Malaysia is scrambling to protect its assets as the descendants of the last sultan of the remote Philippine region of Sulu look to enforce a US$15 billion arbitration award in a dispute over a colonial-era land deal.
In 1878, two European colonists signed a deal with the sultan for the use of his territory in present-day Malaysia — an agreement that independent Malaysia honored until 2013, paying the monarch’s descendants about US$1,000 per year.
Now, 144 years later after the original deal, Malaysia is on the hook for the second-largest arbitration award on record for stopping the payments after a bloody incursion by supporters of Sultan Mohammed Jamalul Alam’s heirs in which more than 50 people were killed.
Photo: Reuters
“It is a fascinating and unusual case,” said lawyer Paul Cohen, a lead cocounsel for the sultan’s heirs from British law firm 4-5 Gray’s Inn Square.
For years, Malaysia largely dismissed the claims, but last month, two Luxembourg-based subsidiaries of state energy firm Petronas were served with a seizure notice to enforce the award that the heirs won in February.
The arbitration ruling in France followed an eight-year legal effort by the heirs and US$20 million in funds raised for them from unidentified third-party investors, according to interviews with main figures in the case and legal documents seen by Reuters.
Malaysia did not participate in nor recognize the arbitration — allowing the heirs to present their case without rebuttal — despite warnings that it would be dangerous to ignore the process.
The claimants, including some retirees, are Filipinos leading middle-class lives, a far cry from their royal ancestors of the Sulu sultanate that once spanned rainforest-covered islands in the southern Philippines and parts of Borneo.
The heirs say that the 19th century deal was a commercial lease, which is why they chose arbitration. They also claimed compensation for the vast energy reserves that have since been discovered in the territory they gave up in Malaysia’s Sabah state on Borneo.
Malaysia said the sultanate ceded sovereignty and the arbitration was illegitimate.
“The arbitration is a sophisticated fiction, veiled as a legal process,” said Uria Menendez, a Spanish law firm representing Malaysia.
Malaysia has obtained a stay in France pending an appeal — a process that could take years — but the award remains enforceable globally under a UN convention on arbitration.
Malaysia honored the colonial-era deal until 2013, when supporters of the late Jamalul Kiram III, who claimed to be the rightful sultan of Sulu, attempted to reclaim Sabah.
Clashes erupted when about 200 supporters arrived in boats from the Philippines and lasted nearly a month.
Kiram, who claimed to be the “poorest sultan in the world,” was not one of the court-recognized heirs who received payments from Malaysia.
The eight claimants in the arbitration — including Kiram’s daughter and cousins — who received the annual payment have condemned the attack.
Up until the intrusion, the Malaysian embassy in Manila wrote a check to the claimants every year for “cession money,” according to checks and correspondence from the embassy to the heirs and shared with Reuters by the heirs’ lawyers.
Then-Malaysian prime minister Najib Razak said that he had stopped the payments due to public anger over the incursion, acknowledging the reason publicly for the first time.
“I felt it was incumbent upon my duty and responsibility to protect the sovereignty of Sabah and the people of Sabah,” he said, adding that he had not anticipated retaliatory legal action.
The claimants, through their lawyers, declined to be interviewed.
Cohen, the heirs’ lawyer, first heard of their claims from an oil-and-gas expert he cross-examined in 2014 in an unrelated case.
Knowing they did not have the financial means, Cohen in 2016 brought on board Therium, a British firm that has bankrolled legal actions by raising money from institutional investors, including a sovereign wealth fund.
Therium conducted nine rounds of funding for the case, during which third-party investors repeatedly assessed its merits, said Elisabeth Mason, a lead cocounsel for the claimants with 4-5 Gray’s Inn Square.
The case has cost more than US$20 million, including lawyers and researchers in eight jurisdictions, she said.
“Investors don’t invest lightly in such matters,” she said.
Therium said it would continue to finance efforts to enforce the award. It declined to provide details.
The heirs notified their intention to commence arbitration in 2017 in Spain and initially sought US$32.2 billion in compensation, the award statement showed.
Malaysia’s first response came in 2019 when then-attorney general Tommy Thomas offered to resume the annual payments and pay 48,000 ringgit (US$10,772 at the current exchange rate) in arrears and interest if the arbitration was dropped.
Thomas believed the demands were “absurd and ludicrous,” but made the offer after colleagues advised him that it was “perilous” to disregard the arbitration as Malaysia’s foreign assets could be at risk, he wrote in a memoir last year.
The heirs rejected Thomas’ offer and the arbitration went on without Malaysia’s participation.
Malaysia successfully challenged the appointment of Gonzalo Stampa as the sole arbitrator in a Spanish court last year.
Stampa argued in his award statement that the courts did not have jurisdiction over arbitration, and moved the case to France to deliver the award — actions that Malaysia says were unlawful.
Stampa is facing criminal proceedings in Spain following a complaint filed by Malaysia. He declined to comment.
By snubbing the arbitration, Malaysia is confined to arguing the procedural validity rather than making a case against the heirs’ claims, said N. Jansen Calamita, head of Investment Law and Policy at the National University of Singapore.
“It was a risky strategy and ultimately, I don’t think it has served them well,” he said.
POTENTIAL SETBACK: Although Chinese chip designers and foundry firms already have US EDA software, they might be unable to update those programs under new US rules The US’ latest ban on advanced electronic design automation (EDA) software exports to China might hinder Chinese chip companies from accessing advanced semiconductor technology, as they attempt to upgrade to 3-nanometer processes in the next three to five years, market researcher TrendForce Corp (集邦科技) said yesterday. The US Department of Commerce’s Bureau of Industry and Security on Friday announced bans on EDA tools for gate-all-around field-effect transistors (GAAFET), a new-generation semiconductor technology that US chipmaker Intel Corp and Samsung Electronics Co from South Korea are adopting to make 4-nanometer and 3-nanometer chips. The bureau in a statement said that gate-all-around field-effect transistor
DISMAL OUTLOOK: A Citigroup analyst predicted firms face ‘the worst semiconductor downturn in at least a decade,’ due to inventory build and the potential of a recession Semiconductor stocks tumbled after Micron Technology Inc became the latest chipmaker to warn about slowing demand, triggering concern that the industry is heading into a painful downturn. In the US on Tuesday, the Philadelphia semiconductor index sank 4.6 percent, with all 30 members in the red, its biggest drop in about two months. In Asia, chip stocks from Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) to Samsung Electronics Co, SK Hynix Inc and Tokyo Electron Ltd slumped. Investors are growing increasingly skittish as the notoriously cyclical industry is hurtling toward a prolonged slump after years of widespread shortages that led to heavy
With a tantalizing array of satay chicken, wok-fried mud crab and chilled tiger prawns, the dinner buffet at Singapore’s Grand Hyatt hotel typically sets diners back about US$70. Those on a tighter budget and with an eye on sustainability can fill a box for one-tenth of that price. Across Asia, tech start-ups are taking food otherwise destined for landfill and providing discounted meals through mobile phone apps. About one-third of food is lost or wasted every year globally, and the mountains of waste are estimated to cause 8 to 10 percent of greenhouse gas emissions such as methane, the UN says.
POSITIVE CULTURE: Pursuing 12-inch wafers earlier than peers helped TSMC lead the industry, said a former executive, whose main regret was working for SMIC in China Corporate culture at Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) is what made the chipmaker a leading player in the global industry, a former executive said in an interview with California’s Computer History Museum. “One of the really important reasons that TSMC succeeded” is the culture at the firm, where “if equipment went down at two o’clock in the morning, we just called an equipment engineer,” and the worker would not complain, said former TSMC joint chief operating officer Chiang Shan-yi (蔣尚義). “We didn’t really do anything special, anything great, but we didn’t make any major mistakes,” when compared with competitors, such
RSS