This stretch of rolling dairy country has long been Milton Hershey’s turf, where he first found success making chocolate more than a century ago and earned a name synonymous with chocolate in the US.
But M&M-making rival Mars has crept up on Hershey’s dominance of US chocolate buyers. And now, Mars has delivered a chocolate-coated slap in the face, setting up shop in south-central Pennsylvania, just 16km from Hershey’s flagship factory on Chocolate Avenue.
The US$70 million “Dove Chocolate Center of Excellence” is the latest sign that the spotlight-shy Mars is breaking out of its shell as it tries to pound cracks into the long-held notion that Hershey is the real US chocolate company.
While Mars makes its surprisingly sharp-tongued attack, Hershey has struggled to cut costs by closing US plants and blending cocoa butter substitutes into some of its chocolate candy — a step that has riled candy enthusiasts who say it dulls the flavor and feel of pure chocolate.
At the unveiling of its newly expanded Dove factory late last month, Mars Snackfood US president Todd Lachman said — without naming Hershey — that cost-cutting competitors are “tricking” consumers with substitutes and outsourcing US jobs.
“The consumer is our compass, and we will always deliver 100 percent real, authentic chocolate products that have been manufactured here in the United States,” Lachman said.
Mars has also pivoted its publicity messages to chide its rival: Its premium brand Dove is “Made in the USA” and Mars can be trusted “to provide pure, rich chocolate,” it says. And Mars is making its case just as it is leapfrogging Hershey as the largest US candymaker, with its US$23 billion purchase of mint and chewing-gum giant Wm Wrigley Jr Co.
Meanwhile, Hershey is closing six plants — three in Canada and one each in California, Connecticut and Pennsylvania — to cut costs and compete in faster-growing and cheaper regions. All told, Hershey is cutting about 3,000 US jobs and expanding its operations in Mexico, India, China and Brazil.
While Mars will still lag behind Hershey’s prized top spot in the US chocolate market — which totals US$16 billion — analysts agree that Hershey is facing a serious challenge.
Together, Hershey and Mars control better than two-thirds of the US chocolate market, the world’s largest. But Hershey’s edge — currently about 42.5 percent to Mars’ 30 percent, IRI/Neilsen data provided to Hershey shows — has slipped several percentage points in the last couple years as Mars has outmarketed and outmaneuvered Hershey, analysts say.
“I think that Mars sees a weakness and anyone who can get ahead in this economy is going to get ahead, even the secretive Mars,” said Marcia Mogelonsky, a senior analyst with Chicago-based market research firm Mintel International Group Ltd.
Hershey defended itself by saying its plant closings are part of broader changes to ensure its long-term competitiveness. The company also said consumer taste-testers approved of the substitutes for cocoa butter, such as sunflower oil and palm oil. In Mr Goodbar, for instance, the change lets the peanut flavor shine through, Hershey spokesman Kirk Saville said.
Besides, Hershey maintains that 85 percent of its chocolate lineup is pure, including popular items like Hershey’s bars, Kisses and Reese’s peanut butter cups. Even with a cocoa butter substitute, a Mr Goodbar has more chocolate by percentage weight than Mars’ Snickers bar, Saville said, and a Krackel has more than a Mars-made Three Musketeers.
“Hershey is chocolate,” Saville said. “We’ve made the world’s best chocolate for more than 100 years.”
Hershey would not provide a list of the products in which it uses a substitute. But under the US federal government’s rules for food standards, Hershey cannot call those products “chocolate,” and a keen eye can scan the packaging and ingredients list and figure it out, candy bar by candy bar.
On the packaging, Hershey dances around the term — Whatchamacallit has a “chocolatey coating,” Mr. Goodbar is “made with chocolate” and Kissables are “chocolate candy.”
And sometimes ingredients speak for themselves: Products with the substitutes do not taste fresh and vibrant, said Cybele May of Los Angeles, who reviews sweets at www.candyblog.net.
“The wonderful thing about cocoa butter is that it melts in your mouth,” May said. “Oils replicate that behavior, but they never get it right.”
Given health scares and concerns about food quality — Chinese milk anyone? — it can be an effective marketing tactic for Mars to cast doubt on its rival’s product, said Jean-Pierre Dube, a marketing professor at the University of Chicago Graduate School of Business. And with both companies strapped by the skyrocketing cost of commodities such as cocoa and milk, Mars’ knocks on Hershey’s quality might persuade consumers to pay a higher price for a Mars product, Dube said.
Whether Mars’ criticism is fair is another question.
Hershey is not alone in using chocolate substitutes: Mars does it in countries where the rules are different. Other candymakers, including Nestle, do not use real chocolate in some of their US candy.
Fair or not, Laurel Haring’s mind is made up.
Once a daily devotee to Hershey’s Kissables, Haring noticed this year that the candies had stopped tasting like chocolate.
“It wasn’t creamy, it wasn’t sweet, it wasn’t milky,” said Haring, 47. “It was just nasty.”
Haring’s husband prowled drugstores and grocery stores near their home in Wilmington, Delaware, in search of the good Kissables, and came up empty. She even contacted Hershey to tell them something was wrong — and got coupons instead of an explanation.
A few weeks ago, she stumbled onto an online news item about Hershey’s use of substitutes — it featured an image of Kissables — but by then she had moved on.
To Dove Promise squares.
CARROT AND STICK: While unrelenting in its military threats, China attracted nearly 40,000 Taiwanese to over 400 business events last year Nearly 40,000 Taiwanese last year joined industry events in China, such as conferences and trade fairs, supported by the Chinese government, a study showed yesterday, as Beijing ramps up a charm offensive toward Taipei alongside military pressure. China has long taken a carrot-and-stick approach to Taiwan, threatening it with the prospect of military action while reaching out to those it believes are amenable to Beijing’s point of view. Taiwanese security officials are wary of what they see as Beijing’s influence campaigns to sway public opinion after Taipei and Beijing gradually resumed travel links halted by the COVID-19 pandemic, but the scale of
TRADE: A mandatory declaration of origin for manufactured goods bound for the US is to take effect on May 7 to block China from exploiting Taiwan’s trade channels All products manufactured in Taiwan and exported to the US must include a signed declaration of origin starting on May 7, the Bureau of Foreign Trade announced yesterday. US President Donald Trump on April 2 imposed a 32 percent tariff on imports from Taiwan, but one week later announced a 90-day pause on its implementation. However, a universal 10 percent tariff was immediately applied to most imports from around the world. On April 12, the Trump administration further exempted computers, smartphones and semiconductors from the new tariffs. In response, President William Lai’s (賴清德) administration has introduced a series of countermeasures to support affected
Pope Francis is be laid to rest on Saturday after lying in state for three days in St Peter’s Basilica, where the faithful are expected to flock to pay their respects to history’s first Latin American pontiff. The cardinals met yesterday in the Vatican’s synod hall to chart the next steps before a conclave begins to choose Francis’ successor, as condolences poured in from around the world. According to current norms, the conclave must begin between May 5 and 10. The cardinals set the funeral for Saturday at 10am in St Peter’s Square, to be celebrated by the dean of the College
CROSS-STRAIT: The vast majority of Taiwanese support maintaining the ‘status quo,’ while concern is rising about Beijing’s influence operations More than eight out of 10 Taiwanese reject Beijing’s “one country, two systems” framework for cross-strait relations, according to a survey released by the Mainland Affairs Council (MAC) on Thursday. The MAC’s latest quarterly survey found that 84.4 percent of respondents opposed Beijing’s “one country, two systems” formula for handling cross-strait relations — a figure consistent with past polling. Over the past three years, opposition to the framework has remained high, ranging from a low of 83.6 percent in April 2023 to a peak of 89.6 percent in April last year. In the most recent poll, 82.5 percent also rejected China’s
RSS