Sun, Oct 19, 2008 - Page 7 News List

Uighurs pose risk to US: court papers

IN LIMBO The 17 detainees, who were cleared of their ‘enemy combatant’ status in 2003, would serve as living reminders of Guantanamo Bay blunders, one expert said


The Bush administration believes the 17 Chinese Muslim Uighurs detained at the Guantanamo Bay prison camp should not be released into the US because they pose a “risk distinct to this nation,” court documents obtained by reporters on Friday showed.

The potential risks, said the US Justice Department, were compounded by the fact “that petitioners were detained for six years by the country to which the district court has ordered them brought.”

A federal judge last week ordered that the group be released and brought before him in ­Washington — an historic ruling where, for the first time, a court ordered that “war on terror” prisoners detained at the US Navy-run prison in Cuba should be released onto US soil.

The US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia halted the process a day after the ruling, to give the US Justice Department time to prepare an appeal.

“Most of these aliens were detained after attending or traveling to, terrorist training camps,” read the US government’s appeal, filed late on Thursday. “The district court’s order could also make it more difficult for the government to negotiate with third countries over resettlement.”

The group has been held in limbo at Guantanamo — despite being cleared of “enemy combatant” status in 2003 and cleared for release in 2004 by the US government — because officials cannot find a country willing to take them. The men cannot be returned to China due to concerns they would be tortured there as political dissidents.

The Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR), which has defended many of the Uighurs in court, said on Friday it was a “baseless assertion” that the prisoners were too dangerous to be released into the US.

“It would be ironic if this were true, since the government exonerated these men as long ago as 2003 and has been trying to resettle them with our closest allies since then,” the CCR said in a statement.

On Wednesday the New York Times reported that the Uighur case had become a focus of many Guantanamo critics.

“The true fear is not that they will pose a security threat,” Jennifer Daskal, a counterterrorism specialist at Human Rights Watch, told the newspaper.

Rather, if the group was released, they would “serve as living reminders of the administration’s mistakes in setting up Guan­tanamo,” she said.

The Uighurs were living in a self-contained camp in Afghanistan when the US-led coalition bombing campaign began in October 2001. They fled to the mountains, but were turned over to Pakistani authorities, who then handed them to the US.

Beijing has urged Washington to repatriate the group, alleging they were members of the East Turkestan Islamic Movement “which has been listed as a terrorist organization by the UN Security Council.”

“China has urged the US to repatriate these Chinese terrorist suspects to China on many occasions,” Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Qin Gang (秦剛) said last Tuesday.

For years the US has attempted to persuade other countries to ­resettle the group, recognizing that the Turkic-speaking minority has been widely persecuted by Chinese authorities.

Only Albania has agreed to take the Uighurs, welcoming a group of five in 2006, who now live far from their homes with no possibility of returning to their families any time soon.

The White House immediately condemned the federal judge’s ruling last week, saying it paved the way for extremists to demand the same freedom.

This story has been viewed 2043 times.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top