Witnesses to the initial public offering (IPO) of M17 Entertainment (M17 娛樂集團) got to see a car crash in slow motion.
Earlier this month, the Taiwanese streaming-content player was attempting to list on the New York Stock Exchange, but the debut never happened, prompting road rage from cofounder Jeffrey Huang (黃立成).
It is easy to blame the bankers — and no doubt they deserve to take a certain amount of the hit — but I would argue that M17 should not have tried an IPO, and for this, company management is also responsible.
There are a few companies I think should never have listed.
In Asia, Line Corp and Sea Ltd are on that list. In the US, I would name GoPro Inc, Roku Inc, FitBit Inc and probably even Twitter Inc.
Single-product companies with fragile earnings should stay private or be acquired.
However, founders — and of course venture backers — seem to be a bit too in love with the idea of an IPO. The spotlight of a public listing tends to show the weakness in a business model, with compliance, investor relations and public relations liabilities to boot.
The risk is that the business never really reaches those pre-IPO expectations and the shares slide, but in a decade-long bull market, such cases are the exception. Expect this to change if and when the market turns.
Because there are so many stories of founders who resisted buyouts and went even bigger, the IPO-or-bust philosophy prevails.
In Asia, this is becoming more apparent. Listing rules for Japan’s Mothers bourse mean that a company need only operate for a year and is not required to post profits. The result is dozens of listed companies unready for prime time.
China requires a history of profitability, while Hong Kong does not. A new China Depositary Receipt program would likely waive the profit requirement, because the stock is already listed elsewhere.
The prime candidate right now is unprofitable smartphone maker Xiaomi Corp (小米). Watch this space.
An IPO is not always the most expedient way for venture capitalists to cash out given lock-up periods. An acquisition can give an immediate injection of liquidity, but a buyout is just not as sexy as a listing.
BYPASSING CHINA TARIFFS: In the first five months of this year, Foxconn sent US$4.4bn of iPhones to the US from India, compared with US$3.7bn in the whole of last year Nearly all the iPhones exported by Foxconn Technology Group (富士康科技集團) from India went to the US between March and last month, customs data showed, far above last year’s average of 50 percent and a clear sign of Apple Inc’s efforts to bypass high US tariffs imposed on China. The numbers, being reported by Reuters for the first time, show that Apple has realigned its India exports to almost exclusively serve the US market, when previously the devices were more widely distributed to nations including the Netherlands and the Czech Republic. During March to last month, Foxconn, known as Hon Hai Precision Industry
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) and the University of Tokyo (UTokyo) yesterday announced the launch of the TSMC-UTokyo Lab to promote advanced semiconductor research, education and talent development. The lab is TSMC’s first laboratory collaboration with a university outside Taiwan, the company said in a statement. The lab would leverage “the extensive knowledge, experience, and creativity” of both institutions, the company said. It is located in the Asano Section of UTokyo’s Hongo, Tokyo, campus and would be managed by UTokyo faculty, guided by directors from UTokyo and TSMC, the company said. TSMC began working with UTokyo in 2019, resulting in 21 research projects,
Ashton Hall’s morning routine involves dunking his head in iced Saratoga Spring Water. For the company that sells the bottled water — Hall’s brand of choice for drinking, brushing his teeth and submerging himself — that is fantastic news. “We’re so thankful to this incredible fitness influencer called Ashton Hall,” Saratoga owner Primo Brands Corp’s CEO Robbert Rietbroek said on an earnings call after Hall’s morning routine video went viral. “He really helped put our brand on the map.” Primo Brands, which was not affiliated with Hall when he made his video, is among the increasing number of companies benefiting from influencer
Quanta Computer Inc (廣達) chairman Barry Lam (林百里) yesterday expressed a downbeat view about the prospects of humanoid robots, given high manufacturing costs and a lack of target customers. Despite rising demand and high expectations for humanoid robots, high research-and-development costs and uncertain profitability remain major concerns, Lam told reporters following the company’s annual shareholders’ meeting in Taoyuan. “Since it seems a bit unworthy to use such high-cost robots to do household chores, I believe robots designed for specific purposes would be more valuable and present a better business opportunity,” Lam said Instead of investing in humanoid robots, Quanta has opted to invest
RSS