It began commercial operations in 1984. Since then, it has experienced several accidents, radiation pollution and fires. It was finally decommissioned on May 17 after the operating license of its No. 2 reactor expired. However, a proposed referendum to be held on Aug. 23 on restarting the reactor is potentially bringing back those risks. Four reasons are listed for holding the referendum: First, the difficulty of meeting greenhouse gas reduction targets and the inefficiency of new energy sources such as photovoltaic and wind power. Second,
RSS