China might be ill-prepared to take on the fight against the US before the WTO over the way it taxes computer chips, lawyers and analysts here said on Friday.
The US filed a case against China at the WTO on Thursday, demanding that it stop taxing imported chips at higher rates than domestically produced chips. Chinese trade officials and semiconductor industry representatives responded with a mixture of caution and indignation.
"We're very disappointed the American business groups have taken this to the government," said Xu Xiaotian, the chief secretary of the China Semiconductor Industry Association. "But it won't affect us," he added. "We don't think it's a problem."
PHOTO: EPA
Chong Quan, a spokesman for China's Ministry of Commerce, which deals with trade matters, said the ministry was considering the filing and refused to answer further questions.
Some American lawyers and experts based in China described the Chinese government's response to the threat of the WTO case as flatfooted.
"We're in new territory here," said Lawrence Sussman, a tax lawyer with O'Melveny & Myers in Beijing who specializes in China's semiconductor sector. "China needs to take this seriously. They think the US is bluffing, but it's not."
Yet Sussman said there might well be legal precedents under which China could redraw its subsidies to protect them from WTO challenges. "I don't think it's an open and shut case," he added.
The tax policy under challenge was introduced in 2000 and imposes a value-added tax of 17 percent on imported semiconductors of 2.5 microns or less, while chips that are made or designed in China, whether by domestic or foreign companies, receive rebates that give them a 3 percent tax rate.
"If you analyze the costs, China doesn't have any advantages, not in labor or land," said James Hexter, a consultant with Mckinsey in Beijing. "What really brings advantage is the tax benefits."
But even if the tax scheme survives the legal challenge, China might not be able to overcome the technical and managerial hurdles preventing its local chip factories from catching up with advanced American and Taiwanese chipmakers, some Chinese officials and analysts said.
"The gap is quite clear," said an official with China's Ministry of Information Industry, who insisted that his name not be used. "We're at least three to five years behind the Taiwanese manufacturers. The gap is shrinking, but it's still big."
Nonetheless, the Chinese government remains committed to making semiconductors a key domestic industry by the end of the decade, the official added.
"It's developed into a high-profile, strategic industry," Hexter said of China's chip industry. "Any individual fab may not recover costs," he added, referring to the factories that make semiconductors to order, "but China has such potential as a high-tech powerhouse, it makes sense."
The Semiconductor Industry Association, based in San Jose, California, which lobbied Washington to take action against China's tax program, points to 19 new semiconductor plants that are scheduled to be built in China by 2008.
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電) on Wednesday said that a new chip manufacturing technology called “A16” is to enter production in the second half of 2026, setting up a showdown with longtime rival Intel over who can make the fastest chips. TSMC, the world’s biggest contract manufacturer of advanced computing chips and a key supplier to Nvidia and Apple, announced the news at a conference in Santa Clara, California, where TSMC executives said that makers of artificial intelligence (AI) chips will likely be the first adopters of the technology rather than a smartphone maker. Analysts said that the technologies announced on
NO RECIPROCITY: Taipei has called for cross-strait group travel to resume fully, but Beijing is only allowing people from its Fujian Province to travel to Matsu, the MAC said The Mainland Affairs Council (MAC) yesterday criticized an announcement by the Chinese Ministry of Culture and Tourism that it would lift a travel ban to Taiwan only for residents of China’s Fujian Province, saying that the policy does not meet the principles of reciprocity and openness. Chinese Deputy Minister of Culture and Tourism Rao Quan (饒權) yesterday morning told a delegation of Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) lawmakers in a meeting in Beijing that the ministry would first allow Fujian residents to visit Lienchiang County (Matsu), adding that they would be able to travel to Taiwan proper directly once express ferry
CALL FOR DIALOGUE: The president-elect urged Beijing to engage with Taiwan’s ‘democratically elected and legitimate government’ to promote peace President-elect William Lai (賴清德) yesterday named the new heads of security and cross-strait affairs to take office after his inauguration on May 20, including National Security Council (NSC) Secretary-General Wellington Koo (顧立雄) to be the new defense minister and former Taichung mayor Lin Chia-lung (林佳龍) as minister of foreign affairs. While Koo is to head the Ministry of National Defense and presidential aide Lin is to take over as minister of foreign affairs, Tsai Ming-yen (蔡明彥) would be retained as the nation’s intelligence chief, continuing to serve as director-general of the National Security Bureau, Lai told a news conference in Taipei. Koo,
MANAGING DIFFERENCES: In a meeting days after the US president signed a massive foreign aid bill, Antony Blinken raised concerns with the Chinese president about Taiwan US Secretary of State Antony Blinken yesterday met with Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) and senior Chinese officials, stressing the importance of “responsibly managing” the differences between the US and China as the two sides butt heads over a number of contentious bilateral, regional and global issues, including Taiwan and the South China Sea. Talks between the two sides have increased over the past few months, even as differences have grown. Blinken said he raised concerns with Xi about Taiwan and the South China Sea, along with China’s support for Russia and its invasion of Ukraine, as well as other issues