An argument about an inadequate supply of free rice at a stir-fry restaurant prompted some National Taipei University of Technology students to give the restaurant a string of negative one-star online reviews. The restaurant owner then tried to enlist public opinion against the students’ online “trial” by complaining to the news media.
To begin with, both sides thought they could stand on the high ground and watch the other side get swept away, but unexpectedly news media and the Internet interacted in a way that overwhelmed them both. Both sides were battered and wanted to stop the fight, but the spectators insisted that the show must go on.
One factor that has received little attention is the issue of Internet literacy.
In the “post-truth era,” everyone thinks they are seeing the truth, but the truth they find is the “truth as interpreted or judged by each individual” and “the truth as seen by social groups.”
To attract more clicks and views, some online media exaggerate their headlines and content to make them as “shocking” as possible. Internet readers and viewers who spot news stories of this kind would often start “throwing stones,” slinging all sorts of negative comments and messages at the accused party. However, such stories might only be partly true or present only part of the facts, which can easily cause Internet users to misjudge the situation and unjustly attack the people involved.
In November last year, there was an incident in which a fried chicken restaurant owner “yelled” at a teenager with Down syndrome. When the story was first reported, it drew a lot of negative comments online, with most saying the restaurant owner “had no conscience” and “bullied the Down syndrome kid.”
The teenager’s mother later handed out a leaflet in the local community, after which the restaurant owner cut his wrist due to all the stress and was taken to hospital.
This prompted a tide of negative messages attacking the mother, saying things like: “Will you only be happy when you drive this person to death?”
These examples show that “Internet justice” tends to sympathize with the underdog. In the rice incident, as soon as the restaurant owner announced that he was suspending business indefinitely, the tide of negative comments turned against the students, saying things like: “Are you happy to have forced the owner to shut down his business and put his staff out of a job?” Some media outlets even behaved like spectators, spicing up the story with headlines like “Stir-fry boss throws in the towel.”
“Internet justice” has several characteristics. First, it is easily incited. Second, it easily pulls a crowd. Third, it can easily switch positions. These features show how shallow and volatile “Internet justice” can be. It can quickly build up pressure and become a powerful weapon to attack opponents, but if it is overmanipulated or people see through its intentions, it could spin out of control and backfire on whoever is manipulating it.
To avoid acting like a herd, Internet users should have basic Internet literacy. When you first see a “shocking” online news story or message, resist the temptation to immediately comment based on your gut feeling.
Start by asking yourself three questions. First, is it fake news? Second, is it only partly true, or only one side of the story? Third, are there any alternative opinions? There will still be time to comment after clearing up these questions. In conclusion, apart from media literacy, Internet literacy should be another important policy objective for governments to educate the public.
Hsu Chih-ming is an assistant professor at Shih Hsin University’s Department of Journalism.
Translated by Julian Clegg
When Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) sits down with US President Donald Trump in Beijing on Thursday next week, Xi is unlikely to demand a dramatic public betrayal of Taiwan. He does not need to. Beijing’s preferred victory is smaller, quieter and in some ways far more dangerous: a subtle shift in American wording that appears technical, but carries major strategic meaning. The ask is simple: replace the longstanding US formulation that Washington “does not support Taiwan independence” with a harder one — that Washington “opposes” Taiwan independence. One word changes; a deterrence structure built over decades begins to shift.
Taipei is facing a severe rat infestation, and the city government is reportedly considering large-scale use of rodenticides as its primary control measure. However, this move could trigger an ecological disaster, including mass deaths of birds of prey. In the past, black kites, relatives of eagles, took more than three decades to return to the skies above the Taipei Basin. Taiwan’s black kite population was nearly wiped out by the combined effects of habitat destruction, pesticides and rodenticides. By 1992, fewer than 200 black kites remained on the island. Fortunately, thanks to more than 30 years of collective effort to preserve their remaining
After Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Chairwoman Cheng Li-wun (鄭麗文) met Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) in Beijing, most headlines referred to her as the leader of the opposition in Taiwan. Is she really, though? Being the chairwoman of the KMT does not automatically translate into being the leader of the opposition in the sense that most foreign readers would understand it. “Leader of the opposition” is a very British term. It applies to the Westminster system of parliamentary democracy, and to some extent, to other democracies. If you look at the UK right now, Conservative Party head Kemi Badenoch is
A Pale View of Hills, a movie released last year, follows the story of a Japanese woman from Nagasaki who moved to Britain in the 1950s with her British husband and daughter from a previous marriage. The daughter was born at a time when memories of the US atomic bombing of Nagasaki during World War II and anxiety over the effects of nuclear radiation still haunted the community. It is a reflection on the legacy of the local and national trauma of the bombing that ended the period of Japanese militarism. A central theme of the movie is the need, at
RSS