The election of board directors yesterday at Tatung Co (大同) sparked controversy after the company blocked some institutional and individual shareholders from participating in the general shareholders’ meeting, prompting the Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC) to announce that the vote would be investigated.
Lin Kuo Wen-yen (林郭文艷) was re-elected as chairwoman of the household-appliance maker’s nine-member board, but prior to the vote she announced that several shareholders would not have voting rights.
They were being denied a vote because they had contravened the Business Mergers and Acquisitions Act (企業併購法), and the Act Governing Relations Between the People of the Taiwan Area and the Mainland Area (兩岸人民關係條例), Lin Kuo said.
Photo: Peter Lo, Taipei Times
The company had previously alleged that some investors have received financial backing from Chinese investors.
Tatung management won six director seats and three independent director seats, leaving minority shareholders led by Shanyuan Group (三圓建設) chairman Wang Kuang-hsiang (王光祥) empty-handed.
Tatung’s move took many people by surprise. It was the first time a publicly listed company in Taiwan has blocked shareholders’ voting rights.
Securities and Futures Bureau Deputy Director-General Tsai Li-ling (蔡麗玲) told a news conference in New Taipei City later in the day that the commission would have Taiwan Depository and Clearing Corp (TDCC, 台灣集中保管結算所) investigate whether Tatung had violated shareholders’ rights.
“Only the government has the right to decide whether shareholders have contravened any regulations, not listed companies. Tatung cannot use this as an excuse to take away shareholders’ voting rights,” Tsai said.
If TDCC concludes that Tatung did contravene the Regulations Governing the Administration of Shareholder Services of Public Companies (公開發行股票公司股務處理準則), it would be barred from holding board elections on its own, among other shareholder services, and would have to have such elections run by a third-party, Tsai said.
The Taiwan Stock Exchange has also asked Tatung to explain its decision, Tsai said.
If its explanation is found wanting, the exchange could fine the firm up to NT$5 million (US$168,577) or delist it, she said.
Tatung’s attorney Lai Chung-chiang (賴中強) told an evening news conference that the firm barred 27 shareholders from exercising their voting rights, including eight foreign investors and three firms belonging to Shanyuan Group and an investor surnamed Cheng (鄭), although they together owned a 53 percent stake in the company.
“We took away their rights, as some investors own more than a 10 percent stake, contravening the Business Mergers and Acquisitions Act, and as they aimed to acquire Tatung, but did not provide true information to the government,” Lai said.
The company revoked Cheng’s voting rights after prosecutors questioned whether he helped Chinese investors buy Tatung shares, which would contravene the Act Governing Relations Between the People of the Taiwan Area and the Mainland Area, Lai said.
Many of Tatung’s units, including solar-power generation, construction and publications, are not allowed to accept investment from Chinese investors, so it was important that the firm blocked questionable investors, he said.
“Disputes regarding voting rights should be part of a firm’s self-governance. If an investor cannot accept our move, they can file a lawsuit,” Lai said.
From India to China to the US, automakers cannot make vehicles — not that no one wants any, but because a more than US$450 billion industry for semiconductors got blindsided. How did both sides end up here? Over the past two weeks, automakers across the world have bemoaned the shortage of chips. Germany’s Audi, owned by Volkswagen AG, would delay making some of its high-end vehicles because of what chief executive officer Markus Duesmann called a “massive” shortfall in an interview with the Financial Times. The firm has furloughed more than 10,000 workers and reined in production. That is a further blow
Answering to a reported request by Germany to help address a chip shortage in its auto industry, the Ministry of Economic Affairs (MOEA) yesterday said that it was in talks with domestic chip suppliers. Foreign media over the weekend reported that German Minister of Economic Affairs Peter Altmaier had sent a request to Taipei to ask Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) to cooperate more closely with German automakers to provide microchips and sensors, to bridge a shortage that has emerged over the past few months. The MOEA said that it had not yet received the request and could therefore not elaborate
FOCUS ON FOUNDRIES: An analyst said that some investors would be disappointed because they were expecting a larger announcement of a partnership with TSMC Intel Corp’s incoming chief executive officer Pat Gelsinger on Thursday pledged to regain the company’s lead in chip manufacturing, countering growing calls from some investors to shed that part of its business. “I am confident that the majority of our 2023 products will be manufactured internally,” Gelsinger said. “At the same time, given the breadth of our portfolio, it’s likely that we will expand our use of external foundries for certain technologies and products.” He plans to provide more details after officially taking over the CEO role on Feb. 15, but Gelsinger was clear that Intel is sticking with its once mighty
AWARENESS NEEDED: The central bank urged lenders to know their customers before undertaking business for them and to seek funding in conventional ways The central bank yesterday said that it would take action against four foreign lenders for their involvement in helping companies trade in the deliverable forward market in contravention of foreign-exchange regulations. Some grain merchants newly based in Taiwan have since July 2019 been practicing questionable currency-trading activity, with the help of branches and subsidiaries of six foreign banks, the monetary policymaker told an unscheduled news conference. Affiliated firms as of July last year completed currency-related deals they referred to as trading that totaled US$11 billion, which was not in sync with their real business needs, the central bank said after wrapping up