With Christmas less than three weeks away, an undercover investigation has revealed the bleak realities of life in Chinese toy factories serving a market worth ￡2.8 billion (US$4.38 billion) a year in the UK alone.
Big brands such as Disney, Lego and Marks & Spencer (M&S) pay only a fraction of the shop price of products to the factories that make their toys. Last summer — as factories geared up to cope with demand for the Christmas period — investigators spent three weeks in the industrial cities of Shenzhen and Dongguan.
In some cases, they found that: Employees worked up to 140 extra hours overtime a month; were paid up to a month late; claimed they were expected to work with dangerous tools and machines without training or safety measures; and had to work in silence and were fined up to ￡5 for going to the toilet without permission.
Perhaps the most insidious effect of the long hours and poor wages was how it tore families apart, separating mothers and fathers from their children for all but a few days a year. Many workers were too afraid to speak to the investigators from the human rights group Students & Scholars Against Corporate Misbehaviour (SACOM), but two women did agree to talk on condition that their names were changed.
Wang Fengping, 27, has two daughters, seven and five. They live a 10-hour train journey away from the On Tai Toys factory. She and her husband earn ￡200 a month making toys for Disney and others, but cannot afford to bring the children to the city. Instead, the girls are cared for by their grandparents. Wang calls them two or three times a week. The younger one always asks her when she is coming home.
“Very soon,” Wang always replies.
The reality is that they will meet only once a year, at Lunar New Year, never at Christmas. She keeps her spirits up by telling her workmates stories of how well the girls are doing at school. Sometimes she sings them songs the girls have learned at school and then sung to her down the phone.
“Our family will not die from hunger, but cannot be fed with this wage level,” she said.
Ma Hui, 25, works for the Hung Hing Printing Group, making items for M&S, Lego and Disney. She has a two-year-old daughter, whom she had to leave behind when the child was just three months old in the hope that she could earn enough one day to return home to set up her own business and reunite the family. She, too, only sees her child once a year and has hung a picture of her daughter on the dormitory wall next to her bed.
SACOM accuses big global brands of failing to pay the factories enough, with workers suffering because factories undercut each other in an attempt to secure contracts. The report also accuses the industry’s own regulator of failing to clamp down on rights abuses.
“In the run-up to Christmas, toys are a popular choice as presents for children,” SACOM spokeswoman Debby Chan Sze Wan said. “They probably bring joy to consumers and the toy companies, but the workers cannot afford toys or books for their beloved children. The hardship of workers is due to the exploitation in the global supply chain. If the brands do not raise the unit price and change their purchasing practices, no structural change in working conditions in the toy industry is feasible.”
Investigators targeted three factories, including On Tai Toys Co, which manufactures for Disney and a number of other international brands, and Hung Hing. All the factories are certified as decent toy manufacturers by the International Council of Toy Industries, which is supposed to police ethical standards in more than 2,400 factories that employ about 1.7 million people worldwide.
However, SACOM has accused the council of permitting “rampant labor rights violations” in factories it has certified.
At the Hung Hing factory, the researcher found that the 8,000 workers put in up to 100 hours of overtime a month, equivalent to an additional eight normal working days on top of the legal maximum. Workers say they have to sign a document agreeing to work additional overtime on top of the legal maximum. The basic wage was ￡132 a month (up to ￡250 with maximum overtime payments), but wages were paid up to three weeks late.
Workers complained of inadequate training with the factory machines and last year one worker died when he fell into a machine. They said there were frequent injuries and concerns over the chemicals used. There were also complaints about the standard of the dormitories, where water for washing and flushing toilets is turned off at 10pm.
At the On Tai Toy Co, the researcher found that most of the 1,500 workers were aged between 30 and 50, though about 300 students are drafted in to help cope with the peak season.
The researcher spent three weeks in the factory and found workers put in up to 140 hours of overtime every month, nearly four times the 36-hour-a-month legal limit.
Basic pay is ￡110 a month, but wages were paid a month late, in breach of labor law. During the peak summer season workers could make up to ￡240 a month, including overtime, but that falls to ￡140 during low season.
A typical working day during the peak season starts at 8am and does not end until 10pm. Workers routinely put in six-day weeks, but if the factory is busy, there are no days off.
Workers complained that they were banned from talking to each other on the production line and were fined up to ￡5 if they went to the toilet without applying for an “off-duty” permit.
They reported regular burns from soldering irons and electric shocks from old hair dryers used to set glue, along with concerns about the effect on their health of unmarked chemicals they have to work with. The law requires the chemicals to be identified and for workers to be instructed in what to do in case of an accident. Up to 10 workers share each 20m2 dormitory room, which is fitted with bunk beds. Dozens share the toilet and the outside of the building is piled deep with garbage, which is home to rats.
In response to the SACOM researchers’ allegations, Disney said: “The Walt Disney Company and its affiliates take claims of unfair labor practices very seriously, and investigate any such allegations thoroughly.”
Lego said the investigation into working practices at the factory had raised very serious issues, which it took very seriously and which it had asked its licensing partner, Dorling Kindersley, to investigate.
“Ensuring respect for workers’ rights is very important to the Lego Group and all our partners agree to adhere to a strict set of guidelines — our code of conduct,” Lego said. “The Lego Group requires all of its licensing partners to give a written assurance that their vendors, too, comply with the Lego Group’s code of conduct, and to audit their suppliers on an annual basis. Adhering to the code of conduct is something that we prioritize in our engagement with our partners. It appears that in this case, the code may have been broken and we are addressing this urgently. Once we have the full facts we will take decisive action.”
Dorling Kindersley said that it was deeply concerned by the allegations and had contacted Hung Hing to express its view: “We have strict ethical sourcing standards covering all the issues identified by this investigation. The allegations, if true, would demonstrate a breach of these standards.”
It said the factory had recently been audited, but that would now be reviewed, adding: “Our terms of business are absolutely clear, that any supplier in breach of our ethical standards is required to change their practices or face termination.”
A spokesman for Marks & Spencer said: “We are a very small customer of the Hung Hing Printing Group — less than 0.5 percent of its business. We take any allegation that suggests a breach of our strict ethical standards very seriously and work closely with all our suppliers, including this factory, to ensure they adhere to our strict standards.”
Hung Hing responded with a four-page letter from its general manager, Dennis Wong, in which it admitted that workers could be asked to do overtime of up to 92 hours a month in July and August. The letter said that last month overtime ranged between 23 and 77 hours. The company said workers who refused to do the extra hours were not penalized.
It blamed late payment of wages on the complexity of calculating the rates for more than 8,000 workers, and said this was a standard industry practice. It said that workers did receive safety training, but warned that individual managers would be held responsible for future lapses and would have pay deducted.
The company said that providing water to the toilets after 10pm was wasteful and that barrels of water were available for workers to use to flush.
The conflict in the Middle East has been disrupting financial markets, raising concerns about rising inflationary pressures and global economic growth. One market that some investors are particularly worried about has not been heavily covered in the news: the private credit market. Even before the joint US-Israeli attacks on Iran on Feb. 28, global capital markets had faced growing structural pressure — the deteriorating funding conditions in the private credit market. The private credit market is where companies borrow funds directly from nonbank financial institutions such as asset management companies, insurance companies and private lending platforms. Its popularity has risen since
An article published in the Dec. 12, 1949, edition of the Central Daily News (中央日報) bore a headline with the intimidating phrase: “You Cannot Escape.” The article was about the execution of seven “communist spies,” some say on the basis of forced confessions, at the end of the 713 Penghu Incident. Those were different times, born of political paranoia shortly after the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) relocated to Taiwan following defeat in China by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). The phrase was a warning by the KMT regime to the local populace not to challenge its power or threaten national unity. The
Philippine Coast Guard spokesman Jay Tarriela on March 1 was promoted from commodore to rear admiral from Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. The promotion is a striking testament to how Beijing’s intimidation tactics on its current main target in the South China Sea have backfired. It is also yet another example that Taiwan can look to when it comes to responding to Chinese scare campaigns. Tarriela has been consistent in his approach since Manila launched its transparency initiative in early 2023 to counter Chinese “gray zone” tactics around its western waters. As the face of the West Philippine Sea Transparency Office,
The Iran war has exposed a fundamental vulnerability in the global energy system. The escalating confrontation between Iran, Israel and the US has begun to shake international energy markets, largely because Iran is disrupting shipping through the Strait of Hormuz. This narrow waterway carries roughly one-third of the world’s seaborne oil, making it one of the most strategically sensitive energy corridors in the world. Even the possibility of disruption has triggered sharp volatility in global oil prices. The duration and scope of the conflict remain uncertain, with senior US officials offering contradictory signals about how long military operations might continue.
RSS