Illegal but often tolerated, caning is rife in India’s school system, but the recent suicide of a 12-year-old pupil after a beating has brought the practice out of the shadows.
Rouvanjit Rawla, a pupil at the prestigious La Martiniere for Boys school in the eastern city of Kolkata, hanged himself in his room earlier this year after being caned for bringing stink bombs into class.
After spending months chasing the school for answers, his father, textile businessman Ajay Rawla, finally filed a police complaint against three teachers last month and is determined to press for justice.
PHOTO: AFP
“We were a jolly, happy family,” he said. “Just go onto Rouvan’s Facebook page and every one of his friends has called him a fun and friendly young boy. He used to be the life of the party.”
Mental health groups point out that suicides can rarely be attributed to a single reason, but Rawla is in no doubt that the caning by the school principal was the factor that pushed his son over the edge.
“These people are teachers. They are supposed to make your children better, stronger people, not drive them to death,” he said by telephone from Kolkata, fighting back tears.
A Supreme Court judgment in 2000 prohibited corporal punishment in all its forms in India. The Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, passed last year, also bans corporal punishment.
But as is often the case in India, the gap between liberal and well-meaning laws passed by the distant federal government in New Delhi and enforcement in local areas is huge.
According to a UN Children’s Fund (UNICEF) report published in 2008, two out of three schoolchildren in India said they had been subjected to corporal punishment.
The practice is particularly prevalent in government-run schools, where the vast majority of cases (62 percent) were reported.
Lov Verma, secretary of the National Commission for Protection of Child Rights, says caning, beatings and slappings are still prevalent in schools all across the country.
“We cannot shut our eyes to the reality, we get umpteen cases of corporal punishment [reported to us]. Laws are there but that does not mean it is not happening,” he said.
A government study conducted by the Ministry of Women and Child Welfare Development in 2008 mirrored the UN findings: Two out of three children across 13 states had been victims of corporal punishment.
The reasons are multiple: cultural attitudes to violence, which are changing slowly in cities but remain entrenched in rural areas; lack of training for teachers; and large class sizes that make pupils hard to control.
Within the teaching profession, attitudes vary. Most schoolteachers publicly disavow violence.
“Most private schools in Delhi have greatly reduced corporal punishment, caning, being hit by the ruler, etc,” Springdales high school principal Jyoti Bose said. “It is all very old generation. We have to learn to negotiate and engage with the child.”
Herod Mullick, general secretary of Bongiyo Christiyo Porisheba, an umbrella organization of 700 Christian missionary schools in Kolkata, says some teachers resort to violence out of desperation.
“You do not allow caning and you do not have a proper procedure in place for counseling or other forms of disciplining, so both the children and teachers are lost in the matter,” he said.
Rounjit Rawla’s case has brought about a huge public outcry, largely because the case occurred in one of India’s oldest and most elite schools and to a middle class family. But as the UN and government of India research underlined, most cases of corporal punishment take place in public schools and go largely unrecorded and unheard off.
“India pampers its richer children and pedigree dogs; most of the kids in most schools are unprotected by society and state,” Supreme Court lawyer Rajeev Dhavan wrote in a column in the Mail Today newspaper.
The national bout of introspection also prompted Bollywood legend Amitabh Bachchan to recall his childhood experience of beatings at the hands of teachers.
“There was not a single year when our principal did not practice his Cambridge Blue tennis forehand on our bent-over posteriors,” Bachchan wrote on his blog.
“That was 1956; it is 2010 now,” Bachchan said. “Times have changed and so have circumstances.”
For Rouvanjit’s father in Kolkata, times did not change fast enough.
“As a father I need answers to my son’s death and I will fight till the end to get justice for Rouvan,” Rawla said.
FRUSTRATIONS: One in seven youths in China and Indonesia are unemployed, and many in the region are stuck in low-productivity jobs, the World Bank said Young people across Asia are struggling to find good jobs, with many stuck in low-productivity work that the World Bank said could strain social stability as frustrations fuel a global wave of youth-led protests. The bank highlighted a persistent gap between younger and more experienced workers across several Asian economies in a regional economic update released yesterday, noting that one in seven young people in China and Indonesia are unemployed. The share of people now vulnerable to falling into poverty is now larger than the middle class in most countries, it said. “The employment rate is generally high, but the young struggle to
STEPPING UP: Diminished US polar science presence mean opportunities for the UK and other countries, although China or Russia might also fill that gap, a researcher said The UK’s flagship polar research vessel is to head to Antarctica next week to help advance dozens of climate change-linked science projects, as Western nations spearhead studies there while the US withdraws. The RRS Sir David Attenborough, a state-of-the-art ship named after the renowned British naturalist, would aid research on everything from “hunting underwater tsunamis” to tracking glacier melt and whale populations. Operated by the British Antarctic Survey (BAS), the country’s polar research institute, the 15,000-tonne icebreaker — boasting a helipad, and various laboratories and gadgetry — is pivotal to the UK’s efforts to assess climate change’s impact there. “The saying goes
ENERGY SHIFT: A report by Ember suggests it is possible for the world to wean off polluting sources of power, such as coal and gas, even as demand for electricity surges Worldwide solar and wind power generation has outpaced electricity demand this year, and for the first time on record, renewable energies combined generated more power than coal, a new analysis said. Global solar generation grew by a record 31 percent in the first half of the year, while wind generation grew 7.7 percent, according to the report by the energy think tank Ember, which was released after midnight yesterday. Solar and wind generation combined grew by more than 400 terawatt hours, which was more than the increase in overall global demand during the same period, it said. The findings suggest it is
TICKING CLOCK: A path to a budget agreement was still possible, the president’s office said, as a debate on reversing an increase of the pension age carries on French President Emmanuel Macron yesterday was racing to find a new prime minister within a two-day deadline after the resignation of outgoing French Prime Minister Sebastien Lecornu tipped the country deeper into political crisis. The presidency late on Wednesday said that Macron would name a new prime minister within 48 hours, indicating that the appointment would come by this evening at the latest. Lecornu told French television in an interview that he expected a new prime minister to be named — rather than early legislative elections or Macron’s resignation — to resolve the crisis. The developments were the latest twists in three tumultuous
RSS